Yes you should have.
I did say the few Moorish Idols I had died prematurely as Moorish Idols do that. The first one was in my 40 gallon tank way before they had reefs and I was lousy at keeping them. (and everything else) Of course the tank was way too small also.
I know I lost all the orange spotted file fish and twin spot gobies I had because I stupidly bought fish I couldn't feed properly. I have also lost plenty of eels but they all jumped out as did every firefish I had and most wrasses (which I posted)
My Log from 1976.
This shows my fish being sick and dying in the early years. Look at some of the medications I tried as there was no information, reefs or salt water medications available.
I didn't come up with my theory then and I lost plenty of fish. (As I say all the time)
Before we kept reefs we used dry, dead corals and we would remove them weekly to bleach them so they were nice and white. The fish were never healthy and we kept our tanks sterile, unlike what I "preach" now. WE also fed "Tetra Min" freshwater flakes among other silly things. Some fish foods then were dried ants and flies. ;Bucktooth
Also remember I was almost the only one with salt water fish in those days and it wasn't quite as simple as it is now.
My last Moorish Idol didn't die from disease. It just died as Moorish Idols do. He was probably lacking something in his diet but I don't know. I do necropsy many of my fish when they die to look for parasites and like all my fish, he didn't have any.
I don't know where that came from about tangs living for 40 years but I normally keep them for about 12 years as my last hippo lived that long. He had HLLE as hippo tangs sometimes get in my tank. HLLE, despite popular opinion, is not a disease but a condition of captivity. Wild fish don't get it. I have my own theory as to what it comes from and I don't believe the carbon thing.
It doesn't normally kill them but they look horrible and I may have euthanized some of them.
(Yes, shoot me)
I also don't remember what happened to any other tangs I had but after about 1980 or so, none of my fish died from disease. That was 39 years ago so I have no idea and I would have to look through the long pages of my old Log book to see what happened, but I bet most of them jumped out.
Maybe when I was bleaching the corals.
If I can find that log book I will see if I can see what happened. I haven't seen it since I moved here over a year ago.
I never said my fish don't die, I said they don't die from disease. Big difference.