Getting a new tank?

Lalaallieu

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Oct 16, 2019
Messages
115
Reaction score
134
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I'm planning to get a new tank sometime soon. I'm thinking of looking at Petsmarts black friday/cyber monday sales. Have you used a HOB filter? I've used them but never noticed anything bad. I'd like to get a nice big tank, but I'm unsure. I have my 13.5 now. I know a bigger tank will be a lot more money. Especially with lights being so expensive. What size tank would you upgrade to? I know a lot of their big 60+ gal tanks are on sale right now. I'm looking for a tank/stand combo. I'd love to get a red sea reefer or waterbox one day, but I don't have 2,000 to drop all at once. We plan to buy this tank and set it up piece by piece. One of the stores I talked to said Petsmarts tanks aren't good because a HOB filter sucks and won't be adequate for my tank. Insights? What do you do?
 
I would get with the biggest I can afford. Like you said, the bigger tank will be more $$$. Now, if you want to drill the tank, a 75g (4') or a 125g (6') will be good but make sure the glass is not tempered so you can drill the tank. If you don't want to drill the tank then a HOB filter like a Aquaclear 110 will be great.
 
Go to petco when they’re having their $1 gallon sale and get a 75. I would drill the back for a overflow. Prob the cheapest way into a larger tank.
 
I'm planning to get a new tank sometime soon. I'm thinking of looking at Petsmarts black friday/cyber monday sales. Have you used a HOB filter? I've used them but never noticed anything bad. I'd like to get a nice big tank, but I'm unsure. I have my 13.5 now. I know a bigger tank will be a lot more money. Especially with lights being so expensive. What size tank would you upgrade to? I know a lot of their big 60+ gal tanks are on sale right now. I'm looking for a tank/stand combo. I'd love to get a red sea reefer or waterbox one day, but I don't have 2,000 to drop all at once. We plan to buy this tank and set it up piece by piece. One of the stores I talked to said Petsmarts tanks aren't good because a HOB filter sucks and won't be adequate for my tank. Insights? What do you do?
I’d put together a budget and see where you can go with it. Don’t rush it and plan it well. A lot of people seek out a tank they like and then build around it. It’s best to find a tank you like and then see what equipment you need and how much it will cost. HOB filters aren’t efficient for 60g tanks imo. Perhaps HOB filters have come around in recent years but back when I used them, they weren’t fit for larger tanks.
 
you may also check out petco’s dollar per gallon sale. I did something similar to your plan with my current build, picked up a 40 breeder and stand for $99 dollars during the dollar per gallon sale at petco and then added necessary equipment as I was able to purchase it.. I’m at about $1700 total invested in tank and all equipment but that was spread out over about 15 months.

HOB filters can work but IMO not the best idea.. I purchased a hang on overflow and sump for about $180, you can even go cheaper by using a something like a 20 gallon tank as your sump ($20 petco).

check out my budget build thread for inspiration ;)

DF0A3A28-3A57-44B1-BFF4-0F1B4D7B6ACF.png

9D00C716-9263-42D0-803A-CF468756B5F8.png
 
I'm planning to get a new tank sometime soon. I'm thinking of looking at Petsmarts black friday/cyber monday sales. Have you used a HOB filter? I've used them but never noticed anything bad. I'd like to get a nice big tank, but I'm unsure. I have my 13.5 now. I know a bigger tank will be a lot more money. Especially with lights being so expensive. What size tank would you upgrade to? I know a lot of their big 60+ gal tanks are on sale right now. I'm looking for a tank/stand combo. I'd love to get a red sea reefer or waterbox one day, but I don't have 2,000 to drop all at once. We plan to buy this tank and set it up piece by piece. One of the stores I talked to said Petsmarts tanks aren't good because a HOB filter sucks and won't be adequate for my tank. Insights? What do you do?

Take a few minutes to read through WV Reefer's threads and read about her tanks. She runs all of her tanks with only lights, powerheads and a heater. Cost effective and it works.

75 gallon - https://www.nano-reef.com/forums/topic/382297-wv-reefers-75-gallon-big-and-dirty/

12 gallon - https://www.nano-reef.com/featured/2018/wv-reefers-12-gal-long-and-dirty-nano-reef-aquarium/
 
Such a loaded question :)

Are you just feeling cramped by your 13 gallon and want a new, larger "first" tank.... or are you looking to buy your forever tank?
Both I suppose, maybe not my forever tank because I absolutely want a Red Sea reefer one day, but it’s not in the budget currently
 
I am in Terre Haute!

This is a good deal..... will get you running.... may just be bigger than you want.



This may seem like a lot of money initially, but for what you get.... this seems like a great deal to me.... offer $1k cash maybe........




Edit: Just saw the 40W UV too. I would 100% just pay the $1,200 and swoop this. I may take a day off of work and beat you to it..... this is a steal.
 
