Gyre or MP40?

[Jaylivi1212]

I have a 110G high and i'm thinking about getting either a maxspect 250 Gyre to run horizontal and have 2 mp40 on the left side and right side of the back. Or should i just use 4 mp40s?
2 going horizontal and 2 on the back wall.

 

[Cherub]

i have 2 mp40s on a 5 foot long 133 gallon tank and that's plenty. i have an overpowered return pump though and split return to help flow. 4 pumps seems like a bit much?

 

[reef4beer]

Go for the mp40s, had a 110G as well and was not impressed with the gyre.

You should be fine with 2 mp40s tbh

 

[Fritzhamer]

For what it's worth, I ran the gyre and sold it. It required constant cleaning to function properly. It was also loud. I've also run mp40s but don't like the giant wart on the outside of the tank. They also have trouble reaching four feet, IME. Plus EVERYONE that isn't a reefer grabs the dry side and says "what's this?", moving it out of alignment.

If I can make a third suggestion, the Tunze 6055 is small, amiable, controllable and reaches four feet easy. You can hook up a few to an apex and make them do anything you want or leave them on their own controllers. The icecap battery backup can run one for a long time if need be.

 

[Jaylivi1212]

i have 2 mp40s on a 5 foot long 133 gallon tank and that's plenty. i have an overpowered return pump though and split return to help flow. 4 pumps seems like a bit much?

Would I place them horizontal or?

Go for the mp40s, had a 110G as well and was not impressed with the gyre.

You should be fine with 2 mp40s tbh

I was worried about dead spots in the back due to my current rockwork.

For what it's worth, I ran the gyre and sold it. It required constant cleaning to function properly. It was also loud. I've also run mp40s but don't like the giant wart on the outside of the tank. They also have trouble reaching four feet, IME. Plus EVERYONE that isn't a reefer grabs the dry side and says "what's this?", moving it out of alignment.

If I can make a third suggestion, the Tunze 6055 is small, amiable, controllable and reaches four feet easy. You can hook up a few to an apex and make them do anything you want or leave them on their own controllers. The icecap battery backup can run one for a long time if need be.

I'll look into that.

 

[TominiReef250]

I was running a mp40 on my reefer 250. I wasn't happy with just that so I bought the ice cap which is a cheaper gyre bit works great I have no promble and I have both running now my tank happy as a clam. Run both the gyre a must I fell in love with it

 

[Cherub]

Just one on each side. I have one higher than the other and do the lagoon mode so flow changes slightly through the day. Get the wireless kind if you do MP40 so they communicate with each other

 

[Jaylivi1212]

Just one on each side. I have one higher than the other and do the lagoon mode so flow changes slightly through the day. Get the wireless kind if you do MP40 so they communicate with each other

Ye. I plan to hook it up with my Neptune Apex.

 

[reef4beer]

Just one on each side. I have one higher than the other and do the lagoon mode so flow changes slightly through the day. Get the wireless kind if you do MP40 so they communicate with each other

Agree, you'd be amazed the coverage they have specially with them synced together in different modes.

 

[roberthu526]

I really like my gyres. They move the water through out the tank and leaves virtually no dead spots if your rock work is relatively open.

 

[chefjpaul]

I run both in an elos 120.
X2 mp40 & a gyre in back

 

[Swoody]

I have a Gyre 150 vertically on the back of my 135G to keep flow behind my rockwork with an MP40 on one end of the tank and a Jebao rw8 on the other....Getting another MP40 soon to replace the rw8......I have no flow problems in my tank! I have had no problems with noise, performance or extra maintenance on the Gyre and have only totally disassembled it once in a year. IMO you are probably good either way.

 

[leepink23]

Another option is the wav since you are running an apex. I have 3 on a 150 running max 50%, pushes water on a 4 foot tank with no problem.

 

[TominiReef250]

I like them both really happy running the two . Try the ice cap it's really nice

 

[Reefltx]

Run both, I have 2x gyre and mp40s in my reefer 350.

 

[mcarroll]

Neither option.

Try a pair of Tunzes.


Turbelle® stream 6105
For aquariums from 200 to 2,000 liters (52 to 528 USgal.) Flow rate: 3,000 up to approx. 13,000 l... mehr

285.00 USD

...or for a smaller form factor...


Turbelle® nanostream® 6055
For aquariums from 40 to 500 liters (10.6 to 132 USgal.). Flow rate: 1,000 to about 5,500 l/h (25... mehr

184.99 USD

But they also make more interesting pumps like these which would also be appropriate to consider:

[URL='https://www.tunze.com/US/en/products/details.html?user_tunzeprod_pi1%5Bprodid%5D=6150.000']
Turbelle® stream 3
for aquariums up to 3.000 liters (793 USgal.) Circulation performance: 2,500 l/h (660 USgal./h) to ... mehr
[/URL]
344.89 USD
[URL='https://www.tunze.com/US/en/products/details.html?user_tunzeprod_pi1%5Bprodid%5D=6040.000']

[/URL]
Turbelle® nanostream® 6040
For aquariums from 20 to 500 liters (5.3 to 132 USgal.) Flow rate: approx. 200 to 4,500 l/h (53... mehr

140.30 USD

 

[mcarroll]

From the Tunze forum:
Flow reach by pump model?

That might help you decide which pumps would be the best to consider.

These videos might also be interesting:



2:08
Interzoo 2016: TUNZE® Turbelle® Stream 3 - First unboxing
2.9K views1 year ago






1:07
2 Tunze® Turbelle® Stream3 creating a wave and a directional current
5.5K views1 year ago






1:06
Only one Tunze® Turbelle® Stream3 creating a gyre flow in the Interzoo 2016 show tank
3.8K views1 year ago

 

[mcarroll]

And of course:



9:37
Flow vs. turbulence

33K views6 years ago

What does the video mean.... There has been much discussion about the Flow Vs. Turbulence video and what it means and what it shows. Many misinterpret what they are seeing as wide flow vs focu...

 

[newfishkeeper88]

The gyre controller is a nightmare compared to the Mp40. I had a gyre 230 and took it off and got mp40s on the 350, the controller of the gyre is just isn't user friendly

 

[TominiReef250]

The controller a little bit more difficult to use, only because its a lot more advanced you can set it to move water forward and backwards throughout the day so your corals not getting blasted from one side. It was designed by reefers.. Just look it up bulk reef supply does a nice detail review on it watch it...