Kessil 360we...Time to throw in the towel?

I wonder what the deal is with kessil? This light is much stronger than my old diy led light, yet most sps turn brown. A monti cap bleached out completely, but other than that, bold bright corals turn brown. The PC rainbow at least developed metallic green. That's better than brown, but not what I paid for it to look like. My sunset montipora has some very nice polyps, but the metallic orange is brown.
 
I am using 3 360's (will be getting a 4th). After seeing ZERO SPS tasks running solely Kessils, I knew I would need supplementing light. I am running 6 54w T5's and a 48" ReefBrite XHO. Tank just got setup, so no corals inside yet. I like the look of the Kessils, and they are the ONLY LED that cut through the T5's and I still get the MH shimmer that I missed when I went T5.
I'd rather just use t5 if I'm going to bother at all. For me, it's low profile or nothing. I absolutely hate the look of bulk over a tank. I used to have t5 and hated their bulk and upkeep.
 
I may try upping the intensity some more before I quit kessil. It sure LOOKS bright, where people say it looks dim.

It would be great to see examples of kessil ONLY tanks with thriving acroporas, not the easier montiporas and what not.

Our eyes are not very good at judging true light intensity, especially if it has a lot of violet/blue in it. A PAR meter would be helpful to get a better idea of the light intensity reaching the corals.
 
Our eyes are not very good at judging true light intensity, especially if it has a lot of violet/blue in it. A PAR meter would be helpful to get a better idea of the light intensity reaching the corals.

Kessil is known for awful par values, yet people recommend them.

How is the xr15w pro?
 
That's not true. Par meters just can't read kessils chips very well. Like I said before, the light isn't turning anything brown, there's another factor. I've observed plenty of tanks with kessils and colors are fine. I wouldn't go as far as to say they are thriving like a t5/mh tank but things grew and colors looked good.

Since kessil is a SF bay company(where I'm located) there's plenty of lfs running them here and have been since the first 150 was released.

They pose their own unique hurdles, but they are capable lights, and much much stronger than the human eye leads you to believe. I would suggest calling kessil. They are very helpful on the phone.
 
That's not true. Par meters just can't read kessils chips very well. Like I said before, the light isn't turning anything brown, there's another factor. I've observed plenty of tanks with kessils and colors are fine. I wouldn't go as far as to say they are thriving like a t5/mh tank but things grew and colors looked good.

Since kessil is a SF bay company(where I'm located) there's plenty of lfs running them here and have been since the first 150 was released.

They pose their own unique hurdles, but they are capable lights, and much much stronger than the human eye leads you to believe. I would suggest calling kessil. They are very helpful on the phone.

Doesn't kessil use the same wavelengths that others use? I see others able to measure par values that have wavelengths that match kessil.

Do these LFS run JUST kessil? I've seen some nice sps tanks with kessil AND t5. Might as well run t5 then.

If your LFS truly run only kessils and have plenty of acroporas then I'll just up the intensity some more over the next month.

I know my LFS runs radion led lights and told me kessil isn't good for acroporas. They did feel that this 360we should be good for my tank though.
 
They do have tanks on just kessils. Diablo corals comes to mind as the owner worked for kessil. I know they usually don't run them really high either. I would not increase the intensity for a while imo. I know there's a guy on the other forum who runs a ton of them on a 300-400g tank and just a few stunner strips for moon lights. I would pm him and see what intensity he is running.
 
after 3 months under kessil 160we tuna blue not only is it growing, its coloring up and I've seen plenty of success stories from others using them. I dont think the lights are the problem. Do you dose aminos? Could help with your color
 
after 3 months under kessil 160we tuna blue not only is it growing, its coloring up and I've seen plenty of success stories from others using them. I dont think the lights are the problem. Do you dose aminos? Could help with your color

Hmm....Well that's definitely not brown, definitely growing.

I don't dose anything at all. There is zero growth and alkalinity stays solid at 9dkh. I just feed mysis and some filter feeding food. I use to feed some old pellets as well. I wonder if mysis and filter feeder food isn't providing enough extra for the corals?
 
Try some aminos very easy to manually dose and you will see a difference pretty quick and when dosed correctly won't screw with your chemistry. As far as growth goes gonna need some help from someone with a lil more experience.
 
PAR meters are not going to read the Photosynthetically Usable Radiation emmitted from these lights. The PUR emmitted from the Kessil's is more than enough for the zooxanthellae to absorb and stimulate the required photosynthesis. I run 2 x 360we's on a 48" wide tank with lps and sps. All are thriving with a 12 hr photo period ramping up from 12% to 70% intensity for high noon @ 52% color.
More importantly is chemistry stability. I found over the years that most corals can adapt to lower intensity but that light is almost secondary to stable parameters held within the proper range.

