Don't want to trust a heater anymore

salttanklife

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Mar 25, 2014
Messages
260
Reaction score
89
Location
Augusta Georgia
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
My JBJ 30 runs at 75.4° without a heater in it. The two return pumps and my WaveMaker keeps it at this temperature. In the last couple of months, I've been through 3 heaters. 1 was sending a shock through the tank and the other 2 I got lucky and caught the temp going up because thermostat broke and they got stuck on. Every heater I've ever had has never been accurate on the temperature selector. In order to keep my tank at 78°, I have to set the heater to 72°. I've always used the Aqueon pro heaters because I like the fact of them not being glass. My question is, I've only got to raise my temperature 3°, what's a good way (if any) to achieve this without the need of a heater?
 
I will never run a heater without a controller. All heaters will fail.....and the fail that is dangerous to the livestock is "stuck ON." A controller will save you from a stuck ON heater. So if you don't have a fancy controller, like Apex, at a minimum, pick up a Ranco.

As far as heaters, I've always preferred Eheim Jager's. Their glass is twice as thick. The only down side is that they are long.
 
I will never run a heater without a controller. All heaters will fail.....and the fail that is dangerous to the livestock is "stuck ON." A controller will save you from a stuck ON heater. So if you don't have a fancy controller, like Apex, at a minimum, pick up a Ranco.

As far as heaters, I've always preferred Eheim Jager's. Their glass is twice as thick. The only down side is that they are long.

+1+1+1+1
 
I haven't broke down and got a controller yet but it'll have to be one of the next things on my list for sure. I believe I'm just going to have to ditch the Aqueon heaters until I get one.
 
+1 on the controller it's worth every penny. You can probably get yourself a used apex pretty easy now too. I've never used the Aqueon heaters but may be better to look into something more reliable...that said all heaters fail.
 
I got lucky again yesterday and noticed my temperature going up. My blasto and clam wasn't looking happy when my lights was on for about a hour. I checked my temperature and it was 84.5. My tank never fluctuates more than .3° when my heater is working properly and is between 78.5/78.8°.

I took my skimmer off a few months ago for two reasons. 1) I've got sps, lps, Zoas, and mushrooms in my tank. The water was staying to clean for my zoas and shoots. 2) it's a hob skimmer and I had it overflow twice on me while sleeping and caused my ATO to empty out into the tank and soak my floor. First time my salinity went from 1.025 to 1.020, The second from 1.025 to 1.023. When the skimmer in, I didn't need the heater because the extra pump keep it at 78°.

I might just buy a skimmer that goes in the rear compartment and just feed the tank more to avoid the heater all together.
 
Product Details
Inkbird Temperature Controller 306 Pre-Wired Dual Stage Thermostat & Timer Time Switch Only Heating for Reptile, Seedling Heating Mat, Germination,Planting, Aquariums, ect.AC 100~240V,1200W
$29.99
5 out of 5 stars (2)
Great controllers
Great price
 
Product Details
Inkbird Temperature Controller 306 Pre-Wired Dual Stage Thermostat & Timer Time Switch Only Heating for Reptile, Seedling Heating Mat, Germination,Planting, Aquariums, ect.AC 100~240V,1200W
$29.99
5 out of 5 stars (2)
Great controllers
Great price
This seems like a good option but is it a constant on and off of the heater and fan? Or would I even need the fan for the cooling side? Will it just shut the heater off at the programed temperature and restart in when it drops below?


I just looked up the Apex and it seems like the Apex Jr would fit my needs and it's not really in the take a 2nd mortgage out on the house price range
 
This always worried me also. I have a heater with controller. Bought first. Then bought apex. So I have my controller plugged into my apex. So have double coverage.
 
I got lucky again yesterday and noticed my temperature going up. My blasto and clam wasn't looking happy when my lights was on for about a hour. I checked my temperature and it was 84.5. My tank never fluctuates more than .3° when my heater is working properly and is between 78.5/78.8°.

