Why yes my GFO does tumble. It very well could have been the case. My carbon did get really gummed up after 2 days after I changed it. But Like I said all is back to good now! Thanks for the insight.It could have been your GFO. Do you tuble yours? I tumble mine and last week after messing with the carbon I had GFO fines all over the tank and the water was very cloudy. The GFO rubs against itself and grinds into a dust making the water cloudy. The good news is that it won't hurt anything. No real bad news. My skimmer was much more red/orange than normal and carbon gets really gummed up. It also looks like a small diatom bloom on the sand if enough settles.

