Effects of tap water on Nitrifying during Rip-Clean method: Experiment

MN this is one time I could have used a professional experiment consultant to request the cured rocks put in last, to show the proven win condition
 
So far from it, isn’t that the same rock as brs investigates considered the worst rock for surface bacteria, seen here at 11:30.



If wee need to determine the exact type of rock, it's exact surface area, etc etc etc etc to be able to assume that it is safe to rinse rock in tap water and know that enough bacteria will survive then who is going to be able to do all that in the first place?
 
I just love the banter regardless. This is 9 pages of YES, NO, YES , NO.... its what makes the site worthwhile. Some interesting thoughts here.. Right or wrong....listening, evaluating....
 
If wee need to determine the exact type of rock, it's exact surface area, etc etc etc etc to be able to assume that it is safe to rinse rock in tap water and know that enough bacteria will survive then who is going to be able to do all that in the first place?
This a test of the rock you have, plain and simple. You are the one considering it in the future on a larger scale, and you are the one brave enough to experiment with it and document it for us. We’re just along for the ride and folks can argue whether it’s valid of not till they are blue in the face, it don’t matter. You’re doing more than can be expected already. ;)
 
Also, my water company provides our yearly tap water results. I've thrown them away... but I can probably run by and get a copy if anyone is interested in what's in my tap water.
You know depending on what this test confirms. .
If it’s not in favour of some they will pick at every straw .
a water test from the municipal might be needed at a later date
 
Are you wondering because of the need for PO4 for multiplication of nitrifiers? or why? I guess I can see the reason for constant PO4 readings - not sure about Nitrate or 30 day period? @Lasse?
Nitrate is no problem - it will be plenty when all this ammonia is converted into nitrate.
PO4 - I was waiting with that as a joker (playing card = wild card) if the process stall before step 2 :D
This test is only banking on ammonia as a food source to the bacteria. If the reading of po4 and no3 are zero is a big variable to not be taken into account don’t you think?
For the autotrophic nitrification bacteria - ammonia and nitrite is not food stuff in normal sense. the AOB and AOA use the energy differences between NH4 and NO2 as energy in the same way plants use light as an energy source. The NOB use the energy difference between NO2 and NO3 in the same way. But yes a PO4 source is probably needed
edit: for anyone that been in the hobby long enough can tell the colour of mature rock and new rock. The rock in this test doesn’t look mature, looks fresh from the shelf to me. The pic on the scales rock locks bone dry to!
One more that can use his/hers eyes to discover things that you normally need microscope to do - talk about eagle eyes

My old eyes can´t that - therefore I rely on the OP that he/she is a honest person. And as a final comment - nitrifier do not need light in order to grow even if they are autotrophic and you can´t see an nitrifying biofilm with even hawk eyes

Because of the genius construction of the test - which type of rocks used is of minor concern. The first test - the actual carrying capacity test of the rocks will automatically rise the biomass of nitrifiers, hence raise the carrying capacity to the load the second test will have. If the area is to small - the initial load will not be processed.

The test could also be done with total dry rocks because the first step in the test is not completed before the stones processing the x ppm of total ammonia that will be used for test 2.

Sincerely Lasse
 
This is an interesting test but your missing a control I would like to see what happens with dry rock/unseeded rock for a side by side comparison. It can't really be called an experiment if you don't have a control. Not bashing, this is a great idea, but if you decide to try and duplicate your outcome, add a control.
 
If wee need to determine the exact type of rock, it's exact surface area, etc etc etc etc to be able to assume that it is safe to rinse rock in tap water and know that enough bacteria will survive then who is going to be able to do all that in the first place?
Anyone with ethic towards a test.
 
This is an interesting test but your missing a control I would like to see what happens with dry rock/unseeded rock for a side by side comparison. It can't really be called an experiment if you don't have a control. Not bashing, this is a great idea, but if you decide to try and duplicate your outcome, add a control.
See my post above - the first test is the control for test 2. Type of rocks is of no concern. test 1 is not fully done before the rocks process exactly that load that is used in test 2. No control needed - but if it was a total scientific test - duplicate could be handy

Sincerely Lasse
 
Anyone with ethic towards a test.
Have you any ethic concerns according that the OP could kill or wash out some nitrifying bacteria?

Sincerely Lasse
 
Anyone with ethic towards a test.


My point is that if someone is going to rip clean their rocks using tap water does it need to be determined what their exact surface area is, weight, type of rock, etc before concluding if it's OK to perform said rip clean with tap water.

If so, almost no average home aquarist is going to be able to do so.

People are ripping this test apart because of unknown variables.. but aren't most of those same variables going to be unknown to the average home aquarist that Brandon recommends rip-cleans to?

The bet is that there is plenty of bacteria no matter the surface area, type of rock, etc... as long as you have enough pounds per gallon of typical reef rock.. because that is what the average home aquarist can most likely determine in the first place.
 