Last edited:
I would be patient and find what you want. I never buy tanks from retail stores Except for 1 20 gallon long hospital tank from pEtco . Past 3 tanks I bought were on Craigslist in Asheville You see a lot of people that just want to get rid of there tank at nothing . My last tank I bought a year ago was a 80 gallon deep blue rimless tank, eshopps r300 sump ,pump and etc for $400! It was like brand new . I just saw a Red Sea 450 on Craigslist that is a great deal but I can’t handle another tank right now .
Like you I would never spend 3 or 4K on a new tank when I can buy much cheaper !
Good luck.
 
This is a good deal..... will get you running.... may just be bigger than you want.



This may seem like a lot of money initially, but for what you get.... this seems like a great deal to me.... offer $1k cash maybe........


Both great deals. That second one is really nice! You could post those pics up on here and peeps would tell you "beautiful tank." Hope that guy is able to find a buyer that will take it whole.

Lalaallieu I get it. The heart wants what the heart wants. I'd gladly take one too if they cost 1/3 as much ;)
I'd never begrudge anyone spending money. You can have an even nicer system for considerably less though. Tanks really aren't that expensive. It's everything else. I try to think in terms of "custom" instead of DIY.. lol. A lot of my stuff is "custom." But, seriously, you can have a beautiful stand and canopy built for you and have a used tank buffed or resealed and come in at half the price.

If you want to ride a motorcycle through the desert and go see California, it doesn't really matter if you're on a Honda or a BMW.
 
Both great deals. That second one is really nice! You could post those pics up on here and peeps would tell you "beautiful tank." Hope that guy is able to find a buyer that will take it whole.

I just saw the 40w UV and Curve 7, etc. I am tempted to grab it. Full tank and all? It’s expensive, rock etc.... adds up fast
 
I just saw the 40w UV and Curve 7, etc. I am tempted to grab it. Full tank and all? It’s expensive, rock etc.... adds up fast
You could buy that, keep what you want, and sell off the rest at a tidy profit. I'd feel bad doing that though when the seller could have done the same and probably just wants a good home for his critters.
 
You could buy that, keep what you want, and sell off the rest at a tidy profit. I'd feel bad doing that though when the seller could have done the same and probably just wants a good home for his critters.

Oh, if I were to buy it, it’d all be used! I just gotta figure out if it’s worth it to me to take down my Max Nano to set up another much bigger tank, and grow out more fun stuff.
 
I'm also looking to up grade my tank after the new year. In February. I couple hours drive for a 90 g marineland reef ready tank. Some months 349.99 other months as low as 249.99 for a marineland reef ready tank. Worth the 2 hour drive.
 
Hello,

I saw one mentioned but first wanna say welcome to R2R where pretty much everyone is your uncle bob. To be fair and honest I have never bought a new tank. (Hold that thought ) but for example my whole setup tank stand sump etc on my 240 gallon that was only 6 months old was approx 500 out the door. My old 125 with almost everything was only 300. If you take your time you can find almost brand new tanks large ones for very little. Yes I have a new 425 gallon but lol I didn’t buy it, my parents gave it to me as a graduation gift and sadly because I had to move it’s still in a big massive wood box. (I haven’t even opened or alone had it delivered but anyway), don’t get set on the more you pay the better. That’s not true and yes some leds are very expensive (we all know the names), but Chinese black boxes, some of the current usa brands and others are 1/10 the cost and actually do a better job.

The same goes with wave makers etc, they are all about the same and they all eventually break if one keeps soaking them in vinegar. I would definitely get a good heater, and if you want quiet dc return pumps and dc co trolled skimmers are super quiet (my eshopps s300 is non dc but still super quiet). I’d stay away from old old equipment simply if it fails you can’t find parts.

Another idea is be creative in a beta tester type. I mean it’s how I fell in love with current usa, I called every company to see if they wanted beta testers and they would send their newest toy for you to test for free. Now let’s clarify (one I was a student at the time and I could prove my research was related and was part of my major). I don’t know how that would work errr now, although current still lets me and they are amazing. A few smaller companies did also but I don’t see them around any more. Also check with your local aquarium they have more stuff on hand than you can imagine. It’s neat because they technically can’t sell it but they can donate it. Again when I was starting I did volunteer work and some extra parts here and there didn’t cost me anything. Plus I was able to spend time on something I love doing. If you look at my thread (other than coral), my whole setup was under 1,000 and I have a pretty extensive setup. With that said I (was a student for part of it, and volunteered for other sections (For those who think other motives were involved (leave it alone because there are none). So depending on aka if your a student and (majoring in a field that’s relevant ahhh really helps, majoring in aeronautical Astro physics as impressive as is, may not help much). Aquariums love love volunteers because they have a very tiny budget and can’t really pay most staff members. A lot of undergraduates would volunteer and low
And behold they now have a salt tank. I can not say every aquarium does this or practices this, but the ones I did, were very generous and extremely professional.
Your dream tank doesn’t have to cost you much money, or just needs a really good plan of action and commitment.

Sincerely
Sarah
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top