Options to solve Red Sea Reefer plumbing leak.

dmsc2fs

Well-Known Member
View Badges
Joined
Dec 29, 2021
Messages
502
Reaction score
583
Location
Charleston
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
How we got here

I decided to replace the Red Sea ATO with another option to move the ATO out of the stand and free up room. This was going great and I was complete with it. I was testing the top up when I noticed a drip from the main drain line. I thought maybe I had dripped some water as part of the ATO work since I pulled the ATO hose through the stand hole just behind the drain.

I looked at it more closely and I could see that the water was swelling around the coupler and had a slight drip to it. I gave it a small turn and I could tighten it by hand. Thinking it had come loose I gave it a bit more of a turn. This is when I had that tell tale sound of plastic snapping that you know is going to ruin the rest of your day.

I pulled the main drain off and i swapped the overflow drain over to the main drain. This didn't fix the problem. I can tighten the plastic nut on the main drain enough that it tightens and gets tight enough that I am concerned that I would snap that nut as well so I don't want to try any tigher. Beyond that, the joint has an O-Ring. I shouldn't have to tighten it that tight to get a seal. The O-Ring should do it.

What can I do about it/Options

I purchased this tank on 31/DEC/2021 so it is only a few months old. My first plan is to call Red Sea Monday morning and see what they recommend. I do not have a lot of faith they are going to provide any remedy for me that will help. I am going to hedge towards they will say it is user error and it is on me to fix. So, how do I fix it.

I thought about just filling the entire fitting with silicone and sealing it that way. I am concerned with doing this since it may not work and I still have a problem to solve. If I did go this route I think i would do it with new pieces and move to a better gate valve.

I can probably replace the entire fitting, it does have a nut on the bottom of it. I don't know how I would find a tool large enough to fit it. Does anyone have a guess as to the size of socket it might need. How would I even replace it. I assume I have to remove all the plumbing and that is going to be a problem but I guess it may be the only option.

I have thought about doing something similar to above where I would replace the nut/connector only but swap the two drains around so that this one is the emergency overflow and I move the main drain to the center one. This would allow me to silicone the fitting together but it would be the emergency drain. I don't know how this helps though, since I have to tear the plumbing out from inside the tank and this is going to have more potential issues.

I don't know any good answers to this problem now so if you have some thoughts please share them. This is how I am "fixing" the leak at this time but I also have to run the valve fully open, any back pressure causes it to leak more. Of course this also means I have the most enjoyable gurgle to live with.

One thing I am thinking about doing is buying a siphon overflow. The point for doing this would be to hang it off the front of the tank lower than the current overflow. This would allow me to keep the tank running, but not use the rear overflow and buy me some time to solve the bigger problem. Thoughts on this?

I really do appreciate any help or ideas you can throw at me. I am not excited about having a problem like this 3 months into my tank setup.
 
A while back when doing sump maintenance on my return pump I noticed that one of the couplings on my overflow (not sure if it was the main or emergency) was loose also, so I just hand tightened it. I was 99.9% sure they were tight when I did the installation but it's entirely possible I missed that one. In any event, I've done a few manual inspections on the couplings since and haven't noticed any loose again. From what I remember the couplings in the bottom of the overflow were pre-installed so I'm not sure if they're siliconed in place or if they're easily removable (this is why you can't lay the tank down flat or risk damaging these).

My suggestion is to contact Red Sea and hopefully they can get back to you right away with a solution.
 
Thanks. After I had time some time to start looking at it and come up with a game plan I have a few options.

I need to replace both parts as the quickest path towards resolution. I can try replacing the Aquarium inner downpipe (R42202A) or the Sump valved downpipe (R42324) and hope I default to picking the correct one. I think the problem is in the aquarium but if I am wrong I have a longer delay for resolution. I am going to throw money at the problem and buy both. If it turns out the problem is the aquarium downpipe I will use the spare sump downpipe to convert to a gate valve.

The problem I have now is that nobody online is selling the Aquarium downpipe. My LFS Red Sea vendor isn't open Monday so if I talk to them today I won't have a clear path until Tuesday. That might be the option I have to deal with.
 
I have the xxl750 - when I was putting everything together I heard that "snap" also. When I filled the tank about a month ago - I realized I had installed the emergency/main drain in the wrong positions and had to swap them. That was when I noticed the connector was cracked and that was what the snap sound was. The female portion that spins had split right down the middle. I was able to get it to thread, but not nearly as tight as I would "think" it needs to be. However, there is no sign of leakage to this point and my hope is that the o-ring is doing the work there. I hope you find a solution to your issues and I have to say I am surprised that yours is not holding well. Try using gentle pressure to ensure the o-ring goes up all the way and just get it as tight as you can without the female part "opening" up - that is what I did and it is holding.
 
Not solution to offer here. Rather I can say that I’ve got 100% faith that Red Sea will take care of you, despite the user error. They’re such a great company with amazing customer service. I would be disappointed if they didn’t help you.
 
I have the xxl750 - when I was putting everything together I heard that "snap" also. When I filled the tank about a month ago - I realized I had installed the emergency/main drain in the wrong positions and had to swap them. That was when I noticed the connector was cracked and that was what the snap sound was. The female portion that spins had split right down the middle. I was able to get it to thread, but not nearly as tight as I would "think" it needs to be. However, there is no sign of leakage to this point and my hope is that the o-ring is doing the work there. I hope you find a solution to your issues and I have to say I am surprised that yours is not holding well. Try using gentle pressure to ensure the o-ring goes up all the way and just get it as tight as you can without the female part "opening" up - that is what I did and it is holding.

Not solution to offer here. Rather I can say that I’ve got 100% faith that Red Sea will take care of you, despite the user error. They’re such a great company with amazing customer service. I would be disappointed if they didn’t help you.

I have tried a few times to push the o-ring up and it just will not seal. The reason I have fear that it is the Aquarium downpipe is because I moved the emergency sump downpipe over to the main sump downpipe and that would not seal either. I honestly don't know one way or another if Red Sea should, or should not, consider any kind of warranty coverage. I can argue the point either way. I am hoping they can give me a solid solution to finding the aquarium downpipe I need and if I have to pay for it myself, so be it. I a sure they can give me a solution, but sitting on a Sunday morning drinking coffee and finding nobody that sells the part online is a bummer. Here is what I have done to "solve" the problem for now. Not a long term solution but at least the tank is back flowing water. Once I plug my UV back in I will be back into "normal" operations - with a leak.

I used silicone cooking mat and zip tied it to make a funnel to divert the water back into the sump. The water pools onto the mat and drops into the sump at about 1/4 teaspoon every 1-2 seconds. It's not a huge leak, but I need to solve it.

IMG_4994.JPG
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top