Harlequin tusk in a mixed reef

Glenn Siegel

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Jul 7, 2018
Messages
186
Reaction score
133
What state or country do you live in
Florida
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I have a 300 gallon well-stocked mixed reef . I understand that hermit crabs and snails are at risk. My fish are very well fed. The Coral is predominately euphelia, leathers, and also have some nems.

Anyone have or had a tusk with any thoughts in this setting? Anyone have or had one with any feedback?

Thanks
 
They will be fine with coral but as you noted crustaceans will be on the menu. I would also be concerned about very small fish in the 1-2” range.
 
I had an Australian Tusk a few years ago, what a great looking fish! Crabs and snails didn't stand a chance, it also moved soft coral frags. It didn't bother any of the other fish - a purple tang, blue throat trigger, foxface.
 
I always have an Harlequin Tusk in my reef, 420 and 320 gal DT. I have no problem with him. I have losts of small wrasses, cleaner shrimp. No crab other than anemone crabs. Small fish like Orchid dottyback, Yellow tail blue damsels, Royal Gramma are all OK. He heat all of my sub 5 mm snails. I don't have hermit crabs other shrimp.
Need to feed him well, and if you add any small fish into the tank, do it after he went to sleep, or else he will have expensive dinner. He just cannot resist disoriented fish or shrimp.
 
I've had differnt harlequin tusk specimens in different reef tanks. The majority were fine inhabitants. However, a minority, but still significant percentage, were aggressive to other wrasses.
 
I agree with @eatbreakfast .....I have tried two different times where they were model citizens for months....then turned on other wrasses. Definitely couldn't ever add any additional wrasses after the Tusk was established either.
 
Great fish. One of my favorites. Fine with coral. Shrimp may be okay if they are in the tank first when the tusk is introduced, but there's always a risk there. Adding a shrimp later most likely would just trigger the eating response from the tusk (after all, fish get accustomed to us dumping food in to them, so adding a shrimp might be viewed the same way). Smaller fish like chromis and other wrasses are probably not good to keep with the tusk, although I think you might be able to manage another wrasse in a large tank....personally, I don't like stressing my fish and smaller wrasses can be irritating to a tusk. Snails and crabs are likely to be snacks for the tusk. My hermit crabs fares fairly well, but any snail my tusk could get a hold of its shell was a goner. Turbo snails were usually too large for my tusk to grab but any cone shaped snail like trochus got killed in short order. I'd really hate that a lot if the snails would get pieces bitten out of them and would live for a while before dying and rotting in the shell. I had to watch snail shells and if they didn't move after a day or so, then I'd check them. I never realized how much cleaning my snails did until my tusk decimated them all. I love the fish, though !
 
Thanks for the responses. One the fence. Found a 4 in. aussie. I am also adding a trio of Lennardi Wrasses (about 3 inch) as soon as they go through QT in a few weeks. Love the HT but would certainly not want an issue with the Lennardi's.
 
Lennardi are a very difficult species that fails to thrive in reef temps. I only know of 1 longterm success story with them.
 
Lennardi are a very difficult species that fails to thrive in reef temps. I only know of 1 longterm success story with them.
I know they are difficult. I have my tank temperature on the colder side which I am hoping will help with them. My immediate concern is whether there could be an issue with the tusk and other wrasses.
 
I've had differnt harlequin tusk specimens in different reef tanks. The majority were fine inhabitants. However, a minority, but still significant percentage, were aggressive to other wrasses.

I had a large tusk that would grab large food-stuffs and bash it against the rocks to break it up. Not a problem in a fish only system but would have been a nightmare in a reef tank...
 
I know they are difficult. I have my tank temperature on the colder side which I am hoping will help with them. My immediate concern is whether there could be an issue with the tusk and other wrasses.
How much colder though? 72 is on the high end for them....
 
I assume urchins would be on the menu also? How about a larger turbo snail?
 
Mine east all crabs and snails, regardless of how big or small. Great fish to have but inverts will eventually be picked off. My clam was also eaten, but am not sure if that was him or not.
 
Interesting thread, Ive always considered them a quintessential saltwater fish and would live to put one in my 300 eventually. I enjoyed hearing about all your opinions and it seems to be the consistent in several regards.
 
Uh oh... I have a harlequin tusk in my tank. Just ordered a mystery wrasse... It's a 220 gallon tank. Am I hearing I should not add the mystery??
 
Uh oh... I have a harlequin tusk in my tank. Just ordered a mystery wrasse... It's a 220 gallon tank. Am I hearing I should not add the mystery??

Hopefully it works out, but I’d put my $ on the tuskfish.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top