How to tell if tank has cycled

Barker88

Community Member
View Badges
Joined
Aug 2, 2015
Messages
53
Reaction score
1
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I need some advice I have a clean up crew and two clown fish in a 55 gallon tank now before that I had a damsel it lived a month and a half before I got rid of it so it wouldn't mess with the clown tank has been set up 6 months maybe but I have never noticed a ammonia spike or anything so is my tank cycled yet?
 
Only your persistent testing of your water conditions will tell you
Has it cycled. Without a lot more information of your tank I can't tell you.
Post up your current tank numbers
 
If it has been up for 6 months and you have had fish it that whole time, I would say it cycled a long time ago.
 
So you have had fish in this tank for 6 months and you want to know if you are cycled? You're a bit off the reservation for typically recommended approaches to starting a tank. Fish go in after the cycle is complete.

Are you familiar with the nitrogen cycle in an aquarium? Ammonia is the first step in the process. Nitrate is the last. Do you test your tank?
 
My pH is around 8.0 last 4 days and adding prime and stability and pH adjuster but ever time I test it the ammonia nitrates and nitrites are all 0 I have a api saltwater test kit the last couple months I have never seen a spike on any of them
 
Why are you dosing? What parameters are off that you are trying to correct?
 
Well thanks icecube I must have missed something along the line somewhere I have done wastewater for 15 years I know the nitrogen cycle thanks when I first set it up I waited 4 weeks before adding fish and only added stability for bacteria had water tested and they said it was good to add fish I had one damsel die and two clown fish die in the first month of adding fish then added one damsel and it lived for a couple months but never detected ammonia in the tank
 
I'm adding prime in case ammonia spike and pH because I was told to get it up a bit and the stability to add bacteria is this not right?
 
Your fish are dead because your tank isn't ready for fish. Did you do any research on starting and keeping a saltwater tank? You waited 4 weeks, but did you test for anything?

You need to stop adding things to the tank for no reason. This hobby is about preparation and proper care not guessing.
 
I tested the whole time never saw a spike in anything I have a little green algae and string algae on my rocks I have a emperor 400 and a rena filstar cannister filter for filtration I have what some call brown algae on the sand and glass at times
 
icecool2 you don't have to be a dick. Not everyone gets the best info when they start a saltwater tank. I have been to many LFS that the people working their don't have a clue or are seriously misinformed. You should be nicer to new people on here. The whole purpose of sites like this is to share knowledge not to talk down to people.
 
That is someone's opinion a lot of people don't have all that but anyway I have 8 pounds of live rock which my local fish store said was enough some say it's way to little
 
Chill back EDO. It is okay to speak to people in a matter of fact manner. I didn't call the guy names or deride him for being utterly careless did I?

I asked pointed questions and suggested some reading before taking more action. If that makes you uncomfortable, I can't help you.
 
You have those kind of people everywhere and I guess he knew it all when he got started my bad I should have thought about it before I started MY adventure and wasted MY money but thanks for the info
 
That is someone's opinion a lot of people don't have all that but anyway I have 8 pounds of live rock which my local fish store said was enough some say it's way to little
8lbs in a 55g tank is pretty light. You've been getting some pretty bad advice it seems. Read the article I posted. It has the info you need. You need a method for exporting nutrients (bacteria in live rock and sand, protein skimmer, water changes, etc.) and it sounds like you just have a basic filter and pretty minimal rock. Do you have sand?

oh I see your one of those keyboard commandos, lol
Alrighty, help or don't. I don't need your lecture and I don't see you contributing to this guy other than giving me a hard time. And the contraction for "you are" is "you're" it is not "your".
 
You have those kind of people everywhere and I guess he knew it all when he got started my bad I should have thought about it before I started MY adventure and wasted MY money but thanks for the info
Oh geez. Nope, I read and read and read to learn before I did anything. I'm trying to help you. Don't want it? No problem, I won't post anymore.
 
and the grammar police as well

The point is if he has had fish in the tank for months, his tank has cycled. If his setup is sufficient is not the question he was asking.
 
My question is why has the damsel lived for a month or so and I have a golby with a grab in there and haven't noticed an ammonia spike
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top