Just how far do you let Aiptasia go?

Don't wait! Kill them now! Here's a pic of my old 75 gallon. Things were everywhere!

Screenshot_20181002-103210.png
Screenshot_20181002-103116.png
 
So, how far do you let Aiptasia go before you call it a real problem? Does anyone have pictures of it taking over? I just want to feel a little better about my current situation, possibly decrease the stress a little lol.

My tank has some rock in it with around 3-10 aiptasia on each rock all small to medium. I'm honestly thinking about getting some berghia but I don't want to get rid of the aiptasia if it's not bad enough to sustain the number I buy.

I honestly would be tearing the rock out and replacing it [assuming that you don't have fish/corals in it].

I have kept aiptasia out of my tanks successfully so far (knocks on wood) since I started a tank that got pretty bad due to aiptasia .

I start my systems with dry rock, or rock that i've gotten from my own systems. I've never used "live rock" and have never experienced any issues related to starting with dry rock [so far].
 
Wesman42,

I think you've received some great advice in this thread, but just wanted to expand a little, based on my personal experience, to try to help you and others that come across this down the road. I'm currently fighting a large aiptasia outbreak that started months ago. Like you, I only had a few at the start, but that quickly changed when I started to improperly eliminate them.

My first mistake was using a Majano Wand. While it was satisfactory to watch them bubble away to nothing, I quickly learned this was a huge mistake as they came back tenfold within a few weeks. The wand might work for certain types of non-porous rock, but I have pukani so the aiptasia would pull back into the holes and crevices preventing me from 'completely' killing many of them. As you know, once you threaten it, it can release spores and make the situation much worse.

After the Majano Wand, I spent hundreds of dollars on Bergia (two times). They worked very well at the start, but I never was able to get them to reproduce for some reason. I was working with the vendor, but they were not able to provide me with the root cause on why they would not reproduce so I was not going to throw more money down that hole. I did have a small turf algae outbreak at one point, and I learned they don't seem to move well in/through thick algae areas. That said - The algae outbreak was caused by a phosphate spike which might have been the cause of the Bergia not reproducing. So if you have a stable system with no night time predators, I still think they are a great way to go, just make sure you research them and follow the vendor's instructions to get them deployed properly in your system. My final thought's on Bergia... I believe they are a great solution if you can get them to reproduce, don't have predators that might eat them while they are exposed on your rock work at night and don't want to add anything else long term to the tank. Also, while I'ver read posts where others had 100% success with them, I just wonder what the odds are for them getting rid of ever aiptasia before they are removed and rehomed or die of starvation.

I currently have four peppermint shrimp and they appear to work well, but they seem to go after mostly smaller Aiptasia. Also, if you decide to use them, make sure you are getting the right ones that will eat Aiptasia. I've seen charts of six different shrimp that look almost identical to the untrained eye ( See Link ). I think this is the reason many people report they don't work or eat certain soft corals. The four I have appear to have stopped the spread of aiptasia, but I'm not seeing much of a dent in clearing rocks. I ordered a second group of six, but I lost them in QT due to an ATO issue. I think if I had ten total that might have been enough to turn the tide in my favor. Point being, I think it's better to get more than you think you need and rehome most of them after they get the job done.

I just added two ORA filefish to the tank two days ago. Like the peppermint shrimp, make sure you get the right filefish as there are several types that look similar and are often sold as aiptasia eating filefish. I guess time will tell, but they are already picking at stuff on the rock, although I think it's just pods at the moment.

Final thoughts, I don't know if I would use the Bergia again since they are expensive and in a larger tank I think the odds are less they will get every last aiptasia. Knowing what I know now, I think I would go with pepps or the filefish from the start. They should get the job done, plus prevent them from coming back long term. Also, I did look into getting a Scat fish, but I could not find enough information to guarantee I could order the smaller species which only grow to 4-6 inches. They are supposed to eat aiptasia, plus algae which would be a bonus.

I hope you have early success and don't end up like me... It's been an uphill battle!

Good luck!
 
I tried Joe's juice, Aiptasia X, Kalk paste and they seemed to multiply. After buying several peppermint shrimp that didn't fix the problem I bought a file fish. I never saw the filefish eating the Aiptasia but within a couple of weeks it was all gone. My file fish does eat pellets so I am not afraid of him not getting enough food.
 
So, how far do you let Aiptasia go before you call it a real problem? Does anyone have pictures of it taking over? I just want to feel a little better about my current situation, possibly decrease the stress a little lol.

My tank has some rock in it with around 3-10 aiptasia on each rock all small to medium. I'm honestly thinking about getting some berghia but I don't want to get rid of the aiptasia if it's not bad enough to sustain the number I buy.

One is going too far already. Anything I hate finding more than an aptasia is. . . TWO OF THEM !! I allow maybe 5 or 6 then its time for battle !
 
Would the CUC then take care of the dead berghia?
I never saw any dead or being consumed per se. They arent very large, it didn't cause any problems with ammonia or anything for me. I assume they die over a period of time with the population dwindling as they cant find any more aiptasia.
 
