For those that don’t QT, why not

At 15, I am extremely lucky to even have my reef tank. An extra QT tank and lots of expensive treatments is a no go, plus the amount of fish that die in quarantine is quite large, especially when it takes 1-2 months to even save up for the fish.
 
I doubt I could be lucky for that long. I just keep my fish healthy and immune by making sure there are diseases always present. My fish all spawn and only die of old age so I don't have any need of a hospital tank, medications or quarantine.

First off, I have seen your tank in many different forums and seen you in several videos all over the web, so I know that you are someone that has an enormous amount of knowledge in this hobby and I trust it when you say it is not luck in your case. That being said, I have QT'd all my fish so far, (in copper and PraziPro) and have lost a lot of fish that probably would have made it otherwise. I would really like to learn more about what you mean by, "making sure there are diseases always present" and how you manage that as well as how you build their immunity. I don't want to take over this thread, but is there a link you can point me to where you talk about this?
 
I don't QT. Too much stress on a starved, overcrowded fish. I put them in acclimation so the rest of the fish can meet them and I feed a lot of food and have a lot of natural food in my tank. I've had fish come in covered in ich or whatever other parasite they picked up and the majority recover once they start eating and pack on some weight. The ones that do succumb to the stress don't nuke my tank either. I've also learned which places to buy fish. One LFS I used to frequent did a terrible job with their fish. Almost every fish I bought there would die, usually covered in parasites. Still, didn't kill any of my other fish. Took me awhile to learn it was them and not me. Once I learn the places that are bad at bringing in fish, I stay away from them. I don't keep going back hoping for a miracle.

This doesn't mean I'm against treating fish with medication. I keep plenty of medication on hand, but I'm not about to treat prophylactically. By doing that, I increase the risk of developing diseases that are resistant to the medication we use.
 
Full QT, separate tank and all.

Since I do have an observation tank separate from my system I don't know if this qualifies....

I tried the whole sterile tank, PVC pipe route and fish kept dying, with and without meds although I never used copper or CP. I think it was a combination of stress and poor water quality. Most often the fish were asymptomatic, they just died. I kept hearing the voice of my old Pharmacology instructor saying "there is no such thing as a medication without side effects". I don't think we know what harm we could be doing to fish livers, kidneys, etc with endless combinations of medications.

So after a while I set up a cycled tank complete with rock, sand and a small CUC. No more worries about ammonia levels or a little extra food. Feed well and watch them for a month and only treat if I can identify with reasonable certainty what I'm treating for. That's when my fish began surviving. The only issue I've seen in my display tank was some transient white, stringy poo.
 
How do I know what? I know diatom filters will filter out parasites, that is a scientific fact soI would assume that if you are worried about parasites, as many people seem to be, then why not use a diatom filter to eliminate them?
I myself don't have to worry or think about parasites but I know many people do. Yes, my fish are totally immune.



You do know that my reef is almost fifty years old and nothing has been sick with anything in about 45 of those years. That is my excuse unless you can find an older quarantined tank that has been healthy that long. :cool:
This will be a horribly unliked post. But - I dont believe you. I don't believe that you can drop (with whatever) infested fish into a tank just like that - and they will mirculauously survive - it may happen 50% of the time - but not always. I dont understand if you've had (as you said) tangs - which live 40 years - and moorish idols - that are not invisible - that you say you never have fish die except from old age (perhaps you traded them - all good) - I just dont believe you. I believe that you believe you - ie - I dont think you believe that you are talking falsehoods - but I believe that you are ignoring failures - and accentuating positives. There is no other explanation - Its not clams its not biodiversity its nothing else but bias - and its normal to feel that way - and Keep feeling that way - but I dont have access to Long Island or Florida mud - so I guess I should just dump my tank out because I cant be successful..
 
First off, I have seen your tank in many different forums and seen you in several videos all over the web, so I know that you are someone that has an enormous amount of knowledge in this hobby and I trust it when you say it is not luck in your case. That being said, I have QT'd all my fish so far, (in copper and PraziPro) and have lost a lot of fish that probably would have made it otherwise. I would really like to learn more about what you mean by, "making sure there are diseases always present" and how you manage that as well as how you build their immunity. I don't want to take over this thread, but is there a link you can point me to where you talk about this?
+1
 
I tried the quarantine route at first , but I think my qt setup was too stressful or not stable enough. After losing quite a few fish in qt I stopped qt and from then on new fish have always thrived being added straight to my 210g display tank. I think the extra room in the display tank is much less stressful on the fish than the 20g long I was using for qt. Additionally I would never buy a fish online.

