For those that don’t QT, why not

If I set up a sterile tank the first thing I'm going to do is drop-in the contaminated fish from the store. The battle then begins and I am not properly armed to win that battle

I don't have the patience, the sterile facilities, or access to the pharmaceuticals or the brains to know which ones to use or the skills to do the smears to figure out how to properly treat with the meds if I did have access, it's outside of my skillset and interests.

I open the bag, reach in and lift the fish out with my hands while I say the prayer asking our creator to watch out for the health of the fish.

It's amazing to see how calm a fish will get when he's been introduced to the tank this way.
 
i personally dont. With human bodies, when given a chemical for a period of time, the body reacts negative. Once the chemical is gone and not used, the body begins to function properly although the chemical helped break down a certain cell, it also destroyed other portions of the body. This i feel is the same for fish.
 
I’ve QT in the past and treated prophylacticly. I haven’t recently due to sheer laziness and not wanting to monitor a QT tank. My fish have been healthy enough to not have losses however I k ow they’re infected and it stresses me out knowing they are infected and untreated. At any point they could take a turn for the worse and I’m aware of it.
If I had an abundance of funds, time and space I absolutely would QT and put the fish through a deworming, and chelated copper regiment. Prazi Pro seems like a total waste and ineffective these days.
I do feel that there are some fish that will never handle the sterile and environment of a QT, I’d probably just not keep them. There is a great piece of mind knowing your tank is totally infection free. If you don’t QT you’re playing Russian roulette with animals lives. It is what it is , it’s not cool to not QT and I think it’s irresponsible to promote not QT’ing. My observation that besides the cost, the next hurdle to people staying in the hobby is fish loss due to parasite infection.
If we encourage successful practices, we can help our hobby as a whole. Encouraging newbs to not QT is not the way to go. The resistant based tanks like PaulB are the exception not the rule. Like I said elsewhere all the clam guts in the world won’t immunize fish against velvet or brook. They will all be dead quickly.
 
I “mostly” QT but admit it’s not ideal for some species ... I had gone decades without one sign of ich until I lost thousands in fish in one outbreak .... I got seahorses now and have to
 
Like I said elsewhere all the clam guts in the world won’t immunize fish against velvet or brook. They will all be dead quickly.

OOOOOHHHHH NNNOOOO. That's what I ate last night!!! :eek:
 
Healthy fish in a well stocked healthy tank dont get sick easily.

Added a sick yellow tang once... he was fully covered with ich or more probably velvet. The yellow really masked it. It was only apparant directly under my leds.

Tang died 2 days later. The rest of my fish developed some spots that cleared up nicely. All new fish added after, never showed any symptoms.

No I dont quarantine.

Stress in fish is the worst.
 
1. I only buy fish either from tanks with inverts/coral - so I know that they are not exposed to copper
2. I only buy fish from a reputable source
3. I only buy fish not that are necessarily 'eating' - but look healthy
4. I do not believe in prophylactically treating fish, etc - for diseases they may not have.
5. I dont buy fish online - that might have been shipped 3 x in the last week. I only buy fish I can observe

Since doing this - I have not had a problem with or without QT. So - If its equivalent - I figure I dont need to do it.

PS - I only buy fish sporadically - Not from 3 places in a weekend etc etc.
 
I use many kinds of food as well and find that it’s nice to have size variation. The Rods tends to have larger particles with more macro algea whereas the LRS nano has has smaller bits. I alternate with various other types with reef frenzy to inc my phosphate. This way both larger and smaller fish are able to feed well.
 
I have been in the hobby for over 40 years I do not QT. Back 38 or so years ago I did have some problems with disease. But I have not for years. I do not have the space or time for QT. I have been doing the other way to run a reef tank no QT for a long time
 
Hi all,

We talk a lot about the QT, non QT methods. I think the non-QT reasoning is clear. But for the non-QT folks why do we do it.

Why don’t you QT? Be honest, no one judging.

