Don't want to trust a heater anymore

I will never trust a heater alone. That said I have had two Aqueon Pro heaters in my tank for 3 1/2 years without any problems at all. Apex is the way to go!
 
If I'm allowed to recomend a store? Premium Aquatics has good prices onEheim Jager's heaters. Also the Masstick food you mix and put in tank for fish to munch, recommended on this site is back in stock.
 
I use a finnex controller with eheim heater. Controller was $40.
I also have an inkbird I diyed for my quarantine tanks.
I'd Recommend either
Which Finnex controller are you using ?
 
Which Finnex controller are you using ?
This one: https://premiumaquatics.com/produc...Y7JLeg2oUT1xzr4sosWBpBudF7sygj2_NxoC4Ufw_wcB
2ae07c54f0c48b7c9c15ee9255d107df.jpg
 
You can get the basic RKL from Digital Aquatics to control the heater. It is upgradeable when you want to expand it.
 
You can also use 2 smaller heaters and not worry if one sticks on. I have a 125 gallon with a 20 gallon sump and use 2 200 watt heaters to raise the temp about 10 degrees on average in the winter. If one sticks on the temp will rise about 2 degrees!!! If one fails the temp will drop the same 2 degrees. Crazy, but it works. I also have a temp meter with an alarm just to keep an eye on things. Never tested the setup with both heaters stuck on though. But that would be a rare problem (I hope)!!!
 
Last edited:
This seems like a good option but is it a constant on and off of the heater and fan? Or would I even need the fan for the cooling side? Will it just shut the heater off at the programed temperature and restart in when it drops below?


I just looked up the Apex and it seems like the Apex Jr would fit my needs and it's not really in the take a 2nd mortgage out on the house price range

The 306 will not control cooling devices like a fan. (Well I guess they could turn it on, but only when the aquarium gets cool - the opposite of what you intend.) It's intended to control heating devices only. The 308 will do both, and is just a few dollars more. So far mine has been reliable over the last year or so, but there is a downside.

When the temperature gets outside of the parameters you set, it turns on an alarm. That's actually a good feature as you get the audible alert that something is wrong. What it took me a while to figure out is that once the alarm is going off, it disables itself as a failsafe. In order to get it back working, you have to reprogram the alarm to make the controller work. If that was hard to follow, here's the scenario:

Controller is set to turn heater on when the temperature drops below 75 and stay on until temperature reaches 77. Power goes out and temperature drops (or heater stops working, can't keep up, whatever). Power comes back on and temperature is below 72 (or wherever you set the alarm parameter at). Controller sounds alarm , but does not send power to heater. (I guess it does this in case the controller itself might have failed.) You have to go into the program and reset the alarm to be lower than whatever the current tank temperature is so it will send power to the heater. You can off course reprogram back to your original alarm point as the water warms back up. I wish you could set the cutoff point to be different than the alarm point, but I guess this thing just isn't that sophisticated.

I don't use mine with any cooling devices, but I have to assume it would work the same way. I do have an alarm for too high of a temperature.
 
You can also use 2 smaller heaters and not worry if one sticks on. I have a 125 gallon with a 20 gallon sump and use 2 200 watt heaters to raise the temp about 10 degrees on average in the winter. If one sticks on the temp will rise about 2 degrees!!! If one fails the temp will drop the same 2 degrees. Crazy, but it works. I also have a temp meter with an alarm just to keep an eye on things. Never tested the setup with both heaters stuck on though. But that would be a rare problem (I hope)!!!

It looks like you could use the Inkbird 306 to control multiple heaters like this.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top