I feel like this was causing problems in my tank.

HandsyLobster

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Dec 12, 2023
Messages
303
Reaction score
281
Location
South Florida
What state or country do you live in
Florida
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
SO I had these metal claps to hold my return pump to my hoses and I haven't seen great growth in my SPS do you think this could be a reason?
tempImageRzaTMm.png
tempImageuI4eCb.png
 
I personally wouldn’t even trust stainless. I use heavy duty zip ties for anything under water in my tanks
 
SO I had these metal claps to hold my return pump to my hoses and I haven't seen great growth in my SPS do you think this could be a reason?
tempImageRzaTMm.png
tempImageuI4eCb.png
Absolutely!! They make plastic clamps. Rust is awful for a tank.
 
SO I had these metal claps to hold my return pump to my hoses and I haven't seen great growth in my SPS do you think this could be a reason?
tempImageRzaTMm.png
tempImageuI4eCb.png
No harm in changing them for something else, but wouldn't be top of my problem list. Your tank is only 4 months old, dry rock start, isn't it?
 
No harm in changing them for something else, but wouldn't be top of my problem list. Your tank is only 4 months old, dry rock start, isn't it?
Mixture of dry and live rock. Also started with water out of the ocean and a cup of sand to get thing rolling. I never had a cycle in my tank.
 
Mixture of dry and live rock. Also started with water out of the ocean and a cup of sand to get thing rolling. I never had a cycle in my tank.
Tank maturity is more than just being cycled...
 
Don’t think that’s your problem… I’ve had pumps pouring out rust that I never knew till they quit.. still didn’t affect my tank really..
Yeah I didn't think it would be the issue either. May be low levels of nutrients. My N03 I can't get about 2-3 and PO4 stays around 1.0. I do 10% water changes every week to replace any trace elements.

Maybe its aminos idk?
 
100% half my rock is from mature systems ive got from other reefers.
That still doesn't mean your 4 month old tank is ready for SPS...
You're looking for reasons they aren't growing, and this is a possibility.
 
Yeah I didn't think it would be the issue either. May be low levels of nutrients. My N03 I can't get about 2-3 and PO4 stays around 1.0. I do 10% water changes every week to replace any trace elements.

Maybe its aminos idk?
Aminos or ammonia dosing wouldn’t hurt… I personally like to see around 10 on my n03… what do you have for lighting and flow?
 
Yeah I didn't think it would be the issue either. May be low levels of nutrients. My N03 I can't get about 2-3 and PO4 stays around 1.0. I do 10% water changes every week to replace any trace elements.

Maybe its aminos idk?
If you typed that correctly 1.0 PO4 could be the issue. The value should be more like 0.05 - 0.2 ideal would be around around 0.1
 
SO I had these metal claps to hold my return pump to my hoses and I haven't seen great growth in my SPS do you think this could be a reason?
tempImageRzaTMm.png
tempImageuI4eCb.png
Probably not enough corrosion to create a toxic level of metals. This is probably stainless steel which is iron, chromium snd nickel. Iron is not a problem, but chromium (18%) and nickel (10%) could be. Unless these were sitting in the water, the corrosion products stayed mostly where you see them. Change the claps to something more inert.
 
I just read that your tank is only 4 month old. How fast do you expect to see your SPS grow? These are very slow growing corals. When you see colonies that are softball sized they are usually close to 2 years old from small golf ball sized or smaller frags.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%

New Posts

Back
Top