So far from it, isn’t that the same rock as brs investigates considered the worst rock for surface bacteria, seen here at 11:30.

You are missing the point. And I can see where you're going. At the end of the day - this test will show (or not show) 2 things - IMHO:

1. If you take rock from an established sump and place it in a tank with 2 PPM ammonia, will it be processed in 24 hours - or how long?
2. Once the rock demonstrates it can process the ammonia in 24 hours, Can you rinse the rock with hot (yes = how hot?) tap water (yes - helpful to know what's in the water - chlorine, chloramine, etc) for x amount of time and have the ammonia still be processed.

I do not think it will prove or disprove 'rip-cleaning'. But I guess I think it makes sense to bring up some of the issues about the experiment - the OP can decide which suggestions to take - or not - and lets see the results. That will be interesting.

Another thing that no one has mentioned - is - there are a lot of things on 'rock' that process ammonia. Those things will not be on 'this' rock. Algae, etc etc. So - its not going to tell you much about what happens when you take rock out of your lit tank, and wash it off.

Frankly - its just as good - than some other experiments that have been done - IMO.
 
I think whats missing without a control is how much die off contributes, with dead rock to start you can compare what effect die off has on the bacteria and how much if any die off actually happens when the rock is rinsed. And duplicating the same test a handful of times and charting the outcomes would really give the best chance of interpreting the results because we could see how much various variables effect the results from one test set to another.
 
My point is that if someone is going to rip clean their rocks using tap water does it need to be determined what their exact surface area is, weight, type of rock, etc before concluding if it's OK to perform said rip clean with tap water.

If so, almost no average home aquarist is going to be able to do so.

People are ripping this test apart because of unknown variables.. but aren't most of those same variables going to be unknown to the average home aquarist that Brandon recommends rip-cleans to?

The bet is that there is plenty of bacteria no matter the surface area, type of rock, etc... as long as you have enough pounds per gallon.. because that is what the average home aquarist can most likely determine in the first place.
Let’s be clear am not in favour of those so called rip cleans. There’s a lot of flaws with that method also.
 
If wee need to determine the exact type of rock, it's exact surface area, etc etc etc etc to be able to assume that it is safe to rinse rock in tap water and know that enough bacteria will survive then who is going to be able to do all that in the first place?
And the entire reason for the test . Lol

will nitrifying bacteria on live rock live through freshwater scrubbing as discussed .
Will washing , rinsing and scrubbing all the nasty from rocks effect the bacteria ?
 
I think whats missing without a control is how much die off contributes, with dead rock to start you can compare what effect die off has on the bacteria and how much if any die off actually happens when the rock is rinsed.
I think that you can do that with the present set up too - but duplicates had been nice. Not possible this time.

Sincerely Lasse
 
This is an interesting test but your missing a control I would like to see what happens with dry rock/unseeded rock for a side by side comparison. It can't really be called an experiment if you don't have a control. Not bashing, this is a great idea, but if you decide to try and duplicate your outcome, add a control.
No - I dont think so. Step 1 is the control to Step 2. But curious - which potential result do you think you're going to miss by putting dry rock in a tank, adding ammonia and waiting for 72 hours? (Actually I mentioned this way back when - I suppose by some miracle - there might something else that will miraculously grow in that time period - i.e. with ammonia and water and sterile rock - that could process ammonia. BUT - my guess is that won't happen - and second if it did the rate will be much different than the rock from the sump.

It does bring up an idea - I would do the experiment in the dark - to avoid any possible algae. (or at least the same light as in your sump)
 
Anyone with ethic towards a test.


Brandon helped me with my tank move and based on a picture alone of the tank and the rocks (these same type of rocks, just in the main tank and not the sump) he concluded that it would be perfectly safe for me to instant cycle the tank by moving the rocks only and using new water. He also said I should rinse the sand and rocks in tap water. I did not end up rinsing them with tap water due to time constraints and the fact that the rocks where very clean to begin with and I used new dry sand. I did test using this same test kit the following morning and he trusted its results.

Yet.... now, running a controlled test to prove the same beliefs he portrayed would be perfectly fine based on a picture he has become very defensive and questioning everything he was so sure about being perfectly fine before.

I don't understand that at all, but like I said... I'm performing this test for my own curiosity and knowledge. Everyone can take what they want from the results.
 
No - I dont think so. Step 1 is the control to Step 2. But curious - which potential result do you think you're going to miss by putting dry rock in a tank, adding ammonia and waiting for 72 hours? (Actually I mentioned this way back when - I suppose by some miracle - there might something else that will miraculously grow in that time period - i.e. with ammonia and water and sterile rock - that could process ammonia. BUT - my guess is that won't happen - and second if it did the rate will be much different than the rock from the sump.

It does bring up an idea - I would do the experiment in the dark - to avoid any possible algae. (or at least the same light as in your sump)

The tank is where it is. I do have the lights off. It's fairly dark except light coming from the next room. That'll just have to be what it is... it's my home, not a lab, lol.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top