I bought 2 Cleaner Shrimp and they all died...

I agree with checking all parameters. But mostly salinity. Some stores have low salinity. And raising it quickly can kill. I do also quarantine. Anytime I get new critters I float them until temperature is the same. Then remove enough water to have room to add small amounts of tank water every 3-4 minutes for about half an hour. I float the bag the entire time. Pouring off into the sink as needed. Might even go a little longer depending on how sensitive the animal is. With my quarantine tank I do the same. But for one difference. I check the salinity in the bag and add fresh water to the quarantine if needed to lower it. Then I can slowly raise it over the quarantine period. Sorry for the book.

I did exactly what you did. Salinity at lfs is 1.026 and my tank is 1.023. Big difference or not?
 
Acclimation is key. You have to go over 1-2 hours adding water very slowly over that time span and slowly release them from bag to tank.
they are salinity sensative
 
Acclimation is key. You have to go over 1-2 hours adding water very slowly over that time span and slowly release them from bag to tank.
they are salinity sensative

I explained what I did above but everybody keeps repeating the same thing
 
30 minutes is not enough.
 
Sorry to be repetitive as well but you’re sure your refractometer is meant for saltwater and calibrated correctly? It may simple be that a jump from 1.026to 1.023 as was noted was too much for the shrimpies. It’s just odd cause I’ve read a drop in salinity isn’t nearly as bad as a jump.

Just brainstorming though I’m sure you’ll figure it out!
 
Sorry to be repetitive as well but you’re sure your refractometer is meant for saltwater and calibrated correctly? It may simple be that a jump from 1.026to 1.023 as was noted was too much for the shrimpies. It’s just odd cause I’ve read a drop in salinity isn’t nearly as bad as a jump.

Just brainstorming though I’m sure you’ll figure it out!

No thank you I do appreciate that. I just didn't know what I did wrong. Probably the jump from 1.026 to 1.023. I did calibrate it twice before using
 
One thing I did once as a noob was I was pouring the bags of fish water and invert water from the LFS into my tank. Also sometimes into a single acclimation bucket. the fish only tanks at the LFS are treated and on a separate system from the invert tanks. I lost a peppermint shrimp and it dawned on me that was what happened.
 
No thank you I do appreciate that. I just didn't know what I did wrong. Probably the jump from 1.026 to 1.023. I did calibrate it twice before using
Yes that jump will kill shrimp they are that sensitive.
I have a few questions I haven’t seen asked that may help.
What are you using for calibration of your refractometer RODI water or Calibration fluid?
If calibration fluid how old is it?
Are you letting the refractometer sit for a bit for the temp to equalize? ( seems like some of the cheaper ones need more time then others )
How old is the tank?
What kind of water are you using tap, rodi, etc ?
Any chemicals added to the tank?
 
You may also want to test the water in the bag. I have had LFS's tell me they keep their salinity at 1.024 and tested and found it was 1.018. Also, I doubt your LFS keeps their PH at 8.4 so you should make sure the PH matches as well as salinity. I don't focus as much on the amount of time I acclimate as the actual parameters. Whatever amount of time it takes to match salinity, PH and Temp is the amount of time it takes... ;Happy
 
I haven't used this yet, but it gets good reviews on Amazon. It's not super sturdy, but I don't think it needs to be. I plan on trying this next time I get a fish. Maybe use something like this next time? I know people use a bucket too, but this will also help with temp adjustments.

 
I explained what I did above but everybody keeps repeating the same thing
I do not have any feedback on the OG post, as I am terrible with shrimp as well. However, I just realized your screen name and I may have died a little. Good luck on your critters; I have tried 4ish shrimp so far and killed them all. I have a shipment coming in soon, so fingers crossed they come alive and survive!
 
Acclimation is key. You have to go over 1-2 hours adding water very slowly over that time span and slowly release them from bag to tank.
they are salinity sensative
This means adding a heater and airstone in the acclimation bucket right? I am not having luck with cleaner shrimp as well but I learned my lfs keeps sg at 1.020. My tank is 1.025
 
These and fire shrimp Must be acclimated well especially adjust ph and salinity
 
When the shrimp was on its back, legs up…are you sure it wasn’t tired from long trip and just getting some much needed shuteye?
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top