For those that don’t QT, why not

I disagree and you can tell the guy who wrote that that I said so. :cool:
I am sure I have been keeping fish longer than him and he probably doesn't even have a goldfish tank. Not even fancy goldfish. :oops:

RjKain, come on down. :)

Based on what exactly? I mean How can you disagree with a scientific fact? This is a bit of why I keep discussing things with you - is because I'm trying to figure out your rationale for what your saying. Is that too much to ask?

It is a scientific fact that the immune system is not destroyed - and certainly not after 72 days - of QT. There is a difference between 'the immune system' and 'immunity'. Take tetanus - you get a shot - immunity lasts x years and you need a booster shot. You wouldn't say 'the immune system is destroyed because immunity to tetanus is lost.

Just another quick 'fact' - you mentioned cancer chemotherapy destroying the immune system - but its only temporary (and its certainly not complete 'destruction'). Take the example of stem cell or bone marrow transplants - where the immune system is actually destroyed... Assuming the person survives - it comes back 'to normal'.
 
I disagree and you can tell the guy who wrote that that I said so. :cool:
I am sure I have been keeping fish longer than him and he probably doesn't even have a goldfish tank. Not even fancy goldfish. :oops:

RjKain, come on down. :)


I would love to move south of the boarder, not only because of fish, but other reasons irrelevant to this post.
 
I would have to say that I don't with no problems...until today. Sick clownfish pair that I have had for 2 months and have no idea why or even what is wrong with them. I've added 2 fish since those the last one 2 weeks ago. I'm not sure QT of the new fish would have made a difference.

It's not the $$$! It's watching them suffer that's heartbreaking. We all know we are going to blow money doing this hobby.
 
Buying fish in a LFS I never needed to. I am thinking about it now that they come in the mail.
I recently got some very poor specimens. Once they go in the tank you can never get them back out without tearing it down. LA shipped some in blacked out bags where you couldnt even see the fish until you released it.

Not true. The black part is removable. Take off the outside bag then remove the blackout part. The inside bag is clear and still intact.
 
1, I do not have a QT tank. LOL. And 2. Fish look more stressed in QT. Then they must stress again going into main tank. Meanwhile new healthy fish direct into my main tank look happy and eat almost instant. I think on healthy livestock, most diseases if you only buy from quality sources come from stress. My source puts stock through QT, l leave them a week he uses copper so when I bring it home in bucket not bag, and acclimate, and add to tank they are great. But I have very few fish too.
 
My LFS is my quarantine. The kids they have working there part time usually don't know much, but the full time staff seem to know how long they've had every marine fish in the shop. And they'll hold any fish for up to a month with no deposit required.
I never buy fish online, but if I did, I might feel the need for a quarantine system at home.
But either way, I'm not a fan of prophylactic chemical or biological treatments on apparently healthy fish.
Some of my fish are older than my kids, who are old enough to have children of their own.
 
Mn, we have been over this for literally years. Scientific fact when talking about ornamental fish is subjective and every scientist has a different theory. Like I said about 5 times, everything I have ever submitted to a magazine was published as fact. I could have made it all up. And like I said 15 times, most scientists don't even keep fish. Someone pays them to study something, Usually a food fish, until the money runs out. Those studies don't last too long, certainly not as long as I have had fish.

So if you want to believe scientific studies, go with that and quarantine your fish.
I personally didn't have to go to college. (There was also that War thing) I learned every thing I wanted to know by doing it and I learned about fish by diving with them, not by listening to scientists who learned from a professor who also probably never spent time with fish and learned all he knows from a book.

Creative people learn on their own by experimenting and I did pretty well in my life. :cool:
Read some history.

All the people who were in the hobby when I started are out now. I may not know everything, but through experimentation, trial and error over fifty years I know a few things.

If you read about ich you will find the studies by Burgess and Axelrod from the 60s.
It's all about the parasite cycle. I read everything they wrote as they published it and I disagreed with them then as I do now. We don't have to care about the ich cycle, all we have to know, as aquarists is how to keep the parasites from killing our fish, (as I have learned but apparently a lot of people have not) My fish can attest to that.:)

If I were a hunter, I wouldn't have to know much about the life cycle of deer, only where they are and when.


I know plenty of people who went through radiation and chemo. They are not healthy and only could come back into society after gradually being exposed to every day pathogens over years.

Quarantined fish can never be exposed to diseases. Try it. Take a quarantined tank and add a sick fish, see what happens.

You always ask me where I base my ideas on. I base them on my experience. That's experience and results. As I also said, if you find anyone with more experience or older, healthier fish, listen to them and forget anything I come up with because it is not scientific fact.

I also have two US Patents on fish equipment and those didn't come from scientists either but from experience, neither did my book.

References:
Me
:p
 
Mn, we have been over this for literally years. Scientific fact when talking about ornamental fish is subjective and every scientist has a different theory. Like I said about 5 times, everything I have ever submitted to a magazine was published as fact. I could have made it all up.

I was talking about a couple specific issues - that you quote as 'your opinion' which are not true. I didnt quote the rest of the post - because you can have an opinion about science and research and thats all well and good. You can also have opinions about 'why' you're successful. But IMHO - when you start saying things that are clearly proven wrong - I call foul. The following are 'facts' - and they contradict your 'opinion'.

1. The immune system is not destroyed after 72 days of QT (and again who does that anyway where are you seeing that recommended?). It may be damaged - but just like other 'immune systems' it comes back.
2. Immunity to certain parasites may drop over time but the 'Immune system' is not destroyed.
3. Immunity to CI is not gained by the fish 'eating' CI. Its gained by a low-level infection in the skin or gills.

