Palytoxin released into air by protein skimmer??

Could a protein skimmer release palytoxins from zoanthids into the air?

  • Yes

    Votes: 14 15.6%
  • No

    Votes: 77 85.6%

  • Total voters
    90
Palytoxin is a very large molecule, so it is not likely to go airborne. BUT a protein skimmer will emit a mist which could carry some toxin into the air. Generally speaking palys will not release the toxin unless something or somebody ticks it off by rubbing against it, biting it, cutting it or even a coral being too close to it. This is natures way of a zoa fighting for space on the reef. In our tanks, there is not much space. Also remember, most zoas have no toxin, but it is not easy to know what does and what does not. If your tank has palytoxin in it, almost everything will be dead.

Julian Sprung has a video about his experience with palytoxins. Julian is an expert aquarist and he got hit. Watch the video and remember it can happen.

 
How bout these suckers. Growing everywhere!! Gotta do something. Laser them or inject each one with kalkwasser ? What do u think? Will they release their toxins while getting annhilated?

IMG_5919.JPG
 
I've never had a problem and have fragged them for years. I ha e a friend that had a paly squirt when she was fragging and it messed her eye up for a week or so ...red and itchy. Wear protective gear. To me Euphyllias ar what I watch out. Been stung by them a few times.
 
Here is part of an article from masna. I think that most people are overly concerned about palytoxin especially from zoanthids. People often call zoanthids palys if they are a little bit larger in size (like 1/2" diameter vs 1/4") but this is wrong. Almost all of the stories that I have seen about palytoxin are about actual palythoa. They are often green and brown and they have a sandpaper like skin and they slime up when you touch them. I have lots of zoanthids and I wear glasses when I frag them and was my hands when I touch them but I dont worry about them coming out of my skimmer or nuking my tank. I don't keep actual palythoa because 1) they are ugly 2) they contain more of the palytoxin. Maybe you could upload a photo to show us what kind you have.

True Palythoa are brownish though some have bright shades of green. They are also very slimy and the tissue itself feels rough as they incorporate sand and other hard material into their tissue to strengthen themselves (Sprung 2003). The family Zoanthidae is the exception and they do not incorporate any particulates into their body. The organization of the tentacles into two distinct rows is the main shared characteristic of zoanthids.

This is palytoxin. It is produced by both Palythoa and Zoanthus sp. though the latter produces far less palytoxin than the former (Deeds 2011, Sprung 2015).

http://masna.org/masna-education/palytoxin/
 
I have a tank full of zoas and paly's and I never worry about poly toxin. I frag them, move them around when needed and never have wore gloves. I don't touch my face and I make sure I don't have any cuts on my hands, then wash my hands and arms once done. I think some have over reacted on this topic and it's just common sense as with anything.
Of course there could be some people who are/could be sensitive when working in their tank, so then you would just wear gloves.
 
Last edited:
Well I can tell you first hand that this story is about whet happened to me. And I know alot of people will argue it. But yes my protein skimmer did release the palytoxin that was in the water into the air. I went blind from the issue and had to have a cornea replacement.
The threat of palyotoxin poisoning (while the threat is there) is widely thrown out of proportion. Practically all instances of people getting palytoxin poisoning was from fragging, or boiling rock that has polyps on it. I've had zoas my entire reefing career and never once ran into an issue. But I put them in their spot, and leave them alone. Unless you're fragging, or heavily irritating them or cutting or boiling them, you'll be fine.
 
The palytoxin phobia seems to be contagious!

Don't chew on your zoas, don't cook them (or your rock), don't handle your palys and then lick your fingers....and you will be fine. :D:D:D

I disagree 100% with this being a phobia. I spent 3 days in hospital after moving green colony from mid level to lower level of my tank. It wasn't pretty. When 3 Drs are scratching their heads until one asks have you been overseas or swimming in ocean - No, but I was elbow deep in my reef tank. 10 days of meds before swelling (all over body) went down. Tell me it's a phobia! And NO I wasn't chewing on them, cooking them or licking my fingers - I moved them from mid level to lower level without gloves - not anymore - gloves always.
 
I had some issues breathing when I bought. A used tank and didnt know what they were. I scrubbed hair algea off all the rocks in my basement while pouring hydrogen peroxide on them. I scrubbed good and hard with a toothbrush. About 30 minutes in I started having trouble getting full breaths of air.

