Carpet anemone

Kapachuka3

Valuable Member
View Badges
Joined
Nov 17, 2020
Messages
1,109
Reaction score
550
Location
United States
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I have a clownfish, 3 pajama cardinals, 1 ywg, snails, fire shrimp, 2 conchs, and a pincushion urchin. Tank is 32.5 gallons and I was wondering if I could possibly have a carpet anemone in this tank. No coral but I think it would look cool. Could somebody give me info on how hard these guys are to take care of. Special lighting? Will it hurt any of my inverts? And if it dies will it nuke my tank?
thanks.
 
I have a clownfish, 3 pajama cardinals, 1 ywg, snails, fire shrimp, 2 conchs, and a pincushion urchin. Tank is 32.5 gallons and I was wondering if I could possibly have a carpet anemone in this tank. No coral but I think it would look cool. Could somebody give me info on how hard these guys are to take care of. Special lighting? Will it hurt any of my inverts? And if it dies will it nuke my tank?
thanks.
Serious lighting, mature tank and ability to treat with cipro are the main things I think. @Eagle_Steve @OrionN @F i s h y @Nemguy123
 
Ok, what types of lighting? Cause I just bought a new light for my tank cause the old one died.
Let the experts weigh in. However I'm pretty sure you need more than what SPS require.
 
Whatever you recommend, I really no next to nothing on anemones. Whatever is easiest to take care of.
Mags and gigs would not be the place to start on anemone. They have the highest requirements. BTA, LTA and RFA are a better starting point. Par of at least 150, mature tank of at least 6 months, closer to a year is better, and stable, acceptable parameters.
 
Carpet (haddoni being assumed) can be kept in a 32 gallon tank. I had one in my biocube for quite a while. Other can as well, but going to be a bit more challenging, as Gigs are usually higher light as are Mertens.

Lighting: Will need to be able to put at least 200 par on the nem.(If a haddoni)

Nutrients: All of my carpets like stability. I run my tanks from 8-9 alk, 400-440 calcium (doesnt really matter for a nem, but helps with overall stability), 1350-1400 mag, 5-10 No3 and -.08-.1 Po4. You can keep NO3 and PO4 lower, but it needs to be available, dinos from no nutrients seriously tick nems off.

Filtration: You will need good filtration. You want the water to be clean. Carbon is your friend.

Flow: You will want ample random flow. You will also want to put covers on any powerheads, just in case.

Sand: You will need sand for a sand burrowing nem like a haddoni. Gigs and Mertens do fine on rocks.

Stability: Tank will need to be stable. ATO is a must, as it allows for salinity to stay constant.

Care: The nem does not need to be fed. They do fine with just light and whatever a clown may drop in them. Especially in a smaller tank. They will grow very quickly when fed. I say stability again, as this is very important.

In all honesty, if I was to do a nem dedicated tank in a 32, I would do BTA, like I am going now. Much hardier, will reproduce and fill up the tank in time and a little more forgiving.
 
Mags and gigs would not be the place to start on anemone. They have the highest requirements. BTA, LTA and RFA are a better starting point. Par of at least 150, mature tank of at least 6 months, closer to a year is better, and stable, acceptable parameters.
Cooll my tank is very mature actually. It’s been up For about two years I believe. What’s PAR?
 
I will also add, with a carpet, you want a tank at least a year old, growing coraline (as it shows some stability), and micro fauna being present. (little feather dusters, pods, etc, as they show a healthy tank)
 
Cooll my tank is very mature actually. It’s been up For about two years I believe. What’s PAR?
Par is the general term used for how much usable lighting your lights provide. Which light did you just get?
 
These things require perfect water, (nitrates below 10, no nitrites, and no ammonia). They require intense lighting - think under radions, a Kessil a500x, MH, etc. They require good water movement over the top. Excellent and stable salinity. They will care about your trace elements, alkalinity, and PH must be solid with minimal day and night swings.

Take all that and factor in the fact that they can can take weeks-to-months to die and that it was probably smuggled in on an international flight from overseas.


These anemones should only be kept by a select few who have some level of knowledge, instincts, and experience and kept as rescues. The rest of us should stop buying them so that it no longer becomes profitable to import and sell them.

I’m tired of the “yeah but I kept one in a leaky shoebox and the only light I used was a lightbrite with 50 purple and 20 red pegs and I kept it alive for 10 years back in the 80’s.”