Is it to time consuming, to expensive with all the meds and equipment, don’t have room for the tank, think why QT there’s nothing wrong with the fish, don’t understand QT, feel a healthy system needs that biodiversity, worried QT is too harsh

(This is not a debate on QT or not. (We already know non QT is better:p) It is a fact finding thread.)

Thanks all.
Most of the time when I have done qt the fish died within a few days. I have always had trouble keeping the ammonia level at zero. I have a 5 gal qt tank which I only use for qt.
 
Yeah i did not QT for years until flukes and ich killed over $1100 dollars in fish!!! Then had to play Ich management for years!!!! Which is not fun because anything can trigger a bad outbreak. I treat EVERTHING now. Too many diseases these days.
 
There is a reason I have a nano tank, simply don’t have room for something bigger at my home let alone a QT. Don’t have the option to since no room so I am just careful about what I put in. Also helps having a nano tank so I haven’t put any fish in for a long time since there isn’t much room.
 
To answer the question directly, in my experience in the trade, the common reasons explained to me by customers as to why they don't wish to quarantine are.

Don't understand how to.
Don't have the space.
Don't want the extra expense.
Can't wait to get my new purchase into the tank and marvel at its beauty.
Looks fine to me, ready to go.
I trust you.
Never Quarantined before, why start now.

Some of the other explanations I sometimes hear, IMHO, based on selective evidence. Mostly a collective assumption and poor administration, practice or understanding of the different options available in quarantining. More importantly in my opinion all of the concerns detailed below can be addressed within a well maintained QT system.

Causes to much stress to the animal.
Sterile environment will completely strip the animal of all of its natural immune defence mechanisms
Better to take the point of view that the fittest survive, let the animal fend for itself against parasites and virus.
Improve its chances by healthy diet within the DT.

There are numerous methods of Quarantine and a varied choice of adaptions within each method. All of the concerns above can be addressed no less effectively than within the main DT. However the risk of infecting your DT are reduced considerably.

My personal favourite being BHD, Bath in fresh Water, Hypo Salinity Environment and Dietary Conditioning (HUFA, Amino, Vitamin Supplement and Appetite Enhancers). Only treat diagnosed problems with a targeted treatment.

If you wish at a final stage if you have the patience, you can also add small amounts of your DT water (Trusted Mature Systems Only) to the QT tank to observe any reaction in the animals response before its added to the DT and acclimatise it to your final water conditions. I personally find this very useful for coral QT in particular.

Stress could arguably be increased by adding an already stressed animal to a tank full of competitors. IMO, the stress involved in QT is far more manageable.

The fact is all of the fish you buy through the trade will have been through an extensive process before you get your hands on them. They have been collected, transported, stored, transported, stored, transported, stored, transported, stored. During this process they may be also exposed to a number of chemical processes to keep them alive. This process is more detailed the further along the animals journey as its value increases with each transfer of ownership. These processes are out of your hands and at the discretion of each holding facility.

For those of us in the trade the economical success is commonly defined by how many and how long we can keep the animals alive until we can sell them on. The trick is to sell as quickly as possible (Of course always being aware of the animals general welfare). However for the hobbyists, the aim is to keep the animal alive long term. Hopefully somewhere near to its natural life cycle.

As retailers, we are the last point of call for the animals before there final destination. The value of the animal is now at its peak. (Retail Value). This is the reason many LFS run procedures such as copper and low salinity in there holding systems. Not to specifically to eradicate any possible infection, but to manage the ability of the infection to become unmanageable, visible or at worst fatal.

A growing number of stores are now running isolated systems and simple QT methods. Many like myself find this proactive approach reduces the stress on the store owner, you don't need to worry as much about one rouge shipment wiping out your entire stock. Personally it also makes me feel so much better caring for the animals in such a way that produces a fine healthy active specimen, ready for its final destination.

No one is trying to force you to QT your animals and I thoroughly understand that it is an added expense and more importantly puts strain on the availability of space within your home. I have nothing but admiration and respect for those on this forum and others that have dedicated there time and effort to help us understand the methods and practices involved in quarantining.

