I bought 2 Cleaner Shrimp and they all died...

ShrimpDemolisher

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Sep 2, 2019
Messages
102
Reaction score
71
What state or country do you live in
California
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
It seems like I never have luck with shrimp. Started with freshwater shrimp and they all jumped out of water.

Now I'm doing SW. Bought 2 Cleaner shrimp at different times and they all died a few hours after. One of them was flipping over while the legs were rapidly moving as if the shrimp trying to swim.

I didn't do drip acclimation but other people also had success without doing it. I just floated the bags in the tank, then poured a little bit of tank water into the bag. It lasted for an hour. Also, I bought the shrimp with other fish and snails and they all survived.

Are these inverts sensitive or did I do something wrong?
 
Not doing drip acclimation? I can with 99% certainty say that's your problem. Saltwater shrimp are SUPER sensitive to rapid salinity changes. If people have had luck with just putting them right in, it's because their salinity was very close to that of where they got them from.

When I get cleaner shrimp, I float the bag for 25 - 30 minutes, then empty the bag water and the shrimp into a bucket. I put a very small heater in the bucket to keep the temperature where it should be. I drip acclimate for 2 hours. Then into the tank.
 
Not doing drip acclimation? I can with 99% certainty say that's your problem. Saltwater shrimp are SUPER sensitive to rapid salinity changes. If people have had luck with just putting them right in, it's because their salinity was very close to that of where they got them from.

When I get cleaner shrimp, I float the bag for 25 - 30 minutes, then empty the bag water and the shrimp into a bucket. I put a very small heater in the bucket to keep the temperature where it should be. I drip acclimate for 2 hours. Then into the tank.

Dripping for 2 hours is in my opinion overkill and also not good either
The water needs oxygen. Most drips are 30-45 min max

The general rule of thumb is twice the water volume then drain half and double the volume again .... done
In they go
 
Last edited:
Wanted to say hello, sorry it had to be on a bad start


Give water parameters, best you can. Like Mike said, acclimation is always needed at minimum for temp, salinity, ph.

Is there any chance you’re tank has ammonia or copper?
 
It seems like I never have luck with shrimp. Started with freshwater shrimp and they all jumped out of water.

Now I'm doing SW. Bought 2 Cleaner shrimp at different times and they all died a few hours after. One of them was flipping over while the legs were rapidly moving as if the shrimp trying to swim.

I didn't do drip acclimation but other people also had success without doing it. I just floated the bags in the tank, then poured a little bit of tank water into the bag. It lasted for an hour. Also, I bought the shrimp with other fish and snails and they all survived.

Are these inverts sensitive or did I do something wrong?
Not doing drip acclimation? I can with 99% certainty say that's your problem. Saltwater shrimp are SUPER sensitive to rapid salinity changes. If people have had luck with just putting them right in, it's because their salinity was very close to that of where they got them from.

When I get cleaner shrimp, I float the bag for 25 - 30 minutes, then empty the bag water and the shrimp into a bucket. I put a very small heater in the bucket to keep the temperature where it should be. I drip acclimate for 2 hours. Then into the tank.

In my experience Invertibrates are more sensitive than most fish in terms if acclimation.
 
Inverts are all sensitive. Your parameters need to be very close along with temp. Nitrates are another killer. I do the cup method I add 1 cup every 5min until salinity matches.
 
My water parameters were all good I think. PH 8.4, ammonia 0, nitrite 0, nitrate 5ppm. Salinity 1.024. LFS salinity is 1.026. So they are close? It's weird all the snails are doing fine though.
 
Dripping for 2 hours is in my opinion overkill and also not good either
The water needs oxygen. Most drips are 30-45 min max

The general rule of thumb is twice the water volume then drain half and double the volume again .... done
In they go

I don't agree at all; my method has always worked for me, and is the widely recommended way of acclimating inverts.
 
Also the trip from lfs to my home is quite long, 20 miles and it takes 50 minutes. IDK if thats a factor.
 
I doubt it. Something else is a foot either acclimation or poor health is my guess

But all the snails are doing great. Fish are less sensitive so they are not counted... :/
 
I don't agree at all; my method has always worked for me, and is the widely recommended way of acclimating inverts.
Widely recommended by who? There is no regulatory body that controls reefing so saying it’s recommended is a stretch in itself. Saying something is reasonably accepted by the community is another

The best part about this hobby is there are a million ways to skin the cat. What works for you may or may not work for me and or some variation of what your saying

Many many ways to do it. The point is, inverts are sensitive. Just go slow and you will be fine.

There probably is some truth so angrymikes 2 hour acclimation. Given the fact that they are shipped in boxes for more then 24 hours at a time suggests that the oxygen is not an issue

I have just never found the need for more then twice the volume two times which’s ends up
Being about 45 minutes

Regardless, I hope you have better luck and enjoy the hobby
 
Widely recommended by who? There is no regulatory body that controls reefing so saying it’s recommended is a stretch in itself. Saying something is reasonably accepted by the community is another

The best part about this hobby is there are a million ways to skin the cat. What works for you may or may not work for me and or some variation of what your saying

Many many ways to do it. The point is, inverts are sensitive. Just go slow and you will be fine.

There probably is some truth so angrymikes 2 hour acclimation. Given the fact that they are shipped in boxes for more then 24 hours at a time suggests that the oxygen is not an issue

I have just never found the need for more then twice the volume two times which’s ends up
Being about 45 minutes

Regardless, I hope you have better luck and enjoy the hobby

I know. If you say there are multiple ways to acclimate the fish then my method was less likely to be the cause, since I did it very slow... But yeah idk.
 
just saying the shrimps death seemed violent (describes as convulsing) just take your water to a LFS to triple check the basics. What kind of refractometer are you using?
 
I observed a similar experience with an astrea snail when dumped into 1.040+ salinity. Wasn’t pretty. Was using a sugar refractometer (which are a lot more common than salt versions. They’re used for making beers and sodas
 
I agree with checking all parameters. But mostly salinity. Some stores have low salinity. And raising it quickly can kill. I do also quarantine. Anytime I get new critters I float them until temperature is the same. Then remove enough water to have room to add small amounts of tank water every 3-4 minutes for about half an hour. I float the bag the entire time. Pouring off into the sink as needed. Might even go a little longer depending on how sensitive the animal is. With my quarantine tank I do the same. But for one difference. I check the salinity in the bag and add fresh water to the quarantine if needed to lower it. Then I can slowly raise it over the quarantine period. Sorry for the book.
 
I observed a similar experience with an astrea snail when dumped into 1.040+ salinity. Wasn’t pretty. Was using a sugar refractometer (which are a lot more common than salt versions. They’re used for making beers and sodas

I use the black hydrometer. The one that looks like a scope with a piece of glass that you drop water on.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top