My point is that if someone is going to rip clean their rocks using tap water does it need to be determined what their exact surface area is, weight, type of rock, etc before concluding if it's OK to perform said rip clean with tap water.
If so, almost no average home aquarist is going to be able to do so.
People are ripping this test apart because of unknown variables.. but aren't most of those same variables going to be unknown to the average home aquarist that Brandon recommends rip-cleans to?
The bet is that there is plenty of bacteria no matter the surface area, type of rock, etc... as long as you have enough pounds per gallon.. because that is what the average home aquarist can most likely determine in the first place.