I need a solid skimmer for 160g.

willthethrill

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Jul 12, 2016
Messages
192
Reaction score
83
Location
Nj
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
For a year and a half my Skimz skimmer has constantly needed adjustment. It'll skim way too dry for a few weeks, I'll tweak it a little, and then it runs good for 2 or 3 weeks and then I'll find the cup overflowing. No filter socks causing it either so that's not why. Overall this piece of equipment has been unreliable for me. I'm currently on vacation and checked in on the webcam, the dang thing overflowed again and its dripping back into the sump. Final straw. What brand and model have you guys had running for a long time.
 
I’ve been running Vertex for some time and love them. A Omega 150 would likely work well. Great build and skimming quality!

That's one of the models I had in mind since seeing the bulk reef supply guys using it on their tanks
 
I have an Icecap K2-120 on my ~80g, and am purchasing a K2-160 for a slightly larger build ~110g. While I haven't used other brands, I've been very impressed with the quality and performance of my current one. I've had to fiddle with it only once in over a years worth of use (after I took it apart to clean it). Skims dark, silent and no custom pump.
 
I've used both vertex and SCA skimmers. I currently have two SCA 302s that are rated up to 180 gallons. They do a great job and extremely easy to set up and dial in.
 
I have a sca-302 which was hard to clean and a bit loud, but otherwise a good skimmer. I now use a RO Elite 220-INT which is a beast. Very quiet and consistent.
 
Vertex alpha series and nyos are my favorites. Can’t hear either of them running, easy adjustment and the amount of crap they pull out is phenomenal. On my new 560 I’ll be running two of the nyos 300s. Nyos and vertex are top of the line and worth every penny imo. If you’re more economical the best bang for the buck you can’t beat the icecap skimmers. They’re reasonably quiet, easy to adjust and the sicce pumps are reliable and easy to source if you ever need a replacement. Reef octos are ok but they change stuff way to often, parts get discontinued and you end up left with a Frankenstein skimmer or needing a new one. My vertex alphas have been around for a long time and I can call vertex and get any replacement part I may need though in 5 years I haven’t needed anything.
 
I used a Vertex Omega 150 on my 170g ish system. IMO they have understated the capacity of the omega line. Customer service, build quality and price made me a fan of Vertex/Royal Exclusive and performance made me a lifelong customer. If you have $ to , look into the Bubble King line. I promise you, they will not disappoint.
 
Review I posted on another site:

About a week after ending my search for a new skimmer last year, I stumbled across the Deltec SC1350N (predecessor to this model). Compared to other skimmers on the market these days, the Deltec is simple in appearance; there aren't any eye catching curves, flashy fittings, or intricate bubble plates. It is a simple yet elegant, single diameter (six inches) tube of acrylic accented by white components. Assembly and disassembly of the entire unit is an entirely toolless process utilizing a single thumb screw on the back of the unit. Loosening the thumbscrew a few turns provides enough space to remove the entire skimmer body from the motor plate. To remove the skimmer body you also need to remove the volute which simply pulls off the motor block like the majority of skimmers on the market. The pump then simply slides out of the mounting plate. The diffuser is removed by turning it approximately 45° and pulling it off the pump. This provides access to remove the impeller (typical pinwheel design). The skimmer cup is removed from the body with a small twist (roughly 15°) and pops right off with no effort.

Recommended water depth for the skimmer is roughly 6 - 9 7/8"; I have it sitting at 7 3/4" right now with the gate almost completely shut to get an acceptable water level in the skimmer so I'd be surprised if it worked well in 6". I have only spent about five minutes tuning the Deltec while I spent days tuning the Bubble Magus Curve 5 it replaced to get the consistency I was after which I find to be a huge improvement.

After using the skimmer for about nine months now, I absolutely love it but needed to replace the impeller which was proving to be more difficult than originally thought due to availability in the US. After a little more than a month and a half (ordered May 9th and arrived June 24th from a different distributor), the unit was finally back up and running like it should (skimmer still worked with the old impeller but required frequent adjustment).

Likes
Ease of maintenance (super simple to assemble and disassemble).
Easy to tune
Simple, sleek appearance
Consistent performance

Dislikes
Availability (hopefully a thing of the past now that Marine Depot is on board)
Cost
Noisiest piece of equipment in the setup (skimmer off 34db and on 44db). No longer the case since I added a pair of MP40s to the setup (skimmer seems quiet now...)
Slight pain cleaning the cup (narrow gap between the neck and outside wall of cup makes it difficult to get bigger fingers down there to clean)

It's been four months since the replacement impeller arrived and I still love the skimmer; so much so that I'm purchasing a larger one for the 150g build we've started. I cant tell you what will work best but I'd be extremely skeptical of anything operating significantly better.
 
I have an Icecap K2-120 on my ~80g, and am purchasing a K2-160 for a slightly larger build ~110g. While I haven't used other brands, I've been very impressed with the quality and performance of my current one. I've had to fiddle with it only once in over a years worth of use (after I took it apart to clean it). Skims dark, silent and no custom pump.

The Eshopps s 120 uses the and pump there have been some reports about start up issues. Have you had any start up issues? Would the K2 120 be good for 75 gallon heavy load?
 
The Eshopps s 120 uses the and pump there have been some reports about start up issues. Have you had any start up issues? Would the K2 120 be good for 75 gallon heavy load?
I have had zero issues with it mechanically, the pump has been flawless and silent. In fact I had some sponge growing all over the place on the pump and in the body, it still continued to chug along. My 65g takes a cube of mysis and some PE pellets every day, along with a sheet of nori every 2-3 days.

2x Ocellaris Clownfish - Amphiprion ocellaris
1x Bluestreak Cleaner Wrasse - Labroides dimidiatus
1x Bi-Colour Blenny - Escenius bicolor
1x Bristletooth Tomini Tang - Ctenochaetus tominiensis
1x Lubbock's Fairy Wrasse - Cirrhilabrus lubbocki
1x Firefish - Nemateleotris magnifica
1x Blue-Sided Wrasse - Cirrhilabrus cyanopleura
1x Social Wrasse - Cirrhilabrus rubriventralis

The major reason I went with it in the first place is the foot print, it had to fit in a very tight spot in a 20L sump. The fact it's worked out so well, was middle of the pack for pricing and doesn't have a bunch of custom parts to source should anything go wrong were just bonus points. I have not used another brand of sump skimmer, so I don't have anything to reference it against. That said as noted in my other post, I'm picking up the larger K2-160 for my nano tank upgrade because of that personal use track record.

I'm not sure how many icecap threads there are here, but I haven't seen anything major posted about them.
 
Can't go wrong with a BK if it is in the budget, Vertex is a little more budget friendly and great as well. Those are the only two I would trust on my tank, I have over ten years EXP with both.
 
I would not use your sump for a total on tank volume. What is the tank volume alone?

Why is that? Do you believe a skimmer designed for a 100g aquarium (typically considerably less than 100g volume with rock, sand, etc.) is capable of skimming 150 gallons total volume?
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top