I have a People Eater that needs identification

The problem with an ID is hard w/ True PE sometimes. They can change color drastically based on lighting. After it has been in the tank for a couple of months. I collect PE so here is an example. These are both the same polyps. Pic 1 is when I got it from the LFS. Pic 2 is what they look like now.
UnkPE.jpg


newpe.jpg


Don't even look similar.
If you don't find a good answer it may because it will change once it settles. Just a thought.
Now my general PE lesson. In the reef community PE are usually identified by the green mouth and white striations on the closed polyps. Not all PE have these chacteristics. PE are Zoanthus Gigantus which translates to Giant Zoas; The zoa answer to Palythoa Grandis. The only true way to tell Zoanthus Gigantus in under a microscope.

Post some updates in a month or two so we can compare them to the pic above.
Hope that helps. :)

your picture one shows very good colouring tho polyps look a bit flustered lol........... your piccy two after a while shows them bleaching out... thats not a colouring but a loss of colour due to lighting/or water biology, the lashes have also become watered out, ie no colour.......

one of the things ive noticed cultivating zoas is a bleaching out of colour to lashes if the tank is going through a tempory water cycle say if a bigggggggg watr change has taken place and alot of cynobacteria is evident (cyno=brown stringy or cobwebby stuff) but as cycle finishes the colours develop back in the lashes
 
ive also had experiences of tempory bleaching of zoas/lashes when i havent actually changed anything.... i think the procceses of water biology do sometimes yoyo even without interfarence.... just a small box of water with all sorts of biology activaty going on within at times with our livestock etc......
 
Here is a picture of my Insane People Eater
 

Attachments

  • 11-10-09 012.jpg
    11-10-09 012.jpg
    51.6 KB · Views: 221
Here is a picture of my Insane People Eater

good colours but speckles not showing....... can be fixed with the right lighting...

lots of extra names on this morph when sold faded/uncoloured up examples....

renaming in various faded/uncoloured up examples suits sellers for obvious reasons.....
 
Mine has its true colors I one in 10 k and 14K I also have another version that does not have the deep green from another source.
good colours but speckles not showing....... can be fixed with the right lighting...

lots of extra names on this morph when sold faded/uncoloured up examples....

renaming in various faded/uncoloured up examples suits sellers for obvious reasons.....
 
Mine has its true colors I one in 10 k and 14K I also have another version that does not have the deep green from another source.

yes genes within same zoa from diff sources can become slightly lacking depending on conditions/lighting they been under and prefer but still same variety...

just for a comparison cuda look at polyp on the very right of Scopus Tang piccy........ compare that to your piccy and tell me they are different variety lol

pictures you lot upload are also under different lighting/bulbs and different cameras used so its obvious theres gonna be slight variations.....

if we all used the same lighting and took pictures of our zoas once they settle and become stable and coloured up properly we wouldnt have half the confusion...
 
All I know are the facts I see . Mine look the same as they did in the tank They came from and the babies all grew to the same, I also have the stardust and you can clearly see they are different and reproduce replicas of themselves in my systems. Well they all die when you kill them so I guess they are the same.\
yes genes within same zoa from diff sources can become slightly lacking depending on conditions/lighting they been under and prefer but still same variety...

just for a comparison cuda look at polyp on the very right of Scopus Tang piccy........ compare that to your piccy and tell me they are different variety lol

pictures you lot upload are also under different lighting/bulbs and different cameras used so its obvious theres gonna be slight variations.....

if we all used the same lighting and took pictures of our zoas once they settle and become stable and coloured up properly we wouldnt have half the confusion...
 
On the first ones, I have them also. I didn't think I would ever see the same ones anywhere else. I have looked for months and can't find them but when I bought them they told me they were "Big lipped Ladies" if you ever see them open there mouths then you would understand. lol. Mine are exactly like yours.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%

New Posts

Back
Top