And I think you made a typo: you said 'everything I have ever submitted to a magazine was published as fact. I could have made it all up.' If it wasn't a typo - this is what I'm talking about.
 
Ain't nobody got time for that! Lol. In reality, for me, I adopt fish from my trusted buddies that let fish go. I know their health and living conditions, therefore I'm not scared of any potential disease. Only had an ich outbreak once in 16 years of keeping! Vitamin enriched diet is key as well.
 
Ain't nobody got time for that! Lol. In reality, for me, I adopt fish from my trusted buddies that let fish go. I know their health and living conditions, therefore I'm not scared of any potential disease. Only had an ich outbreak once in 16 years of keeping! Vitamin enriched diet is key as well.

I QT “cuz I got time for that”. I’ve enjoyed reading this thread even though I’m in the QT bus.
 
1. The immune system is not destroyed after 72 days of QT (and again who does that anyway where are you seeing that recommended?). It may be damaged - but just like other 'immune systems' it comes back.

Come on Mn. In one minute I found 4 references to the 72 day thing. Just search for 72 days on this forum and you will find dozens of people who do that or recommend it. You know that.
Here are 4 of them but I can list them all day long.

That’s not ich. That’s velvet, bad. Maybe some brook as well. 72 day fallow once all fish are out.

Knowing the life cycle of Ich, you would need to stay fallow for 72 days to be safe. Tang would need to be QT'd for observation, as it could have it as well.

i would go about the same as QT process for a coral. dipping, and observation coupled with being in a separate QT tank for at least 72 days with no new additions.

Because the theronts are the issue in the life cycle and take a long time to release (up to 72 days) a UV is unlikely to remove any parasites that are not in their free swimming stage, unfortunately.


2. Immunity to certain parasites may drop over time but the 'Immune system' is not destroyed.




No one knows this, do you? That is your opinion and I am sure it varies with every fish

3. Immunity to CI is not gained by the fish 'eating' CI. Its gained by a low-level infection in the skin or gills.

Immunity is not gained because fish from the sea are already immune. Eating the parasites like every fish does in the sea keeps their immunity along with the gill and skin infections. Fish need all of that which my method provides and quarantine eliminates.

And I think you made a typo: you said 'everything I have ever submitted to a magazine was published as fact. I could have made it all up.' If it wasn't a typo - this is what I'm talking about.

This is not a typo and it's true. I have written many magazine articles and never has any been disputed by anyone.

Again, I have nothing to prove and everything I say is what I believe from personal experience and not internet searching.

Why do we have to go through this all the time. If you feel my practices or the way I write about them are wrong, do something else or write your own book with your practices like I did.
 
Come on Mn. In one minute I found 4 references to the 72 day thing. Just search for 72 days on this forum and you will find dozens of people who do that or recommend it. You know that.
Here are 4 of them but I can list them all day long.
The 72 day thing here is the fallow DT. It isn’t the medicated treatment of the fish. Yes the fish are moved to QT but they are only run through 14 to 30 days copper to eradicate the parasite (CI and velvet). The rest of the 72 days is just them waiting unmedicated while the DT finishes the 72 days.

@Paul B , I will say with your track record I am not disputing that you know your stuff. Only stating that the 72 day fish treatment isn’t correct. That is the time for CI to run its life cycle and die without fish present.

Continue on

#ClashoftheTitans
 
why not QT? Because its something that most just dont understand, no matter how many of the 1000's of posts regarding this subject that is asked here.... Its been answered a bazillion times already. ;Facepalm;Dead
 
The 72 day thing here is the fallow DT.

Yes, I know that, but the 72 days is quarantine. I didn't say anything about medication.
Quarantine is being kept away from disease causing organisms. This, to me is wrong.
Shoot me! ;Bucktooth

why not QT?

I don't know. If you want to quarantine, do that. Who is stopping you? :cool:
 
Yes, I know that, but the 72 days is quarantine. I didn't say anything about medication.
Quarantine is being kept away from disease causing organisms. This, to me is wrong.
Shoot me! ;Bucktooth



I don't know. If you want to quarantine, do that. Who is stopping you? :cool:
I dont QT... These threads are just annoying with the same ppl answering over and over and over with the exact same response year after year after year...
 
1570311957309.gif
1570311957309.gif
 
I dont QT... These threads are just annoying with the same ppl answering over and over and over with the exact same response year after year after year...

This thread was intended to just find out why people don’t QT. I don’t know how it got into a QT debate.
;Nailbiting ;Woot :cool::D

1570312110670.jpeg
 
Come on Mn. In one minute I found 4 references to the 72 day thing. Just search for 72 days on this forum and you will find dozens of people who do that or recommend it. You know that.
Here are 4 of them but I can list them all day long.

If it is not a typo how is it in one case you say your just posting your opinion. In that sentence you said everything you state is fact lol. Which is it













No one knows this, do you? That is your opinion and I am sure it varies with every fish



Immunity is not gained because fish from the sea are already immune. Eating the parasites like every fish does in the sea keeps their immunity along with the gill and skin infections. Fish need all of that which my method provides and quarantine eliminates.



This is not a typo and it's true. I have written many magazine articles and never has any been disputed by anyone.

Again, I have nothing to prove and everything I say is what I believe from personal experience and not internet searching.

Why do we have to go through this all the time. If you feel my practices or the way I write about them are wrong, do something else or write your own book with your practices like I did.
A fallow period is not the same as a QT period. You know this.
As to the rest. I’m writing my book post by post. There is a lot of new i formation out there on fish immunity and the immune system in general.
 
I dont QT... These threads are just annoying with the same ppl answering over and over and over with the exact same response year after year after year...

This is true and I am unwatching this thread. Have a great day.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top