Getting overwhelmed...

On Friday I plan to get some rock and my own testing stuff. Will also look into a wave box.
r/o will be on the list but my fish budget is a-little slimmed down because of the baby due in a month....

there has been really good advice here and I appreciate it greatly. The hard coral and red finger are things my wife wanted lol so yes I should do a lot more research and just not allow things to go in there. This is my third time at coral and some of it is doing really well. The zoas I am really happy about :)
As far a the lights... I’m not sure. Right now the two strips of led seem to be doing a better job but the hard coral hasn’t really perked up much. I think I see the polyps out on the bird nest when the the lights are not though.
 
@CuzzA is "spot-on" with his recommendations and is not "father lecturing" you. He like, many others (hundreds) here on R2R have gone through similar circumstances as you are currently. And have made the same mistakes trying to cut corners or go inexpensive with gear trying to achieve results that quality gear has proven to produce. Trust me I bought Amazon stuff and Ebay stuff trying to save money and trying to have an "insta reef", and over time I've ended up biting the bullet and buying good gear. Yes it's expensive but it's cheaper than buying stuff that you'll eventually replace in the near future. Well truth is you can't rush or fool nature. If anything @CuzzA is trying to save you from wasting money.

Cold hard facts, if you're on a budget (as mentioned with baby on the way) start off with simple corals & fish. Sure they're not going to be show tank magazine phenoms but you'll still enjoy the satisfaction of keeping them alive. Patience is is one part of this hobby and if you rush things or think you have a better way - you're going to get bit. "If you buy a farm, you're NOT an instant farmer"

The other side of this coin (which may not be obvious yet now that this is in your blood) take your time & research each and every fish, coral, piece of gear and make an educated decision as to what you want/need next. We ALL go through this phase and we want a beautiful, successful reef but you can't buy an "insta-reef" (many have tried) It's nature, there's no guide or owners manual how to "build the perfect reef tank". The variables are in the millions and each of us has to wade are way through the info to make it work in our tanks.

I'll give you my own personal "bonehead" start. - I bought a 60gal long tank & stand from Petco years ago. I bought sand, live rock, salt etc. But I went w/dual Current USA LEDs (because they were cheap). I also went w/2 canister filters, an Ebay hang on the back skimmer and then ordered coral & fish online. Tank looked good initially (so I thought) but corals died shortly afterwards, buy more same result. Started testing, shooting blindly buying bigger pumps, powerheads etc and still the nightmare continued. Finally after spending nearly 5 times what I planned on and researching, I bought a sump, a skimmer to fit and quality LEDs. I literally flushed $4k down the drain because I thought I could do it "on the cheap". This is what all of us here are trying to help you avoid. Take your time, research, ask questions, then ask more questions.

Good luck (Btw - it's a boy...lol)
 
I def get what your saying. To be honest though not everyone on this site has 10k into their tanks thought many do I’m sure.

im great at taking constructive criticism but this post has made me both a better reffer and two the beloved my tank is horrible.

Everything in my tank seems to be doing good other then a few bad choices a coral show.

passions is great.
 
I def get what your saying. To be honest though not everyone on this site has 10k into their tanks thought many do I’m sure.

im great at taking constructive criticism but this post has made me both a better reffer and two the beloved my tank is horrible.

Everything in my tank seems to be doing good other then a few bad choices a coral show.

passions is great.

The whole purpose was to make you a better reefer and to save you money & heartbreak. Your tank is not horrible, just in transition and we're trying to help you make it better to reach your goals. That's what this forum is about, helping, sharing info to push the hobby forward in a positive direction. There's a million vendors out there who have the perfect solution and we're barraged w/info and "deals" but the bottom line is - those of us who have stumbled through those things are trying to help others like yourself avoid those pitfalls.
 
Thanks. Since I can’t go right about and spend a crap load on lights I will stick to the earlier coral and also work on a sump.

it will have to be around 20g correct? ( I will do a lot more research, just thinking about where I can fit it with my stand and kid )
 
Concentrate on being a new parent and the tank will follow. When the pressures of daily life start getting to you, the tank will be your solstice, your place of "level" or balance. Once you grasp that, all the rest around you falls into place.

Re: sump - whatever fits in your cabinet. It's just a space that gives you extra water capacity, a place for gear (heaters, skimmer,etc ) that would normally be an eyesore in your tank and a place for filtration (refugium, filter socks) And you don't have to spend bundles of $$$.

Take your time (Time is on your side) read, research and you'll be amazed when things level out on "cruise control". That's the goal - a nice tank, easy maintenance and enjoying both the journey and the results.

Happy reefing!
 
Concentrate on being a new parent and the tank will follow. When the pressures of daily life start getting to you, the tank will be your solstice, your place of "level" or balance. Once you grasp that, all the rest around you falls into place.

Re: sump - whatever fits in your cabinet. It's just a space that gives you extra water capacity, a place for gear (heaters, skimmer,etc ) that would normally be an eyesore in your tank and a place for filtration (refugium, filter socks) And you don't have to spend bundles of $$$.

Take your time (Time is on your side) read, research and you'll be amazed when things level out on "cruise control". That's the goal - a nice tank, easy maintenance and enjoying both the journey and the results.

Happy reefing!
Kid number 2... need the distraction this time lol the few hours I get alone at night. Also my two year old is obsessed with the fish lol
 
I'm in the same boat. I have 3 kids and one on the way plus a 65 gallon and starting a 250 gallon tank. I have a easy sump set up and Ebay marsaqua led lights and have had success. I have acro sps and a clam. I do bare minimum unfortunately but if I see things off or looking a bit closed I always go to what works. Water changes. If you can keep salinity and temp the same water changes help a ton.
20200127_220830.jpg

20200128_201351.jpg

I run majority soft corals with fun color and a few acro cuz I got them as small frag for cheap. This tanks been up a year but I've been in the hobby for about 14 yrs
 
In these pictures, all your lighting looks weak to me. Perhaps it is just the look of the pics ofc. and I keep an anemone and it does take a stronger light than many corals, but do you know the PAR output on your light and does it match your types of corals?
 
Last edited:
With mixed corals like that, my guess would be that your skimmerpower will have strong say in the coral growth.

Oh, also corals that will capture prey might appreciate that you flush the system with zooplankton when you introduce them, that will help kick out shock from their system after transfers.
 
Last edited:
the simple sump ,100% perfect run them love them
 
So I got a slimmer that’s HOB but rated above my tank size.

the guy who said my tank was smaller then I thought was right... sorry I dismissed it so quick.

The birds nest more or less dead but at least I know what I can keep until I get new lights.

ordered: Red Sea Fish Pharm ARE21525 Marine Care Test Kit for Aquarium so I no longer have to rely on lfs for testing.


thnaks.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%

New Posts

Back
Top