Again, to use my own rip-clean as an example. My scape is composed of 20-25 pieces of individual rocks, some glued together and some freestanding. All of this rock was cycled at the same time.
If the rock in the test example is simply broken up into pieces, that would most definitely amplify the surface area. However, the new exposed surfaces would not have the bacterial colonies that the exterior areas have. The newly broken up rock would need to be "seasoned" so that all of the surface area available has a supply of the bacteria. Then each small piece would have to be scrubbed under hot running tap water. I am curious if the rocks were broken up this way and then placed back into the sump for a week or 2, if that would be enough time to create the colonies on the required amount of surface area to replicate the test to mimic the results of my Rip-clean, which after all is what I believe the OP is attempting.