You may have an over abundance of nutrients causing the brown out. Try increasing the light exposure to stimulate the zooxanthellae photopigmentation. 10-12hr photo period with a high noon working your way up from 60% to 70% and take notes on how the creatures are responding. I increased intensity by 2% every 4 days. Don't throw in the towel just yet.:)
 
Last edited:
PAR meters are not going to read the Photosynthetically Usable Radiation emmitted from these lights. The PUR emmitted from the Kessil's is more than enough for the zooxanthellae to absorb and stimulate the required photosynthesis. I run 2 x 360we's on a 48" wide tank with lps and sps. All are thriving with a 12 hr photo period ramping up from 12% to 70% intensity for high noon @ 52% color.
More importantly is chemistry stability. I found over the years that most corals can adapt to lower intensity but that light is almost secondary to stable parameters held within the proper range.

It seems you may have an over abundance of nutrients causing the brown out. Try increasing the light exposure to stimulate the zooxanthellae photopigmentation. 10-12hr photo period with a high noon working your way up from 60% to 70% and take notes on how the creatures are responding. I increased intensity by 2% every 4 days. Don't throw in the towel just yet.:)

What kind of sps do you have? Any acroporas? I'll take your advice and ramp up some more.
 
PAR meters are not going to read the Photosynthetically Usable Radiation emmitted from these lights. The PUR emmitted from the Kessil's is more than enough for the zooxanthellae to absorb and stimulate the required photosynthesis. I run 2 x 360we's on a 48" wide tank with lps and sps. All are thriving with a 12 hr photo period ramping up from 12% to 70% intensity for high noon @ 52% color.
More importantly is chemistry stability. I found over the years that most corals can adapt to lower intensity but that light is almost secondary to stable parameters held within the proper range.

It seems you may have an over abundance of nutrients causing the brown out. Try increasing the light exposure to stimulate the zooxanthellae photopigmentation. 10-12hr photo period with a high noon working your way up from 60% to 70% and take notes on how the creatures are responding. I increased intensity by 2% every 4 days. Don't throw in the towel just yet.:)

To be accurate, PAR meters are designed to read all visible light (400 and 700 nm), which includes PUR. They just aren't as sensitive to wavelenghts at the extremes (violet-blue/red) and require a correction factor depending on the type of light source being measured (Apogee plot below in blue):

mark10.jpg


The point is that a PAR meter is the best that the vast majority of reef aquarists have access to (they are relatively inexpensive and can often be loaned from a reef club) and, when used correctly, can be quite helpful when comparing numbers from similar light sources installed on our reef tanks.

Increasing light intensity (up to a point, type/species dependent) will typically stimulate the coral's own fluorescent/non-fluorescent proteins while decreasing the amount of zooxanthellae (the coral will expell the excess zooxanthellae in an attempt to avoid toxic oxygen buildup). Less zooxanthellae, less brown background coloration, brighter colored coral (unless nutrients are so low that pigment production is negatively effected leading to pale, pasty corals).

I agree that the Kessil PUR is quite adequate for growing photosynthetic corals of any type, even though the PAR is relatively low. The Kessil LED chip set for any model of reef aquarum light (obviously, ignore the 'Amazon Sun' unless you are really 'Old School' in your lighting preferences) doesn't 'waste' much energy in the warmer wavelengths (not used much in photosynthesis):

kessil-a150_2_1.jpg
 
Last edited:
I wonder if the uv in this light could be causing any browning? I was under the impression that 12mW or whatever it is, is wayyyy too low for anything.
 
I wonder if the uv in this light could be causing any browning? I was under the impression that 12mW or whatever it is, is wayyyy too low for anything.

It has been shown that UV A can be used for photosynthesis by corals, but the amount given off by the Kessil is relatively small. MH gives off a lot more UV (which typically is shielded somewhat to reduce the UV) and the corals don't necessarily brown from it.

I think Reefbeard is on the right track with the water quality/stability issue. SPS (Acros, Seritopora, etc) are known for browning out when conditions become unstable (especially large alkalinity swings in a short period of time).
 
Last edited:
No swings that I know of. An ATO keeps salinity stable. I don't dose anything. All I do is feed mysis and skim. I used to dose potassium nitrate back when I had zero nitrates, but haven't done so in a few weeks since upping my feedings keep nitrates up.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top