My Fish Collection trip to Oahu, HI

TJ's Reef

Valuable Member
View Badges
Joined
Oct 26, 2013
Messages
2,454
Reaction score
289
Location
Everett, WA
What state or country do you live in
Washington
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Hi All, some of you may be aware from reading my build thread that the majority of the Fish in my system I collected myself while visiting my friend Les in Honolulu back in September 2011. The so-called water proof camera I bought specifically for this trip failed near the end of my stay and I lost nearly 200 cherished pics of our Diving and Tide Pool Collection outings. Was and am still really bummed about losing some really awesome pictures of my first ever time at collecting Tropical Marine Fish and Invertebrates, then actually bringing some of them home for my own Reeftank. So earlier today was doing a little Spring Cleaning and came across my old cell phone and low and behold was full of pics thought 'long lost', some even from Hawaii in 9/2011. One or a couple in particular as is my Blochii Tang which was the first ever I caught and literally only in the water for about five minutes on first dive.

My friend Les had thrown out the offer a few times to stay at his place and go diving/collecting with him whenever I could make it over to Honolulu. For my 50th B-Day we, my wife and I had planned on doing something fun like a quality guided Salmon/Steelhead Fishing trip where I did not have to take charge or run things as usual. Shortly before booking something our plans were side-railed by her Business trip to China getting rescheduled last minute to the last two weeks of September covering my Birthday of course. But being the wonderful wife that she is said "Why don't you do something FUN just for you like go to Hawaii and visit Les" after many hugs and kisses I called up Les and said "Hey Bro, guess what......." and using her business miles cost me a whole $5.20 for round trip air fair to Honolulu from Seattle.

I had all these ideas swimming around in my head for days about what, where and how this Fish Collection would go down...... none was even close............. After getting settled in at Les's place and getting the nickel tour of his operation we or I helped him with some water changes on his Holding Tanks then after dinner loaded up everything for our first Dive and off we went as the Sun was going down.....hmmmmmm.......
At an undisclosed location we geared up with Snorkel Gear, hand nets, Dive Lights and collection containers and dropped into the inky water within Pearl Harbor. First off you need to picture me a 'Mainlander' in a bright Traffic Cone Orange 5mm Wetsuit without forgotten weight belt uncontrollably bobbing around the shoreline................. OK, with this picture in your head I was only able to tip upside down and stretch my arms to maybe 5-6' at best in depth. Les paralleled the shore about 20' out and I stayed very close to have any chance at all. Literally within the first five minutes with a dive light in my right hand and net in my left a lil Tang swam nearly into my mask..... with a quick flip of my net I had caught my very first fish of the night. With me struggling/floating like a neon orange cork we did not stay out long but long enough for Les to catch several juvenile Butterfly's and Tangs plus half a pair of Moorish Idols. I ended up with the small Blochii Tang a few small Butterfly's, small Sailfin and Unicorn Tang, pair of Coral Banded Shrimp and other half of Moorish Idol pair and maybe another one or two that i cannot remember now. When we get back we place all fish in holding tanks dosed with Formalin which they stay in for 18-24 hours before going into copper treated 40B's or a 250g vat.

This is early the next evening while transferring fish into copper treated holding tanks, my first ever collected lil Blochii Tang



For the first few days we would do maintenance and/or bag and box Fish that had already gone through a two week medicated QT, were readily eating and healthy and run down to FedEx or an Airline Shipping Center to send off to customers/LFS's on the Mainland. Prep our gear and everything like charging Dive lights and making sure we had good batteries in air pumps for Livestock transport and as the Sun sat off we would go to always a different location. I learned a whole lot from Les on Collecting ethically and sustainably. At night these fish are in a subdued state and easy to encourage into the net with little stress on them. Almost all the fish we/he collected were juveniles and not of breeding age. Most all the fish we/he collected are in our opinions good aquarium candidates and ship well, those that were not ideal only went to specific clients that Les felt had the knowledge and or experience to handle. Any questionable fish that was not acclimating and eating well through QT process was netted from tanks and brought back out with us and released back to the Reef.