I ran outside in a snow storm for about 30 minutes till I was breathing fine.

That is the only time I've had issues with them.
 
I had some issues breathing when I bought. A used tank and didnt know what they were. I scrubbed hair algea off all the rocks in my basement while pouring hydrogen peroxide on them. I scrubbed good and hard with a toothbrush. About 30 minutes in I started having trouble getting full breaths of air.

I ran outside in a snow storm for about 30 minutes till I was breathing fine.

That is the only time I've had issues with them.
 
I disagree 100% with this being a phobia. I spent 3 days in hospital after moving green colony from mid level to lower level of my tank. It wasn't pretty. When 3 Drs are scratching their heads until one asks have you been overseas or swimming in ocean - No, but I was elbow deep in my reef tank. 10 days of meds before swelling (all over body) went down. Tell me it's a phobia! And NO I wasn't chewing on them, cooking them or licking my fingers - I moved them from mid level to lower level without gloves - not anymore - gloves always.

What were your symptoms? If just swelling that is not a reported symptom with palytoxin and sounds like you had anaphylaxis.

There are no antidotes for palytoxin. No specific meds for it, only supportive care. What medicines did they give you? 1-2 days of symptoms is on the long side for palytoxin as well.
 
Your more likely to get attacked by a Polar Bear and a Grizzly Bear on Monday, bit on the butt cheek by a Great White Shark on Tuesday, and win the PowerBall on Wednesday..... before you get Palytoxin poisoning. Stop worrying about it and enjoy your tank. Don't eat them, don't sauté them, or use them as breath mints and you'll be fine.
 
They all have different levels of the toxin. I recently was shot in the eye fragging Palys (Mohawk). It’s a week later and my eye is still twitching and sore, I have swelling around eye/cheek but the redness is now gone. I have one spot on my eye that still looks irritated. What saved me was flushing my eye right away and I had a flush at the emergency room.

Just be safe when fragging, wear gloves and glasses. I frag, rinse and then run carbon afterwards. Wash your hands well. Most inhalation’s I have read were from people boiling rocks or pouring hydrogen peroxide on them. They are too pretty to not have in a tank
 
I disagree. I had palytoxin poisioning once and never again will I have any palys in my tank. I got “stung” while picking up a rock that had been in very close proximity to the paly. I don’t think my experience was due to my inexperience or negligence because I was neither. For me personally they are not worth the risk!
 
I agree with the phobia. I can't tell you how many zoas and palys I've handled, grew and fragged. Most of these occurrences with "poisonings" are guesses at best. In these cases were paly toxin was suspected I'd like to know how they tested the patient to come to a palytoxin diagnosis. Is the toxin real, yes. I still think its highly exaggerated. I always use caution and try to be a responsible reefkeeper and for many years myself and the family have been fine and enjoy looking at the many colonies of zoas and palys we've grown.
 
Perhaps some people are more sensitive to it than others - like Vibrio. Vibrio is very common and can be extremely serious to those with compromised immune systems. Most people that come into contact with it have no symptoms at all. I had a friend that had a live bait shrimp prick his finger while he was baiting a hook on a fishing trip. Within hours, he was in the ICU, infected with the very aggressive vibrio virus. The next day they were talking about amputating part of his arm. He did lose the infected finger. He was a type one diabetic. Some people have severe reactions to particular pharmaceuticals, while others do not. I think it maybe depends a lot on the individual.
 
Last edited:
joshporksandwich is the jedi knight of Zoas and he's alive and well........I think. LOL! Google him.... and have a look at his Zoas.
 
Andrew Sizemore started this thread with a question because he was concerned about "zoanthids" that he bought. Andrew, if you are still following, please post photos of the zoanthids. I'd like to see them. If they are zoanthids (Zoanthus spp.) you really have nothing to worry about. It's really Palythoa spp. (which are correctly called zoantharians, not zoanthids) that you need to handle with care. The short answer to your question is yes, palytoxin can be released into the air by the foaming of a protein skimmer. You'd need a pretty good sized colony to be a concern, though--- a frag plug of a few polyps is NOT going to be an issue with this route of palytoxin exposure. As someone mentioned earlier in the thread, use of activated carbon removes palytoxin from the water, and that would greatly reduce any risk of a skimmer releasing toxin into the air.