I often come across statements from seasoned aquarists who argue against QT, by advocating their personal success of controlling the environment and diet within the DT. Personally I believe there is no comparison. Diverse biological environment and nutritious pro biotic diet are simply good husbandry practices, not viable alternatives to QT (isolation of a new member from the general environment as a means of observation and risk management).

After all, at worst, practising QT just gives you that extra argument to have another tank:)

Happy reefing from across the pond.
 
I am surprised more people, and wholesalers don't use diatom filters. They are not that expensive and the diatom powder, if purchased from a pool supply is very cheap. They will remove parasites without altering water quality.

I personally don't need it for that reason but I do use my diatom sometimes when I collect NSW because I take it from the shore and it is filled with particles and sand. But if I were worried about parasites, I would use it in a "quarantine" tank or any tank where I was worried about parasites.
It won't cure a fish but it will keep new parasites from re-infecting your tank.

A diatom filter will remove anything smaller than about a micron, parasites are much larger than that.
Just a thought.
 
I am surprised more people, and wholesalers don't use diatom filters. They are not that expensive and the diatom powder, if purchased from a pool supply is very cheap. They will remove parasites without altering water quality.

I personally don't need it for that reason but I do use my diatom sometimes when I collect NSW because I take it from the shore and it is filled with particles and sand. But if I were worried about parasites, I would use it in a "quarantine" tank or any tank where I was worried about parasites.
It won't cure a fish but it will keep new parasites from re-infecting your tank.

A diatom filter will remove anything smaller than about a micron, parasites are much larger than that.
Just a thought.
Hi @Paul B , I agree, this along with a balanced UV filter can significantly add to the successful management of parasite infection, especially in large plumbed systems. At least two of my wholesalers and a number of the public aquarium management teams I know, use a filtration such as diatom filter or similar. The trick of course is having adequate water turnover.
 
Even though I am QTing everything wet that goes into my DT currently, I have never QT'd anything prior to this experience and I have been keeping freshwater fish for over 30 years so I can give my two cents on why I didn't in the past...

My main reason is not the money or space, but the time and energy that goes into QT. Not only keeping up with the meds and what doses and figuring out how much to add during water changes to keep the correct levels and separating all the equipment and washing my hands 2,000 times a day so I do not cross contaminate and disinfecting the tank in between QT's and worrying about cycling the tank, (before we had starter bacteria so readily available) each time etc...

The only reason I am going through all that now is that I knew from the beginning that I wanted a bunch of Tangs and I kept hearing how susceptible they are to ICH and Velvet. I never really worried about ICH with freshwater because it is much easier to treat and you don't need a separate tank to treat them like you do with a reef tank.
 
I am surprised more people, and wholesalers don't use diatom filters. They are not that expensive and the diatom powder, if purchased from a pool supply is very cheap. They will remove parasites without altering water quality.

I personally don't need it for that reason but I do use my diatom sometimes when I collect NSW because I take it from the shore and it is filled with particles and sand. But if I were worried about parasites, I would use it in a "quarantine" tank or any tank where I was worried about parasites.
It won't cure a fish but it will keep new parasites from re-infecting your tank.

A diatom filter will remove anything smaller than about a micron, parasites are much larger than that.
Just a thought.
They still sell Vortex Diatoms? I haven’t seen one since Comic books had sea monkey adds and that Pet Place sold Supreme Aquaking filter
 
Sounds stupid but I always saw fish as much smarter than most people do and with emotions and memory. (This is my veiwpoint on even the coral .) I just want to make as happy and suitable environment for them as possible , and always keep cleaner fish and animals in my tanks with fish. I think they are traumatized by QT and the whole capture /shipping display tank in store deal to begin with. I have never lost a fish or cross infected a fish this way, but I also pick healthy specimens to start with and only buy fish from 3 suppliers ever.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top