I try to feed nutritious food including live black worms, so I don’t really worry about ich being in the tank. I may see a spot or two of ich on my blue tang every once and awhile when I come home from vacation with only auto feeders been feeding the tank. But I start feeding healthy again and it always clears up, no problem.

I think what scares me most about not quarantining is stories of velvet, but luckily the lfs around me doesn't seem to have any issues like that.
 
I dont believe you. I don't believe that you can drop (with whatever) infested fish into a tank just like that - and they will mirculauously survive
I just dont believe you. I believe that you believe you - ie - I dont think you believe that you are talking falsehoods - but I believe that you are ignoring failures

I don't believe you wrote all the things that you don't believe. Then don't believe, what can I tell you? I have nothing to prove. :cool:

Besides that, your response if totally full of falsehoods which I have never said. For instance I never said I can drop any sick fish into my tank and it will survive. I did say (many times) that that fish may die, but never my other fish.
I also never said I have kept a Moorish Idol or tang for 40 years. My last Moorish Idol died at five years old which is a failure. (One that you don't believe I said) 5 years stinks but with a Moorish Idol it is practically a record and I kept them in a 40 gallon tank in the 70s (which I also posted with my Log book)

AS for ignoring failures, I always post when one of my fish dies. You have not been in the hobby long enough as I post when I get a fish and years later when it dies. I have posted many times when my fish spawn as you know. I have posted numerous pictures of my 28 year old spawning fireclowns and eggs with my pipefish, bangai cardinals, clown gobies, striped cardinals, watchmans etc.
I have posted many pictures over the years of my fish dying of old age but one thing I have never posted on this or the other 7 forums I am on is a sick fish unless I was showing a fish I just bought.
That's because My fish don't get sick as I found the secret of being "Lucky".

I have not seen any of your fish spawning or any of your old fish.
I also said I am not as good with corals as I do lost them and I have posted why I think that was.
I posted one this week.
I have been posting since way before there was forums or even computers in Magazines. Maybe even before you were born.

All the people who I originally disputed this with are now out of the hobby but I am still here and have been longer than anyone because I was here when it started. Probably on a rainy Tuesday about 2:15 in the afternoon on a Leap year.

Marco as I just mentioned to Mn, I have numerous threads on this.
Here are some

I could go on, but Mn man not believe me. ;)
 
Marco as I just mentioned to Mn, I have numerous threads on this.
Here are some

Thank you! ;Happy
 
Since I do have an observation tank separate from my system I don't know if this qualifies....

I tried the whole sterile tank, PVC pipe route and fish kept dying, with and without meds although I never used copper or CP. I think it was a combination of stress and poor water quality. Most often the fish were asymptomatic, they just died. I kept hearing the voice of my old Pharmacology instructor saying "there is no such thing as a medication without side effects". I don't think we know what harm we could be doing to fish livers, kidneys, etc with endless combinations of medications.

So after a while I set up a cycled tank complete with rock, sand and a small CUC. No more worries about ammonia levels or a little extra food. Feed well and watch them for a month and only treat if I can identify with reasonable certainty what I'm treating for. That's when my fish began surviving. The only issue I've seen in my display tank was some transient white, stringy poo.
This is quarantine.
 
I don't believe you wrote all the things that you don't believe. Then don't believe, what can I tell you? I have nothing to prove. :cool:

Besides that, your response if totally full of falsehoods which I have never said. For instance I never said I can drop any sick fish into my tank and it will survive. I did say (many times) that that fish may die, but never my other fish.
I also never said I have kept a Moorish Idol or tang for 40 years. My last Moorish Idol died at five years old which is a failure. (One that you don't believe I said) 5 years stinks but with a Moorish Idol it is practically a record and I kept them in a 40 gallon tank in the 70s (which I also posted with my Log book)

AS for ignoring failures, I always post when one of my fish dies. You have not been in the hobby long enough as I post when I get a fish and years later when it dies. I have posted many times when my fish spawn as you know. I have posted numerous pictures of my 28 year old spawning fireclowns and eggs with my pipefish, bangai cardinals, clown gobies, striped cardinals, watchmans etc.
I have posted many pictures over the years of my fish dying of old age but one thing I have never posted on this or the other 7 forums I am on is a sick fish unless I was showing a fish I just bought.
That's because My fish don't get sick as I found the secret of being "Lucky".

