Opinion/help/ideas

dexterie

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Jul 9, 2017
Messages
157
Reaction score
128
Location
Belgium
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
so..I’m not having a great time here.

I set my first saltwater tank last year, in July. It a Red Sea max nano. All went well, with little hiccups here and there.
Got some fish (a couple clownfish, a damsel, a cardinal and a bicolor blenny). Also a cleaning crew and some cheap coral to start with. I was very excited with it all and the tank was looking nice.
Then, last April, I stated to notice algae problems. Cyano, Dino? At the LFS I was told, from the pics, that it was Dino. Got dinoX and it worked. One weeks after the downfall started. More algae. The cardinal died, most of the snails died. The skunk shrimp died..all in a few days.
The algae kept propagating. Lyngbya, I was told, after all the usual procedures. 3 day blackout, nopox, phosphate removing media. Water changes. No water changes. The tank looks terrible. Fish seem to be doing ok, but everything is covered in algae, no matter how much I scrub, blow, ...
I even went down to try fluconazole...no effect.

I’m thinking about giving up. It’s a shame, but..this is going nowhere.
I just don’t know what to do with the tank. The fish I’d probably be lucky and have them accepted at a LFS. Same with the few snails and hermits I have.
Or..do you think I could just clean the tank, remove all sand, all rock and keep the fish? I just feel they’d be unhappy in a bare tank.

Please, pleas give me ideas. How do you see the idea of a bare tank? How could I do it? I have a small fluval edge that I could use to keep the fish for a few hours while I clean the tank. Should I save some of its water?
Any other idea or solution? I’d rather keep the tank and as a normal tank.

Parameters seem to be ok. I’ve always had low phosphates.. So it’s a typical low nutrient case, i think. Decided to increase magnesium this week. Still no visible effects. I don’t have a reactor (I don’t even know how I could use one in such a small tank).

Thank you for any info/comment.

PS: I feel that, somehow, the algae issue was made worse with the heatwave(s) that hit Belgium this summer. I got a ventilator to keep the tank fresher, but the house was very warm.
 
Last edited:
Thank you for your replies guys.
Here’s a pic I took today to show at the lfs

413D2637-8FF5-4E9D-9822-00603F79E529.jpeg


It’s all over. Sandbed, back wall, rocks...corals.
 
Dexterie...
Although this post gives you no advice on how to fix your problem, don’t give up. That’s the easy way out of any problem in life, including aquariums. I just finished a 3 month battle of cyano. I wanted to pull my hair out. It was driving me INSANE. Water test after water test, countless water changes, minimal feedings, lights out, dead coral, it all did nothing. Now I just wake up everyday and hope that I don’t see it coming back. We’ve all lost livestock, even the best of us, for no known reason to us. There are guys on here that have lost entire SPS tanks for no known reason. A lot of folks on here have had tanks for a long time and even they encounter problems.

If this was an easy hobby, everyone would do it.

Good luck sir.
 
Dexterie...
Although this post gives you no advice on how to fix your problem, don’t give up. That’s the easy way out of any problem in life, including aquariums. I just finished a 3 month battle of cyano. I wanted to pull my hair out. It was driving me INSANE. Water test after water test, countless water changes, minimal feedings, lights out, dead coral, it all did nothing. Now I just wake up everyday and hope that I don’t see it coming back. We’ve all lost livestock, even the best of us, for no known reason to us. There are guys on here that have lost entire SPS tanks for no known reason. A lot of folks on here have had tanks for a long time and even they encounter problems.

If this was an easy hobby, everyone would do it.

Good luck sir.
You’re right. But sometimes it just feels too much. It’s like a fighting a battle that is impossible to win. Maybe something will help. :)
Thank you
 
Have you tried an urchin it solved my problem
 
Last edited:
Yes, rodi...
With an out break that large there is something fueling it. A few spots , yes more snails, fluconazole . But with that there is clearly a systemic problem or neglect.
For the latter , basically scrub n scrub or a peroxide bath / full rebuild scenario.
Ammonia , no3 , and Po4 are the main drivers of alge. How they got in the tank to that point is he question.
My rodi got to 2 tds and I had problems. But my tap water is basically poison. 450+ with cloramines too.
 
I’ve had a tuxedo urchin... it was one of the victims.
I will add more to my cuc. Not sure what to get, but I’ll head to the LFS tomorrow and see what they have.
I already have a few hermits (around 8); a few astrea, and 5 tectus that I got today.

Should I try to get a Sea hare? Not sure if I can find them here in belgium...

Thank you all for your help.
 
With an out break that large there is something fueling it. A few spots , yes more snails, fluconazole . But with that there is clearly a systemic problem or neglect.
For the latter , basically scrub n scrub or a peroxide bath / full rebuild scenario.
Ammonia , no3 , and Po4 are the main drivers of alge. How they got in the tank to that point is he question.
My rodi got to 2 tds and I had problems. But my tap water is basically poison. 450+ with cloramines too.

I’ve been trying it all. The water from the rodi is ok. I measure it two weeks ago.
I scrub most of the rocks every other day. I feel it stressed the coral too... I don’t think it’s a negligence case.. The only time I didn’t do the water changes, for example, was when I decided to try and let it be for 3 weeks..no help.

Thanks!
 
But what?
I even stopped giving them frozen food.
I feed a little as possible. The rocks? The sand?

Just checked. TDS at 9. Too much? (Comes from the tap at 252]
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%

New Posts

Back
Top