Interesting topic with a lot of good opinions so far.
Personally, there are tons of chalices out there that do nothing for me, mainly the mottled color types, like the acid trip, melting pot, etc...It's not the high $ amount either that turned me off to them, I just don't think they look all that special and I definitely do not want to have to wait ~10 years just to see it take on a couple colors that it's "supposed" to have. For example, look at that chalice WWC just posted labeled as "the best chalice ever", sugar mama or whatever it's called. That coral really does nothing for me. Sure it looks cool and the mother colony is pretty impressive in it's own right, but honestly I could see that coral taking FOREEVERRR for a small frag to even come close to looking like that mother colony..
I really prefer the classic, hardy, more proven pieces. I'm also a big fan of the watermelon type chalices, the mummy eye variations and few pieces like the flamethrower, Golden G, orange Immolation, orange sherbet, atl pink mojito are amazing as well. I like chalices with sharp, contrasting colors with larger, bright eyes and a defined rim color is a plus as well. Currently, my Bazooka Joe is the favorite coral in my tank, the thing is just unreal looking and it's so hardy as well.
It comes down to different strokes for different folks, obviously not everyone is going to have the same tastes in coral. IMO, one of the biggest things that makes chalices so awesome is the myriad of different types and color combination's available.(I'm still a stickhead at heart though :tongue