I have not seen any of your fish spawning or any of your old fish.
I also said I am not as good with corals as I do lost them and I have posted why I think that was.
I posted one this week.
I have been posting since way before there was forums or even computers in Magazines. Maybe even before you were born.

All the people who I originally disputed this with are now out of the hobby but I am still here and have been longer than anyone because I was here when it started. Probably on a rainy Tuesday about 2:15 in the afternoon on a Leap year.

Marco as I just mentioned to Mn, I have numerous threads on this.
Here are some

I could go on, but Mn man not believe me. ;)

Perhaps I worded what I wrote too strongly - I apologize. I specifically said in that post that I do not think you are posting falsehoods on purpose - ie. I don't think you're lying. I should not have said 'I dont believe you'. I should have said 'I dont believe your rationale behind what you're saying'

My point was (and I asked you a question several days ago that you ignored - which is your prerogative). Paraphrased it related to the fact that you said that over the years you have kept many tangs and moorish idols (with no disease problems) - and you have also said - your fish only die of old age. My point was - since tangs can live to be 40+ years old - what has happened to all of them (and where are all the moorish idols) - (and I believe I said this in the post - unless you traded them away - because you find tangs boring).

PS - the reason you dont see my fish spawning is that I dont have any pairs of fish in my tank. But - I have a dotty back - that im pretty sure is full of eggs - and is eating 90% flake food. Spawning is (IMO) a function not of having live food - but of having 'good food'
 
In 20+ years I've had one issue that wiped out all my fish (first or second year in the hobby). I dont know what caused it as everything looked healthy (looked fine at lights out and dead the next morning).

Ich just isn't a concern for me; I dont keep fish prone to getting it and the others can kick it as long as they're getting enough to eat. I rarely lose a new fish but I read about many deaths during the QT process. I think the fish have a better chance in my display than a sterile QT setup. Other issues are usually pretty easy to spot if you scope the fish out before the purchase.
 
To proper qt I don't have the room for. Multiple qt tanks and seperated gear for each tank.
 
I should have said 'I dont believe your rationale behind what you're saying'

Yes you should have. :p

I did say the few Moorish Idols I had died prematurely as Moorish Idols do that. The first one was in my 40 gallon tank way before they had reefs and I was lousy at keeping them. (and everything else) Of course the tank was way too small also.
I know I lost all the orange spotted file fish and twin spot gobies I had because I stupidly bought fish I couldn't feed properly. I have also lost plenty of eels but they all jumped out as did every firefish I had and most wrasses (which I posted)

My Log from 1976.



This shows my fish being sick and dying in the early years. Look at some of the medications I tried as there was no information, reefs or salt water medications available.
I didn't come up with my theory then and I lost plenty of fish. (As I say all the time)

Before we kept reefs we used dry, dead corals and we would remove them weekly to bleach them so they were nice and white. The fish were never healthy and we kept our tanks sterile, unlike what I "preach" now. WE also fed "Tetra Min" freshwater flakes among other silly things. Some fish foods then were dried ants and flies. ;Bucktooth

Also remember I was almost the only one with salt water fish in those days and it wasn't quite as simple as it is now.



My last Moorish Idol didn't die from disease. It just died as Moorish Idols do. He was probably lacking something in his diet but I don't know. I do necropsy many of my fish when they die to look for parasites and like all my fish, he didn't have any.

I don't know where that came from about tangs living for 40 years but I normally keep them for about 12 years as my last hippo lived that long. He had HLLE as hippo tangs sometimes get in my tank. HLLE, despite popular opinion, is not a disease but a condition of captivity. Wild fish don't get it. I have my own theory as to what it comes from and I don't believe the carbon thing.
It doesn't normally kill them but they look horrible and I may have euthanized some of them.
(Yes, shoot me)

I also don't remember what happened to any other tangs I had but after about 1980 or so, none of my fish died from disease. That was 39 years ago so I have no idea and I would have to look through the long pages of my old Log book to see what happened, but I bet most of them jumped out.
Maybe when I was bleaching the corals. :p

If I can find that log book I will see if I can see what happened. I haven't seen it since I moved here over a year ago.

