Orange Spotted Filefish (OSFF)

Lionfish Lair

Renee
View Badges
Joined
Jan 29, 2012
Messages
8,812
Reaction score
9,042
Location
California
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
There's a site that has been selling weaned WYSIWYG Orange Spotted Filefish for some time now. Does anyone know personally or even through the grape vine, how they have been doing? Like, did they continue to eat frozen, or did they give it up again? I'm not digging up much info about those.
 
I'm trying to decide if I should get the "trained" ones or just get them untrained from the LFS. If there's not a huge difference, I'll go with the LFS. If they take it like gangbusters, that's one thing. If they're still just picking, they're not worth it for the extra price.
 
I know someone who has one, purchased through Divers Den, and I believe he's had it about a year. I know he had at least one that didn't make it before that, purchased from the LFS. That one was also weaned onto frozen before purchase. I can't recall how long he had it before it went downhill, but he said his experience with the DD fish was much better.
 
I would like to try this fish myself one day and have read up on them quite a bit, but I'm not there yet with a suitable home. There is a lot of useful information in this thread.
 
In the (very long, but very informative) RC thread I linked, most who kept them in tanks with SPS experienced a lack of polyp extension from certain corals, rather than actual damage. Some experienced nipping of LPS. In all cases, the fish was deemed more important/desirable than the corals, so if you're the type who prizes corals over fish, probably not the fish for you.
 
To get them weaned is probably worth every penny. Follow the thread on breeding them for more insight.

Agreed. Everyone I've heard from who weaned/attempted to wean theirs themselves said it was incredibly difficult, labor intensive, and not always with a positive outcome. The DD stories are in stark contrast, with a high success rate. The DD fish still need special attention, but feeding them doesn't take over your life, as it seems weaning on your own does.
 
If the DDs were eating with gusto, they are worth the money. If I have to retrain them because they aren't eating like champs, I might as well put that extra money into my own training, you know what I mean? I've honestly heard zip about these guys from DD. They are selling them almost everyday and I'm not seeing them all over the forums. Why I wonder. People love to show their stuff.... where are DD's Orange Spots!!! WHERE!!!
 
Give the RC thread I linked a thorough read. Several accounts of DD purchases, documented over the course of a few years, along with some contrasting experiences with LFS purchases. Incredibly valuable, real life experiences, both good and bad.

It's up to you, but after reading through that thread and every other one I've come across by googling (I've been researching this fish since the Coral magazine article on it, dreaming of one day attempting), DD is your best shot at success. It's more than just the training; it's also the fact that the LFS fish has usually gone too long without food along the chain of custody.
 
Do you know why? Like what they noticed about the fish before it died?

The DD fish is still alive. I believe he purchased it about a year ago. The one he purchased from an LFS (prior to the DD fish) is the one that died, but no, I don't know the circumstances of that. He's a member of my local fish club, someone I see from time to time, but don't talk to on a regular basis. He has the fish inside a display tank in the bar he owns. If you're ever in Portland, you can visit him.
 
Heh, the daughter may be moving to Portland.!

I think I'll give the DDs a go. If I have to retrain I'll have to retrain. Gonna wait for a chubby one to show up.
 
Never have I heard of a DD one that had to be retrained to the extent of smearing food on coral skeletons, but of course some are more eager than others to take particular foods and all have to be watched to make sure they really are eating in the beginning. That may feel like re-training, but does not begin to compare with the experiences shared by those who started from square one with starving fish from the LFS.

One thing that become very evident in the long RC thread was that everyone's fish had different food preferences; even those who purchased pairs experienced each of their fish gobbling up completely different foods. Popular items were Nutrimar ova (no longer available), formula 1 & 2 gel foods, cyclops, NLS pellets, Ocean Nutrition reef flakes, roe, mysis, spirulina brine, regular brine, and a couple of other things, but not every fish ate all those items, and some fish would only consume one or two particular things, while others gobbled everything in sight.

The bar owner said his DD fish was eating mysis straight out of the shipping bag, but reading through the RC thread, some fish owners say theirs won't touch mysis. Same goes for just about all other foods - some fish love them and others refuse them. The important thing is that all the DD fish accepted some type of prepared food. With the LFS purchases, some would not eat anything, others would only eat coral, and others accepted prepared foods but were already too far gone when the owner purchased them. There were some LFS purchase successes, but many failures; I don't recall any DD failures, other than fish that died for other reasons long after they were purchased.

If you get one, treat us all to info and pictures!
 
Walking through the Aquarium of the Pacific..... oh hello!

filefish_zpsxmfdyv9d.jpg
 
I'm looking for a mandarin pair for this tank as well. I'm sad that ORA stopped breeding them. I know a lot of people were having trouble with them not eating frozen as they expected, but they were captive bred! CAPTIVE BRED! I would pay extra for captive bred over wild any day. We need to support everything that's responsibly captive bred and reasonably priced. Planning to train the mandarins as well. I'll get the first fish, deal with it and make sure it will convert. If it doesn't than I'll have a mandy in the 100g tank too. If it converts, it's on the second of the pair. I know it's silly, but I want a blue and a red. The red may be harder to find, especially where the blue, (which I'm sure I'll find first) will dictate the sex required of the next. But I can wait until I find it.

I'm not looking for an OSFF pair. Just a single.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%

New Posts

Back
Top