Near disaster partialy averted tonight.

I'll say! And yet this whole thing does seem like such bad luck. I guess 1 in a million situations happen now and then if your sample size is large enough.
Yea no kidding. I have had this tank running for 12 years and one before it for a few so over time crap happens I suppose.
 
I'm definitely adding a floor water sensor upstairs under the main tank that is for sure, but that won't keep it from happening again.
 
I would try covering the overflow with a small square of mesh like is used for a mesh top. Large enough to avoid clogging easily from food and whatever, but small enough to keep unexpected stock out. A simple zip tie or similar would hold it in place, and make it simple for cleaning.

EDIT: I mean cover that open emergency drain tube... not the entire overflow. Sorry if that was unclear.
No worries. It makes me wonder though if I did use a mesh to cover the entire overflow box wouldn't that prevent this bc it woukd be impossible for a fish to get in then. Granted the fish could still jump out but at least it wouldn't flood the kitchen.
 
So my concern about covering the emergency drain is that may make the problem worse bc eventhough it may stop a fish from getting in it would clog easier and the fish still could get sucked to the cover causing the same issue. That would at least be my concern.
You'll need to check it more often but it works. My set up is similar. I used a course screen cover. I see them everyday. No clogs yet. Fingers crossed. Lol
 
No worries. It makes me wonder though if I did use a mesh to cover the entire overflow box wouldn't that prevent this bc it woukd be impossible for a fish to get in then. Granted the fish could still jump out but at least it wouldn't flood the kitchen.
Some of the kit tanks they sell these days come with overflow covers and they look tidy too.
 
It's a small wonder that your wife noticed it and caught the "oops" before it became a home renovation project.
For sure. She heard the dog drinking the tank water off the floor. Seems gross but his slurping drew her to the kitchen. It happened like 11 pm so any layer and we would have been in bed. I have about 60 gallons of water in my sump so this would have put a ton of water on the floor before it ran out.
 
You'll need to check it more often but it works. My set up is similar. I used a course screen cover. I see them everyday. No clogs yet. Fingers crossed. Lol
That is the issue this ran for 12 years just fine then bam waterfall in the kitchen.
 
I'm definitely adding a floor water sensor upstairs under the main tank that is for sure, but that won't keep it from happening again.
These are AWESOME. I have Neptune Leak Detectors, but IMO, these are better as they give an audible detection as well as notifications. Also, they have a sensor on the top and bottom, unlike Watchdog or Neptune.

Govee Water Detectors
 
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
I have a strainer on the main drain but I was always told to leave the emergency open so that it doesn't get clogged since it shoukd only be being used in case of an emergency.
On a tuned Herbie, there should be a trickle down the secondary anyway.

Strainer would be a good investment.
 
glad you caught it and nice wife to allow you to have a kitchen tank…
and sorry, as some one with a Valentini i know 1) how clever, inquisitive they are and likely to get into unexpected situations, and 2) how much you miss it.

E18DFFE3-365D-447A-9CB2-4341BEB7AD12.jpeg
 
Very interesting. Is it just me that enjoys watching engineering disasters on youtube? A bunch of professionals with fancy degrees and millions of dollars still managed to mess stuff up, what hope is there for people like me on my aquarium? I think anyone that hasn't had a mini disaster with their aquarium is either extremely lucky or hasn't been in the hobby long enough.

Sorry about your fish/tank. I would brush it off, learn from the mistake and try to set up a system to prevent it in the future.

Have you thought about adding a float valve on the tank that will turn off the return pump if the water gets too high? Can you add another emergency drain? Flood alarm would be a great idea.
 
I had a similar scenario (but no waterfall) with a sixline wrasse that somehow made it into the overflow and got caught up in the gate valve of the main overflow pipe. This triggered the emergency overflow and I was alerted to the problem by the noisy sound of water running down the emergency overflow.

Beyond covering the overflow box, other than increasing the diameter of the emergency overflow I'm not sure what else you could do to avoid this in the future. Both overflows should be setup with a wider diameter than your return plumbing to ensure any one can completely drain the tank.
 
These are AWESOME. I have Neptune Leak Detectors, but IMO, these are better as they give an audible detection as well as notifications. Also, they have a sensor on the top and bottom, unlike Watchdog or Neptune.

Govee Water Detectors
Thanks. That looks like a good idea bc I can put them everywhere and as you said wifi alerts and audible.
 
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
glad you caught it and nice wife to allow you to have a kitchen tank…
and sorry, as some one with a Valentini i know 1) how clever, inquisitive they are and likely to get into unexpected situations, and 2) how much you miss it.

E18DFFE3-365D-447A-9CB2-4341BEB7AD12.jpeg
Yea he was a great fish. I was always leery about adding one but now that I have had one I would highly recommend. I just have to make sure I out smart it next time.
 
100g display that I have been running with mostly the same setup for 12 years. Tonight my wife started telling that the fish tank which is in the kitchen is overflowing. I spring up and sure enough water flowing over the top like a waterfall. I ran to the basement and unplugged the return pump then started to frantically figure out what had happened. The overflow is setup as a herbie so this should never happen. To make a long story short after a fair amount of looking somehow my valentini puffer made its way into my overflow (I have no.idea how that is even possible. He isn't a jumper) and then went down the emergency drain and became stuck in the hose rendering the emergency drain useless and then the main got out of whack and it became a waterfall. Lucky we caught it really quick fixed the issue and it's back up and running minus my poor puffer. I have no idea how this could happen. Any thoughts are appreciated bc this can't happen again.

an2_20211204_130420.jpg
@Greenstarfish03 That sucks. I suppose one could invest in something with a leak detector and a shutdown of the pumps. Perhaps a smart plug that works with a leak system and there are a few of both out there, some that will also let Alexa/Siri or Google know. If you wish to spend more or have more control of both, get an Apex system and add the FMM with LDK sensors and flow sensors. If you see either stop or LDK, use that as trigger to set off audible alarm and send notifications.

I'm pretty sure there are some open source solutions that will even summon your mopping bot if this occurs as well.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top