I never said my fish don't die, I said they don't die from disease. Big difference. :)
 
Here is my experience:


When I didn't quarantine, my fish died even with the best foods

When I started to quarantine using Hot Rocks method, I've had no fish die

It's hard to argue with that
 
Yes you should have. :p

I did say the few Moorish Idols I had died prematurely as Moorish Idols do that. The first one was in my 40 gallon tank way before they had reefs and I was lousy at keeping them. (and everything else) Of course the tank was way too small also.
I know I lost all the orange spotted file fish and twin spot gobies I had because I stupidly bought fish I couldn't feed properly. I have also lost plenty of eels but they all jumped out as did every firefish I had and most wrasses (which I posted)

My Log from 1976.



This shows my fish being sick and dying in the early years. Look at some of the medications I tried as there was no information, reefs or salt water medications available.
I didn't come up with my theory then and I lost plenty of fish. (As I say all the time)

Before we kept reefs we used dry, dead corals and we would remove them weekly to bleach them so they were nice and white. The fish were never healthy and we kept our tanks sterile, unlike what I "preach" now. WE also fed "Tetra Min" freshwater flakes among other silly things. Some fish foods then were dried ants and flies. ;Bucktooth

Also remember I was almost the only one with salt water fish in those days and it wasn't quite as simple as it is now.



My last Moorish Idol didn't die from disease. It just died as Moorish Idols do. He was probably lacking something in his diet but I don't know. I do necropsy many of my fish when they die to look for parasites and like all my fish, he didn't have any.

I don't know where that came from about tangs living for 40 years but I normally keep them for about 12 years as my last hippo lived that long. He had HLLE as hippo tangs sometimes get in my tank. HLLE, despite popular opinion, is not a disease but a condition of captivity. Wild fish don't get it. I have my own theory as to what it comes from and I don't believe the carbon thing.
It doesn't normally kill them but they look horrible and I may have euthanized some of them.
(Yes, shoot me)

I also don't remember what happened to any other tangs I had but after about 1980 or so, none of my fish died from disease. That was 39 years ago so I have no idea and I would have to look through the long pages of my old Log book to see what happened, but I bet most of them jumped out.
Maybe when I was bleaching the corals. :p

If I can find that log book I will see if I can see what happened. I haven't seen it since I moved here over a year ago.

I never said my fish don't die, I said they don't die from disease. Big difference. :)
Thanks for the response - I have to say (almost using a non-family-friendly word) - that your log book is wonderful. The interesting thing is - your fish have died from disease. HLLE is a disease. No one really knows 'what causes it' - I know the carbon thing (doesnt make complete sense) - I was bleaching corals every couple weeks with you years ago lol. I have been there done most of it.

However - saltwater tanks - not with much coral (living) - though were common 40 years ago.

BY the way in the wild its well documented that tangs are long-lived - I believe the longest I've seen is 45 years
 
HLLE is a disease.

It is not, but that is semantics. I believe that because it is mostly on tangs and schooling fish and always starts on the lateral line, it is from confinement. Wild fish do not get it. I believe that is because all fish have a lateral line and tangs and schooling fish have a more defined lateral line which is more sensitive to allow those fish to swim right next to each other and not crash. I also believe thats why tangs are a flatter fish, to allow the lateral line to be longer.

Just look at them.

In a tank fish can "feel" the glass around them but can't see it. They know there is something there and they can't get away from it. They also can't get away from the bottom and the surface ,as a tang, or most fish would never swim in 18" deep water. Their lateral line is constantly getting signals from these things and the nerves deteriorate.

In the sea the lateral line just gets signals from the fish next to them which allows them to swim together and fit in crannies in rocks without getting stuck or cut.
Fish can get along just fine with one eye or sometimes no eyes. They can swim perfectly at night and never swim into the glass. It is also impossible to catch a fish with a net unless you cheat and jam him up against a rock or the glass.

Follow a fish in the sea with a net and see if you can catch him without cheating.

Thats why these fish are this shape and not streamlined like fast swimming tuna.
Tuna also swim in schools but they do not swim milometers from each other.

Tuna escape by speed, tangs hide in rocks as they are not the Ferrari's of the sea.

 
You can clearly see the lateral line on my copperband. They don't swim in schools but dive into holes to grab worms thats why they have a well developed lateral line and why they are shaped to have a longer lateral line.


My fireclown has a very mild case of HLLE on his face, but he has been in my tank for 28 years so I am sure his nerves are shot. But he is still spawning almost every day.

 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top