How to make a Tank Last for 40 years with few problems

  • Thread starter Thread starter Paul B
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users None
Scott, I use earthworms whenever I see them but my fish are all too small for them now unless I chop them small. I use live white worms which I grow and live blackworms which I get at an LFS. I also buy live clams and freeze them myself.
Here is some of my log book.




 
Then the finished product. My reef is supported off the gravel by these which are simple to build and almost free. I wrote an article about how to build them if you like. (it is also in my book but if you read my threads you can get all that information)

So, this appears to be PVC and acrylic that you bent (and burned a little) with a torch, and then covered it in what looks like hydraulic cement, yes?

Did you do this 40 years ago when you started the tank? Because I am wondering, what gave you the idea, or for what reason did you build these as apposed to just making a pile of dry or live rock to form the same thing? I can sure think of reasons why, but I am wondering what yours are/were.


My reef was started with NSW but now I am older and it doesn't get any lighter so I only have a very little NSW in my tank because I didn't collect any this year. When I move shortly, I will fill the tank with NSW as I will be near the beach.

Did you pour it right in the tank, or did you "cure" or filter it in any way? As I mentioned, the guy I knew many years ago who did this had 32-gallon trash barrels in his garage and he would run air stones for days before using it. I don't exactly know what he was doing though...

The sand worms are great and you can freeze them and chop them small. Your home freezer won't kill the bacteria so they are good as are the clams. You can get the clams at the bait shop or a supermarket and freeze them. It is better if you can buy themalive and freeze them yourself because in a bait shop they could have been frozen 5 years ago.

OK, so sounds like I have some flexibility here. If I were to buy a box of the worms, or the clams and I could freeze them and use them over weeks / months, that would not be so bad if they don't need to be kept alive.

I went to a new LFS that opened today, and they had a selection of frozen food:
- Krill
- Silversides
- Brine shrimp
- Bloodworms
- Mysis shrimp
- Beef heart
- Then a bunch of combination things including vegetarian stuff (various cubes)

Are these options?

My tank is also 6' long. It's hard to tell but most of my rock is above the gravel.

You will also have to use something like LRS food which is excellent as it will be a pain to get all natural worms and clams.

Yeah, that LRS food looks great.

I wrote many threads on here that address your questions.

Understood, I will look for them so that I don't ask the same questions over again. I will see if I can get to the point where I would be comfortable with these ideas. Certainly I will incorporate some of it, and maybe more in the future.

Still thinking on the undergravel filter, did you know that you are #1 in Google searches for that?

I was hoping to use sand on this tank.... which probably won't work, would have to use dolomite or similar.

Thank you for taking the time to respond and for your great information.

-JCL
 
Scott, I use earthworms whenever I see them but my fish are all too small for them now unless I chop them small. I use live white worms which I grow and live blackworms which I get at an LFS. I also buy live clams and freeze them myself.
Here is some of my log book.




Very neat, thanks for sharing. How much success did you have with the copper band Long term? did you get them to eat frozen foods?
 
JCL, I made those pillare maybe 30 years ago to support my rocks because they only have small areas touching the gravel. Real rock is to big and covers to much area. Originally I did have the rock on the gravel like everyone else. I invented that type of rock after many experiments. I like it because it is cheap, hollow and easy to build. It is regular cement or mortor mix.
NSW I use as it is from the sea. I just strain out jellyfish and sticks. I use it right away. If you store it it will become cloudy for a few days as the bacteria die, then it will clear up. Ether way it is fine to use.

I would not use any of those foods you listed. The worms may be OK but clams are your best choice. They are filter feeders and have a lot of minerals and bacteria. Great food.

Scott, my copperbands always live for many years. My current one I got as a baby and now is about 5" long. They can live 15 or 20 years if they don't jump out. He will eat anything that is not dry.
In the 70s I probably couldn't keep them for many years but after a while I figured out how to keep my fish immune so now I never have a fish die from disease.
 
Hello Paul

You always provide a very interesting read it certainly impossible or at least down right close to impossible to argue with your success. For those reasons I am going to implement many of your methods in the new reef tank I am starting. Can you tell me specifically how you feed something like clams ? If I were to freeze them and slice them thinly, do you chop them extremely small for the smaller fish? Same with the other live foods?

By the way although I live in North Carolina now, I'm a Long Island boy at heart, born and raised in Freeport. Spent most of my childhood fishing on the family boat out of Jones Inlet .
 
Scott, I get clams at a supermarket, fish store, bait shop of collect them myself. Blackworms I get at an LFS and white worms I raise from a culture.

Andy, nice to meet another Long Island boy. I get chowder clams live, freeze them, open them and shave off paper thin slices like you would shave chocolate. Make a dent and keep scraping. The pieces are tissue thin so smaller fish have no problems with them. I shave them thicker for larger fish.





 
Now I am not saying they have remembered but they have certainly been conditioned to recognise that the tube means food is imminent. Is there a difference between memory and conditioning? Am not sure but somebody with an ology will be along shortly to explain I guess. :)

I feed my fish frozen food now. I use a box of Menthos to defrost the food.
As soon as my fish see me shaking that box, they get very agitated and out in the open, to the point where even my wife noted "you've added more fish?" as usually, they are not so obviously out in the open. And I'm not standing near the aquarium, they see me across the room.
 
Paul B, thanks for a very interesting read! Even for a noob such as I. I noticed in your notes that your French Angel died around the same day that I was born. Don't know what that means, but I take it as a sign. For something.

