Effects of tap water on Nitrifying during Rip-Clean method: Experiment

I think there are some very easy things that could be done. Mainly just documenting that he has a good ammonia kit. I think the rest is fine.
So just make a stock calibration solution and test that?
 
ou do need to verify that the background ammonia before starting is correct (i.e. make sure your test is reading correctly) - which is why I suggested duplicate tests.
Are you sure - if it reads wrong but you do not perform the rinse before it is zero - it will read as wrong the second time but 0 is the reference point and OP will confirm it with nitrite test and following nitrate test, This is a batch test.

Sincerely Lasse
 
Thanks - I read it as 10 minutes. It might be good to get input from @brandon429 - what the average rinse time should be. And BTW - what Brandon said above - is true - you do need to verify that the background ammonia before starting is correct (i.e. make sure your test is reading correctly) - which is why I suggested duplicate tests.


I'll see if I can do that. I know that it reads zero on my tank water. After my tank move it did read .2 NH3+NH4. So .02 NH3.

But I'll try to add a lower known amount of Dr. Tim's to a gallon and do some tests.
 
Again, to use my own rip-clean as an example. My scape is composed of 20-25 pieces of individual rocks, some glued together and some freestanding. All of this rock was cycled at the same time.

If the rock in the test example is simply broken up into pieces, that would most definitely amplify the surface area. However, the new exposed surfaces would not have the bacterial colonies that the exterior areas have. The newly broken up rock would need to be "seasoned" so that all of the surface area available has a supply of the bacteria. Then each small piece would have to be scrubbed under hot running tap water. I am curious if the rocks were broken up this way and then placed back into the sump for a week or 2, if that would be enough time to create the colonies on the required amount of surface area to replicate the test to mimic the results of my Rip-clean, which after all is what I believe the OP is attempting.
Thanks!
 
The setup is fail proof - IMO - first he test and let the rock pieces adapt its nitrifying biomass to a certain load. If it does not direct convert the added ammonia into nitrate (and he/she measure nitrite too). The OP will wait until the biomass is high enough to process the same load again. At that moment OP will clean the rocks with fresh water and repeat the stress test.

The only concern I have is the aquarium itself and maybe the water but if it is a rather particle free water - its maybe enough to take out the saltwater - clean even the aquarium with fresh water - put back the salt water and the cleaned rocks

Go for it

Sincerely Lasse


Yes, I plan to use new water and clean the tank and equipment in between.
 
Are you sure - if it reads wrong but you do not perform the rinse before it is zero - it will read as wrong the second time but 0 is the reference point

Sincerely Lasse
Sorry - I wasn't clear - I mean document the ammonia with an accurate test in step 1. (make sure there are no expired reagents, etc and the test is being done correctly).
 
Yes, I plan to use new water and clean the tank and equipment in between.
PS - one thing to be a little aware of. When you are adding water add a measured amount - and then make sure you top it off with RODI - in case it takes longer to process ammonia than planned. For example - add 4 gallons exactly then put the rock in. It will make it easier to add the exact amount of ammonia each time.
 
PS - one thing to be a little aware of. When you are adding water add a measured amount - and then make sure you top it off with RODI - in case it takes longer to process ammonia than planned. For example - add 4 gallons exactly then put the rock in. It will make it easier to add the exact amount of ammonia each time.


Yes, I used a clean gallon jug that I measured with a measuring cup to get an exact 4 gallons. I also have a water line on the tank so I can top with rodi when needed.

16357192041832257953605946047812.jpg
 
Yes, I used a clean gallon jug that I measured with a measuring cup to get an exact 4 gallons. I also have a water line on the tank so I can top with rodi when needed.

16357192041832257953605946047812.jpg
Sorry I thought of something else - thats easy. I would measure pH when you measure the total ammonia - so that there will be an idea of 'free ammonia' as well as total
 
last tweak for the re test:

after completing this re assessment, repeat the steps with equal degree of rocks not rinsed at all, true cured rocks, show them passing oxidation using the same methods. if you do that/solid job.

you have to make this arrangement pass using that control for us to get the most input from the test. use the same approximate amount of cured rocks for the re re verification step.
 
last tweak for the re test:

after completing this re assessment, repeat the steps with equal degree of rocks not rinsed at all, true cured rocks, show them passing oxidation using the same methods. if you do that/solid job.

you have to make this arrangement pass using that control for us to get the most input from the test. use the same approximate amount of cured rocks for the re re verification step.


You are more than welcome to run your own test and show your results. I would love see them.

But unless some wants to pay me for this the test will be run as stated.
 
Sorry I thought of something else - thats easy. I would measure pH when you measure the total ammonia - so that there will be an idea of 'free ammonia' as well as total


I can do that.
 
You didn’t see a need to show the arrangement could work at all given non rinsed rocks? Still invalid. That’s leaving a cliffhanger

No I won’t be testing I use real reefs, such as yours, for the outcome tracking. this test shows nothing once that final proof is skipped. The backing group was going to believe the first iteration, to even get secondary consideration of methods lacking was unusual and appreciated at that moment.


two passed tap water rinses are linked. If yours fails, with no final proofing, watch how fast the crowd accepts the 1/3 proof.
 
You are more than welcome to run your own test and show your results. I would love see them.

But unless some wants to pay me for this the test will be run as stated.
Im not sure what Brandon meant with his test - and I'm not sure what the purpose would be to do it with new rock meant. BUT - I do think that you should think about this.

Lets say in Step 1, you have 2 ppm Ammonia at the beginning and the next day you have 1ppm and the next day you have .5. I would repeat step 1. until you get a constant reliable time where the ammonia drops to zero. Note this ONLY becomes an issue IF it takes longer than 1 day to complete Step 1. If you don't understand what I'm talking about - you can PM me.
 
This is my QT tank, but I have never used it. All equipment was previously cleaned and is sterile. It has never had any meds in it. There is no filter, only the power head and heater. Power head was used, but cleaned well. Heater is brand new.

The HOB is on there, but it's not touching the water and it is sterile as well.
Thank you for the clarification, it concern me that you mentioned on opening statement that a QT was being used for this process.
Regarding your second test can I clarify if no3 and po4 detectable readings will be present for more than 30 days will be taken in to account? For a real life comparison, Or is this going to be done immediately on the next 72hours?
Are you using a second tank as a control?
 
You didn’t see a need to show the arrangement could work at all given non rinsed rocks? Still invalid. That’s leaving a cliffhanger
Brandon - Thats what Step 1 is - right? Thats non-rinsed rock. being taken from tank A to tank B. and proving ammonia reduction?
 
Regarding your second test can I clarify if no3 and po4 detectable readings will be present for more than 30 days will be taken in to account? For a real life comparison? Or is this going to be done immediately on the next 72hours?
Are you wondering because of the need for PO4 for multiplication of nitrifiers? or why? I guess I can see the reason for constant PO4 readings - not sure about Nitrate or 30 day period? @Lasse?
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top