These are not suitable creatures for home aquariums in the same way a penguin, raccoon, or cheetah is a good house pet. Quoting anecdotes and YouTube clips of cute fuzzy lions playing with kids isn’t proof of success either.

Go out and throw a couple thousand dollars of equipment and life support at your tank or find someone locally who can or has experience.

Also factor in that the specific animal’s needs will also vary and there are so many factors to consider and questions you will never have answers to unless you find the poacher who scooped it up and sold it.
 
Well, carpets require a lot of maturity on the tank (stability, nutrients, bacterias, planktons). Many get really large so the 32g will limit the carpet type.
Have you considered a BTA (bubble tip anemone)? They tend to be a bit easier and you said no coral, so no issues with stinging. These will still require good lighting (MH,T5 or good LED).
If you are set on carpet, research the LTA (Macrodactyla doreensis). They are smaller but require a good level of sand.
 
These things require perfect water, (nitrates below 10, no nitrites, and no ammonia). They require intense lighting - think under radions, a Kessil a500x, MH, etc. They require good water movement over the top. Excellent and stable salinity. They will care about your trace elements, alkalinity, and PH must be solid with minimal day and night swings.

Take all that and factor in the fact that they can can take weeks-to-months to die and that it was probably smuggled in on an international flight from overseas.


These anemones should only be kept by a select few who have some level of knowledge, instincts, and experience and kept as rescues. The rest of us should stop buying them so that it no longer becomes profitable to import and sell them.

I’m tired of the “yeah but I kept one in a leaky shoebox and the only light I used was a lightbrite with 50 purple and 20 red pegs and I kept it alive for 10 years back in the 80’s.”

These are not suitable creatures for home aquariums in the same way a penguin, raccoon, or cheetah is a good house pet. Quoting anecdotes and YouTube clips of cute fuzzy lions playing with kids isn’t proof of success either.

Go out and throw a couple thousand dollars of equipment and life support at your tank or find someone locally who can or has experience.

Also factor in that the specific animal’s needs will also vary and there are so many factors to consider and questions you will never have answers to unless you find the poacher who scooped it up and sold it.
Dude thanks for telling me that. I feel the same way about starfish and certain inverts and fish. Did not know they were not captive bred. I won’t bother with them now. I think I’ll just get another clownfish. Thanks.
 
Dude thanks for telling me that. I feel the same way about starfish and certain inverts and fish. Did not know they were not captive bred. I won’t bother with them now. I think I’ll just get another clownfish. Thanks.
With proper care, you can keep a carpet with no issues. You just have to dedicate the tank to the nem and not add the nem to the tank.

Once you own a nem, it is the tank, so to speak. All other critters are secondary, as the nem will more than likely be the most sensitive.

As for nems being shipped, I just received a very large order and the collection practices have improved a lot. They also ship them in more water now, which they did not used to.

Just food for thought, but if you do not want to put complete dedication for the carpet, go with some BTAs from a local reefer. They are already adapted to tank life, provide great movement in the tank and once established can be the focus of the tank.
 
With proper care, you can keep a carpet with no issues. You just have to dedicate the tank to the nem and not add the nem to the tank.

Once you own a nem, it is the tank, so to speak. All other critters are secondary, as the nem will more than likely be the most sensitive.

As for nems being shipped, I just received a very large order and the collection practices have improved a lot. They also ship them in more water now, which they did not used to.

Just food for thought, but if you do not want to put complete dedication for the carpet, go with some BTAs from a local reefer. They are already adapted to tank life, provide great movement in the tank and once established can be the focus of the tank.
Ok, thanks. BTA’s are fairly easy to take care for? I just dont want to have alot to care for. I know I sound lazy but I just Want something cool for my tank. Will it nuke my tank if it dies?
 
Ok, thanks. BTA’s are fairly easy to take care for? I just dont want to have alot to care for. I know I sound lazy but I just Want something cool for my tank. Will it nuke my tank if it dies?
Any nem can nuke a tank if it dies. Luckily there are signs of a nem going south.

I will say, laziness is never good with any nem. Even the simplest of nems require excellent care. With that said, if you want 0 interaction to ensure the nem stays healthy, then best not to get a nem.
 
Ok, thanks. BTA’s are fairly easy to take care for? I just dont want to have alot to care for. I know I sound lazy but I just Want something cool for my tank. Will it nuke my tank if it dies?
Before going on to step 3 let's circle back to step 1 and make sure you have the proper lighting that will be required.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%

New Posts

Back
Top