I have one in my tank and spot feed mysis whenever I feed my fish/coral, its never picked on any of my coral. But I do understand that thats something people may not be willing to do!
I can say Ditto to this. I have one in a NPS Pico tank that is pretty large. It gets fed by default when feeding corals. So far the only one. Experimenting. Pico will be easy to eradicate if necessary.
 
Green files are death to aiptasias. They’ll clean out the small ones first, medium ones second, and big ones last. When the anemones are gone, they seem to transition quickly to the foods you’re offering.

I won’t say theywould never nip at other corals, but I haven’t seen it.
 
What do you do with the berghia after all the aptesia is gone?
Also ive had a file fish before and worked great but when no more aptesia he went after corals???
 
I have a filefish in my sump eating aptasia I want to put him in my DT but should I be worried about them going to town on my coral?
 
I have a filefish in my sump eating aptasia I want to put him in my DT but should I be worried about them going to town on my coral?
they will- when my aptesia was gone corals came next.....i loved the little fish but out he went to the QT
 
I had some, about 5, on different pieces of live rock after a new set up. If the rock was small enough, I would take it out and break off the part with the aptasia on it. If the rock was too big, I used reef epoxy to cover them or cover a hole they were in. In a 180 gallon tank, it's hard to see them sometimes, but I keep on the lookout for them and dispatch them ASAP. My only worry now is any I can't see that might be on the back or underside of the rock. Don't hesitate, take care of them sooner than later. Good luck!
 
I have a 45 gal JBJ AIO that I converted to have a sump. They are all over the back of the tank. The front very few and those I kill as soon as I can. The ones in the back I can’t reach. I don’t have any in my sump and if I see any in there I kill right away as well. My overflow box (CPR90) was also full of them or rather gets full of them until every so often I take it off and dunk it in a five gal bucket with water and vinegar for several hours to clean it. I have or rather keep two or three peppermint shrimp in the tank.
But I rarely see them as it seems they are always in the back of the tank hiding
The ones that I do see I manage to kill with a shot of lemon juice.
But I have ordered Red Sea’s Aptasias X and maybe I can reach some of them in the back as well
 
I've been fighting with aips for a good while now in my 150g. I've tried numerous peppermint shrimps, but after adding them I never see them again... I have witnessed my big ole' grumpy pink-spotted goby eat them whole just for walking by... And I do have a few wrasses that might be targeting them as well. I picked up an ORA Filefish and he did go after some smaller aips, but after a cpl says he'd nip at sps polyps, zoas, and styloceneillias too.. He was banished to sump and I'd let him pick the Aips off smaller rocks that I could place in there. Thinking he turned over a new leaf, I'd try him in the DT again and after a few days he was right back to nipping corals...
I will do AipRx occasionally, but I have mixed feelings about it working... I do know that if it gets on corals it will burn them... and that's usually the aips um trying to get rid of is the ones growing amongst corals or above them...
I thought about trying Nudi's, but with the wrasses and pink-spotted goby I figured that'd be an expensive lesson...
And just last week one of my reefing buddies came over and in no time pointed out the fact that most of my aips are actually Majonos... I've been in the hobby since 2012 and that never crossed my mind!!! Learn something new everyday!!! lol So now I'm still wondering what my best option would be.. I'd love a CBB, but finding a healthy one that will eat aips and other foods as well is a crap shoot. I tossed around the idea of buying one of those Super Bad to the Bone Catch Couch on Fire Lasers, but have not had time to do more research on one...

View attachment 20181008_195125.jpg

View attachment 20181008_194927.jpg
 
Not far. Lets say its impossible for me to remove and replace any rocks in my 500 gallon tank. I got the A...... Prob on some corals from another reefer. I saw 1 then 1 more. I got the A...X. Was able to get the 2. A few weeks later I see one more. Even with a 3 foot bent rigid piece of airline tubing glued to a syringe I could not bend it to get the bugger. Time for the peppermints. I got 5, figured maybe 2 or 3 would survive in the tank. After a few days the aptasia was gone. I never see the shrimp. Even at night with a flashlight. But then its a big tank with lots of big rocks. I think they see in the dark and know Im coming. I know they are still alive because every so often I see a small aptasia and in a few days it is gone. I have a lot of pods in the rock work. They must eat those or any scraps of food they find.
 
I watched a video last year on MLev's Reef. He used a laser to kill them. I got a laser and use it whenever I see one. Problem I have is they are hiding in my corals. I hit them when they come out, but the duck under a zoa and I won't burn a perfectly good zoa. Its kind of fun though, so I don't really playing "whack a mole" with the laser.
Ted
 
I had a Copperband Butterfly in my 140, before I tore it down. I had no visible aiptaisa in my display for around 10 years (the fish is at least 11 now), although there were plenty of them in my overflows and sump. I still have the CBB in a temp tank and will move him to my new tank. The only other thing that the CBB ever messed with was feather dusters.

I did use a file fish in another tank and after the aiptasia was gone, he started eating my zoas. I also saw another one in a LFS rip zoas off of rock while I was watching it.
 
I stopped fussing over aiptasia and majanos years ago. Since I dont really do Zooanthids, and have a big tank, a few Angels (asfur is best) and butterflies took care of them. Aiptasia grows in the sump, but who cares about that.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top