I understand that much of what you write aren't for noobs. I'm in the process of planning out and saving up for my very first reef tank. So i'm definitely one of them. But if you would give at least some advice from all of this that also could be used by new reefers what would that be? I'm afraid I'm slipping further and further down the sterile tank path at the moment. But if there could be at least some elements from your advice that I could try to implement that would be very good I think. Collecting wild and healthy (for the fish) food seems to be one of them.
 
And I'm not standing near the aquarium, they see me across the room.

My fish constantly text me to see when I am coming home. :rolleyes:

Mandelstam, the reason I normally tell people my advice is not for Noobs is because many people feel my methods are weird, out of the box, impossible to do or just won't work. Most hobbiests are young so they don't realize that my methods are not new or odd, they are the methods us old timers started with and over the years we tweeked them, before the internet was invented so we don't have all the wrong knowledge that virtually all inside the box thinkers possess. I use a reverse UG filter, you will find maybe three people who do and thousands who will say it can't work, yet it is the oldest tank on here. Those people just never used one or used it wrong.
If I say that parasites and bacteria is a good thing, I will get hate mail because most people can't, or won't understand that because the internet teaches otherwise even though my fish have not been sick in decades.
But it is only me and maybe three or four old timers with healthy tanks that never get sick. Everyone else quarantines and as you probably know, I feel that is the worst thing you can do if you want long term, healthy, spawning fish. I am outnumbered thousands to one and I am old so I don't want or need to argue.
Read the disease threads and see how many sick fish there are in quarantined tanks and you will always read that it is because either they didn't quarantine a rock, coral or sand. I believe fish should never get sick.
Of course you could run a sterile tank and quarantine everything as that is one way to go.

In the first page of this thread I lay out how I would start a tank now from scratch.
I would just set up the tank, cycle it, put in some fish, not the most expensive fish, feed them food with live bacteria in it and don't worry about parasites unless a fish is obviousely covered in them.
Keep feeding fresh food like live worms or clams with absolutely no dry foods. No pellets, no flakes and God Forbid, no freeze dried.
If you live near the sea I would put some NSW in there along with some rocks or anything you can collect that has wild copepods or amphipods on it.
Thats about it. Good luck what ever you do. :p
 
Last edited:
My fish constantly text me to see when I am coming home. :rolleyes:

Mandelstam, the reason I normally tell people my advice is not for Noobs is because many people feel my methods are weird, out of the box, impossible to do or just won't work. Most hobbiests are young so they don't realize that my methods are not new or odd, they are the methods us

[...]

Thats about it. Good luck what ever you do. :p

Thanks again Paul, I really appreciate your view on things and I agree with the things I understand lol. I try to treat my kids the same way. I've never told them to wash their hands before dinner, only after.. :p We need dirt and bugs to keep healthy. This obsessive behavior around bacteria and keeping our homes and ourselves as sterile as an operation room I've never understood. To get an immunity and a defense against something we need to be exposed to it first. Like soldiers need to train.

I live by the ocean but unfortunately it's just at the end of the Baltic ocean where the salinity hasn't yet reached normal ocean levels, it's only around 12ppt/1.0058g/cm3. But could you start with that and add salt instead of starting with ro/di maybe? I will go fish for some proper food!
 
Here where I live the salinity is also very low so I have to add salt.
 
My fish constantly text me to see when I am coming home. :rolleyes:

Mandelstam, the reason I normally tell people my advice is not for Noobs is because many people feel my methods are weird, out of the box, impossible to do or just won't work. Most hobbiests are young so they don't realize that my methods are not new or odd, they are the methods us old timers started with and over the years we tweeked them, before the internet was invented so we don't have all the wrong knowledge that virtually all inside the box thinkers possess.



.... :p


LOL and a big +1

You should (possibly not) seen the reaction(s) to my planted tanks (now dubed the beaslbob build) on other boards. People who think water changes are the only method to maintain tanks just don't get it. Let alone as you stated these methods are not only effective but the oldest most successful methods around. Dating back to before electricity and glass tanks.

Funny thing is they work and feedback I've gotten from newbies are not only encouraging but amazed.

Still just my (our?) .02
 
Last edited:
Beas, I have been getting hate mail for many years from people who think I am saying these things for the shock value or I want people's tanks to crash. I have always tried to help people but for some reason my methods seem weird. I don't get it. Many people work so hard at this and I feel it is fairly easy but the internet makes it more complicated than it is. I am not that smart and I can do it so I am sure anyone can. I think we over think this too much. :eek:
 
Beas, I have been getting hate mail for many years from people who think I am saying these things for the shock value or I want people's tanks to crash. I have always tried to help people but for some reason my methods seem weird. I don't get it. Many people work so hard at this and I feel it is fairly easy but the internet makes it more complicated than it is. I am not that smart and I can do it so I am sure anyone can. I think we over think this too much. :eek:

Well at least you get a reaction Paul.... I just get ignored when I post similar things, in fact sometimes I think I am the only one who can actually see my posts. :confused:
What you have to remember is some people have difficulty thinking outside the box and think your as mad as a box of frogs, one sandwich short of a picnic or just plain crazy. ;Wacky It goes against what all the "experts" have been telling them and many of them selling lots of nice bottles with pretty fish and corals on them...so it must be right what they say and you are wrong or even lying but what many can't figure out is what are you wanting to sell them ;)
 
I guess so. Sometimes I spend 45 minutes writing something that I feel is earth shaking and I get no responses. :confused:
Maybe I should take up golf. :eek:
 
Keeping your reef sterile and unnatural sells more equipment/additives/controllers.
 
Awesome approach!! Love it and have been doing it myself. However I can see many trying and failing.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top