Mn, we have been over this for literally years. Scientific fact when talking about ornamental fish is subjective and every scientist has a different theory. Like I said about 5 times, everything I have ever submitted to a magazine was published as fact. I could have made it all up. And like I said 15 times, most scientists don't even keep fish. Someone pays them to study something, Usually a food fish, until the money runs out. Those studies don't last too long, certainly not as long as I have had fish.
So if you want to believe scientific studies, go with that and quarantine your fish.
I personally didn't have to go to college. (There was also that War thing) I learned every thing I wanted to know by doing it and I learned about fish by diving with them, not by listening to scientists who learned from a professor who also probably never spent time with fish and learned all he knows from a book.
Creative people learn on their own by experimenting and I did pretty well in my life.

Read some history.
All the people who were in the hobby when I started are out now. I may not know everything, but through experimentation, trial and error over fifty years I know a few things.
If you read about ich you will find the studies by Burgess and Axelrod from the 60s.
It's all about the parasite cycle. I read everything they wrote as they published it and I disagreed with them then as I do now. We don't have to care about the ich cycle, all we have to know, as aquarists is how to keep the parasites from killing our fish, (as I have learned but apparently a lot of people have not) My fish can attest to that.
If I were a hunter, I wouldn't have to know much about the life cycle of deer, only where they are and when.
I know plenty of people who went through radiation and chemo. They are not healthy and only could come back into society after gradually being exposed to every day pathogens over years.
Quarantined fish can never be exposed to diseases. Try it. Take a quarantined tank and add a sick fish, see what happens.
You always ask me where I base my ideas on. I base them on my experience. That's experience and results. As I also said, if you find anyone with more experience or older, healthier fish, listen to them and forget anything I come up with because it is not scientific fact.
I also have two US Patents on fish equipment and those didn't come from scientists either but from experience, neither did my book.
References:
Me