To be continued...... Cheers/Mahalo, Todd
 
This pic below was one of the nights after getting back and placing fish in a Formalin treated tank.



These are a few pics of the 40B's holding a variety of small Butterfly's and Tangs after a few days of collecting.




And this is the 27 Hawaiian Bicolor Anthias we bought from another Diver that collected them from 85-90' and spent 2+ hours on decompressing them correctly. Much to deep for me not being properly certified. I had all the Anthias eating NLS pellets within two days of capture.



These are daylight pics of Formalin tubs, some fish being separated for aggression reasons or known jumpers.........




And the big 250g vats for large numbers of slightly larger Tangs, Wrasses, Triggers etc..




This was such a Unforgettable and Amazing ADVENTURE for me plus an eye opening event in the business of Tropical Marine Fish Collection making it somewhat 'Full Circle' as a Reefkeeper, LFS employee and finally in Collection and Shipment. Hope you enjoyed my story and more so hope at least some of you get this kind of opportunity at some point.

Cheers/Mahalo, Todd
 
The same Blochii Tang as above now 6"+ in my 125g and needing to be re-homed unfortunately




Three of the Bicolor Anthias, Naso, Yellow and Kole Tang plus the Flame Angel that Les sent me later.




Cheers/Mahalo, Todd
 
I wanna do that soooo bad!!
Can't say I'd have much of a chance, though. I really can't get down past 7 or 8 feet without the pressure making my head feel like it's going to implode. The fibromyalgia doesn't help either. But oh, if I could!!!

I'm glad you found those photos and I really enjoyed the story :)
 
Thanks Eienna and Hung, going back in June and plan to do a little collecting again though probably not any Fish. Zoanthids, Octocoral, Macro Algae and some interesting inverts are my goal for this trip. The one possible exception would be if I could capture a Flame or Potters Wrasse or a very small Chevron or Achilles Tang. I'm adamant about not collecting Achilles any larger than 2-3" since most all perish.

Cheers/Mahalo, Todd
 
One more pic, I posted this in my build thread a while back but this is my lil Naso Tang when I first brought it home about 2" only. The Longnose B-fly did not make it through a Ich outbreak about a month later unfortunately.



And with his/her buddy the Powder Blue now at around 5"


This lil guy (Halfspotted Goby) I collected in a Tide Pool and was less than an inch, now about 2" while gathering the Hermits in pic below.




OK, now I'm done......lol


Cheers/Mahalo, Todd

 
The same Blochii Tang as above now 6"+ in my 125g and needing to be re-homed unfortunately




Three of the Bicolor Anthias, Naso, Yellow and Kole Tang plus the Flame Angel that Les sent me later.




Cheers/Mahalo, Todd

Great fishes , i dont see never these tang , but is very georgeus !
Do you have any problem with the corals and your flame angel ?
 
How much does it typically cost to get a permit to catch these fish and get them transported into the mainland US?

Thinking maybe I could at least do a little tidepool collecting...
 
Last edited:
Eienna, you can get permits from either Hawaii DLNR or something similar to a Fish & Game license and runs $12-20 is all. Most all regulations are directed to food fish means so some are a little unrealistic towards Reeftank related ideas such as the Convict Tang though by far the most abundant needs to be 5" minimum and some Unicorn tangs 14" or better. As for shipping it only cost me like $84 to ship a full 150 quart Ice Chest back with 50+ fish and 100's of inverts.
Chris, Les does not collect any more in general though would probably do so for a select few if convenient.

Lalo, unfortunately my Flame has turned on a new Favites colony and will most likely be removed if I can catch it now.

Cheers/Mahalo, Todd
 
Great read, what a blast that must have been.