As is the case with these threads about palytoxin, there's always the ill-informed "bravados" who will tell you that you have nothing to worry about. I understand their point of view, believe me, since I too have handled plenty of Palythoa, collected it (various species) in the wild with bare hands on many occasions. Never had any problem whatsoever until, BAM an aquarium colony, a relatively small one at that, knocked me on my butt. And I had not done any of the stupid things with it... I had simply moved the colony. Watch that video shown earlier in the thread for the full story. The explanation for why Palythoa is sometimes so toxic, but other times not, is that Palythoa is SOMETIMES extremely toxic, period. The palytoxin is produced by microbes that live on the Palythoa, and nobody knows why they sometimes produce more palytoxin. It is not something about certain people being more sensitive.

Vins Reef-- yes those are Palythoa and yes they would release lots of toxin if you were to try to annihilate them. If you want to end up another example of poisoning in the news, very ill, go ahead and try repeating the same experiment to see whether you get a different result. If you seriously want to eliminate the Palythoa from your tank, consider putting a sundial snail (Heliacus) in there... Palythoa is their favorite food.
 
I mentioned this on R2R before. Bought some old rocks from someone quitting the hobby. Hosed them off in a bucket with a fine spay. Breathed in enough spay so pulse went to over 180 and over 190 by time I got to the emergency room. Close call, could have caused a heart attack. So in addition to gloves, washing afterwords, being careful of cuts, don't breathe in spray from washing rocks which have been in a tank. Like many others, I handle Zoas, frag them, move them around, regularly scrap and cut at glove polyps trying to rid my tank of them and have never had a problem except the one time I accidentally set up the perfect aerosol disbursement system and breathed in the spray for about 3 minutes.
 
I have handled them frequently in the past. Lately I have noticed a bit of nausea and headache after messing with any of my corals. Maybe I'm just more aware of it now? Maybe there is something to it? I don't know. Maybe I've developed a sensitivity? I think awareness is reasonable precaution. But that's just my thought
 
Mr. Sprung let's be clear. None of us "cowboys" as you so put it is telling anyone that the toxin is not something real, or made up, at least I don't believe that's what we are trying to convey. Palytoxin is very very real. I'm in the medical field, so I know that it indeed is a true and real toxin that exist. Being on an ambulance for 21 years, I'm exposed to all sorts of infectious diseases.... HIV, HEP C, TB, and many types of infectious airborne and blood bourne diseases. To this day and after 21 years coming into contact with God knows what....... I have never had an exposure to an infectious disease......... why?........."common sense" and protecting myself with proper PPE (Personal Protective Equipment)

We are trying to convey that there is no need to "not have them, or not put them in your tank, or remove them now that you've learned about their toxic makeup. We are simply saying that with proper care, the OP has nothing to worry about. No different then if you own a Pit Bull..... sure we all hear how they are prone to bite and have an aggressive nature, but I have met many Pit Bulls who are very mild mannered dogs. I was bit once by a dog......care to guess what type?.......... a Cocker Spaniel. I had a Lionfish years ago...... never was stung...... ever. Owning a firearm is another example...... it's all about responsibility and most importantly "good ol common sense" These are beautiful creatures to be enjoyed, not feared. Just my 2 cents.
 
I bought rocks from someone on Facebook I came home rinsed them off outside with a garden hose was unaware the zoas were not dead. I put the rocks in my tank cut my hand on the rock. Next morning I woke up and my dog was dead. Took the dog to the vet rubbed my eye thinking just allergies. Ended up in the er the palytoxin got into my eye from the open wound. I ended up blind in my right eye spent a week in icu. Ended up having to have a cornea transplant because the toxin had melted the cornea and perforated and leaked fluid out of my eye. I had my skimmer on just like I always do and wasn't aware what was happening till the next morning when the skimmer was overflowing. It took doctors 4 days to determine it was palytoxin. I can tell you first hand it can go airborne. If people wanna debate it I'll gladly accept. My daughter had breathed the toxin in from the air and the dog either licked some of the water that dropped off the rocks or when was airborne.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top