I took my skimmer off a few months ago for two reasons. 1) I've got sps, lps, Zoas, and mushrooms in my tank. The water was staying to clean for my zoas and shoots. 2) it's a hob skimmer and I had it overflow twice on me while sleeping and caused my ATO to empty out into the tank and soak my floor. First time my salinity went from 1.025 to 1.020, The second from 1.025 to 1.023. When the skimmer in, I didn't need the heater because the extra pump keep it at 78°.

I might just buy a skimmer that goes in the rear compartment and just feed the tank more to avoid the heater all together.
Take the money from the new skimmer and buy a used Apex. Then you can not only provide protection for your heater, but you can set it to only run your skimmer 4 or 5 hours a day. ;)
 
Honestly, you are probably fine running the tank at 75*F. I run my between 75 and 77*F, and all my acros, fish, and inverts including my maxima clam are fine. Many reefs around the world normally experience water temperatures in this range.
 
I used a temp controller before I got my apex. It was just a cheap inkbird
 
I would find one with a non-metal probe. These metal, even the stainless steel, probes corrode in salt water within a year. I don't know the side effect of that beside buying a new probe.....Not worthy IMHO.


Product Details
Inkbird Temperature Controller 306 Pre-Wired Dual Stage Thermostat & Timer Time Switch Only Heating for Reptile, Seedling Heating Mat, Germination,Planting, Aquariums, ect.AC 100~240V,1200W
$29.99
5 out of 5 stars (2)
Great controllers
Great price
 
Product Details
Inkbird Temperature Controller 306 Pre-Wired Dual Stage Thermostat & Timer Time Switch Only Heating for Reptile, Seedling Heating Mat, Germination,Planting, Aquariums, ect.AC 100~240V,1200W
$29.99
5 out of 5 stars (2)
Great controllers
Great price

Inkbirds are amazing I wouldnt have a tank without one, and for 30$ nonetheless. anything in this hobby for under 100$ is a steal IMO, not to mention under 100$ and works properly.

The inkbird is a process controller so it will "learn" what combos of heat and cool to use in order to stabilize the tank, my tank runs warm so only the fan kicks on every once in a while. I'm sure once it gets tuned in it will almost always be off.

Also one thing to keep in mind...Apex controllers are great, no one will deny that, but if you are on a budget 549.99$ is a hard pill to swallow. Even if your 30$ inkbird Probe corrodes after a year or two its 30$. You could buy a new inkbird once a year for FIFTEEN YEARS and still come up 100$ short of the cheapest Apex
 
Last edited:
Many many options based on how much your willing to spend.
Titanium heater and a heater controller is a minimum for safety.
Apex or other controllers are the best for redundancy and to notify you if things go wrong and ur away.
Also external temp controller can be connected to control heaters and another one to ring and alarm if water temp rises. You can also use one to trigger a phone call to your number. Some chillers also have a heating function through a heat blower...
heating coils hooked to a controller, usually for larger tanks. Titanium heater exchangers linked to home heating pipes, also intended for larger setups.
 
I will never run a heater without a controller. All heaters will fail.....and the fail that is dangerous to the livestock is "stuck ON." A controller will save you from a stuck ON heater. So if you don't have a fancy controller, like Apex, at a minimum, pick up a Ranco.

As far as heaters, I've always preferred Eheim Jager's. Their glass is twice as thick. The only down side is that they are long.
+1 on the Eheim. Aqueon is crap
 
I trust glass heaters zero! I trust heaters alone zero. I trust a good heater on a controller 100%!
 
I use a finnex controller with eheim heater. Controller was $40.
I also have an inkbird I diyed for my quarantine tanks.
I'd Recommend either
 
I feel the same as you. I dont use a heater, dont need to.

Simplest way to increase temp is to put a lid on the tank, or add another powerhead or light.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top