(Todd, don't know if you realize, but the blue font is incredibly hard to read on tapatalk. I always skip your posts until I get home and can read it on the browser)
 
Eienna, you can get permits from either Hawaii DLNR or something similar to a Fish & Game license and runs $12-20 is all. Most all regulations are directed to food fish means so some are a little unrealistic towards Reeftank related ideas such as the Convict Tang though by far the most abundant needs to be 5" minimum and some Unicorn tangs 14" or better. As for shipping it only cost me like $84 to ship a full 150 quart Ice Chest back with 50+ fish and 100's of inverts.
Chris, Les does not collect any more in general though would probably do so for a select few if convenient.

Lalo, unfortunately my Flame has turned on a new Favites colony and will most likely be removed if I can catch it now.

Cheers/Mahalo, Todd

Okay, thanks. Where can I check on specific regulations for this?
 
Great read, what a blast that must have been.

(Todd, don't know if you realize, but the blue font is incredibly hard to read on tapatalk. I always skip your posts until I get home and can read it on the browser)

Thanks, did not know and have been using font style and color for several years now..... on the positive side it saved you from reading some of my lonnnnnnng RANTS on LED's and Engineering topics.....lol Does this Dk Green work or would Maroon be better ???

This trip literally changed my life and definitely how I now view this hobby of ours in whole. It really brought home that we can do this to a very sustainable level by collecting primarily juvenile Fish and not breeding pairs or of breeding age. The math is enlightening, as somewhere between 1 in 3000 to 1 in 5000 newly hatched fish make it to breeding age so even with a guess-timation of predation/mortality to make it to juvenile stage and becoming a 1 in 50-100 fish. Les did a little Spring collecting of post larval fish a couple years for one of the big Wholesalers to 'Tank Raise' and felt that it had/has a miniscule impact on Wild Fish populations and very little impact for the collection of juvenile aged ones. The big advantages of collecting these juvenile fish at night and in shallow to very shallow water was not over stressing them, no decrompression issues and were very easy to get eat prepared foods such as NLS Pellets, Seaweed Extreme Pellets and dried Nori sheets as they were still at that 'try everything age' I can only hope that the collection of Ornamental Marine Fish will continue in the Hawaiian Islands and as a group of Diver/Collectors and Environmentalists can come to some agreement in sustainable collection practices that will satisfy both parties.


Cheers/Mahalo, Todd


Cheers, Todd
 
Eienna or ??? I just filed online for my 'Recreational Aquarium Permit' for collecting and seems to be a no charge ??? license through the Hawaii DLNR.
Link is below, now hopefully can find or receive list of rules with license.

http://state.hi.us/dlnr/dar/licenses_permits.html

http://state.hi.us/dlnr/dar/fishing.html


​Cheers, Todd
 
Last edited:
Todd, green is the best as it actually shows as white font (against dark grey background) in tapatalk and as for font style I think tapatalk converts it all to the same font so that isn't an issue. Thanks, I enjoy reading your posts and now I can actually do that from my phone.
 
This is awesome, and I hope to do this one day. Even if it is only 1 fish, to have a fish in my home reef that I collected would be an amazing feeling. I took my first trip out to Hawaii this november and look to do it again soon!
 
Marshall, you will love it and was certainly a BIG DEAL for me in collecting my own Livestock. Beyond the Fish and Hermits mentioned above I also collected and brought home Coral Banded Shrimp, Snakehead Cowries and Nerite Snails (that all crawled out eventually). The permit does indeed seem to be a N/C fro 'Recreational Aquarium License' and will be mailed to me. I will let everyone know how it goes actually getting them home myself through the Airline this time and from Kauai instead of Oahu. Also, I've been to St. Cloud a few times.... I used to be a Rep for Design Line Cabinets before Crystal bought them out.

Cheers, Todd

 
Okay - this thread is awesome! The purple NOZ caught my eye. One of my favorites. lol

Amazing experience, I'm sure. Amazing even from afar. Thanks for sharing!!
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top