Pigment shift, corals going from yellow to greenish

Charterreefer

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Mar 25, 2016
Messages
337
Reaction score
202
Location
Central NJ
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Hi Dana, Welcome to R2R. I love your articles. I switched from 400 Watt MH to 250 watters after reading an article of yours last year. I'm getting much better coloration in my sps tank as a result...not to mention the electric bill is a bit lower.

I'm having an issue with some of the coral in my tank getting green hue to them. The corals affected are: a wolverine, pikachu and a pink floyd. These coral are normally a school bus yellow/banana color. Additionally, I have a yellow microclados that has also gotten very green. In contrast, I have a pink lemonade that continues to be as yellow as can be.
About my tank: 250 gallon DD. I have very low nutrients my NO3 is 1-2 ppm and my PO4 level is very low too, I had a Triton water test done recently and they said to feed the fish more more because the phosphates were so low. I don't normally use any gfo either just 10% water changes religiously and keep a low fish load. I have 5 MP40's providing lots of water flow.
My lighting: I had 4 ATI 80 watt actinics with 250 watt Radium MH bulbs running for several months prior. I just swapped out 2 of the ATI T5 actinics with a "coral blue special" and a "Blue plus" bulbs both of these bulbs are in the 15,000K range. This is in hopes of thinking that the actinics were exciting the green pigments in the affected corals.
Should I swap out the other actinics for warmer spectrum bulbs? Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated.
 
I used to have a similar issue that no matter what sps I put in my tank most would slowly turn Green but my floyd stayed yellow. I also have almost undetectable nutrients so I started feeding amino nightly and after 2 weeks corals that had been Green for over a year changed one even turned purple again. I also take my skimmer offline for a few hrs a day and I'm in the process of adding more fish
 
I used to have a similar issue that no matter what sps I put in my tank most would slowly turn Green but my floyd stayed yellow. I also have almost undetectable nutrients so I started feeding amino nightly and after 2 weeks corals that had been Green for over a year changed one even turned purple again. I also take my skimmer offline for a few hrs a day and I'm in the process of adding more fish

Thanks for your input. That sounds like it could be the solution for my tank. I cracked open a new bottle of "fuel" and put some in. I stopped using amino acids when I had a cyano outbreak quite a while ago...the yellow corals were still yellow then, no green hue. I will let you know how it goes. What amino acid brand do you use?
 
I use reef energy from red sea it's a 2 part and I've gotten better results than I did with fuel.
 
Hi Dana, Welcome to R2R. I love your articles. I switched from 400 Watt MH to 250 watters after reading an article of yours last year. I'm getting much better coloration in my sps tank as a result...not to mention the electric bill is a bit lower.

I'm having an issue with some of the coral in my tank getting green hue to them. The corals affected are: a wolverine, pikachu and a pink floyd. These coral are normally a school bus yellow/banana color. Additionally, I have a yellow microclados that has also gotten very green. In contrast, I have a pink lemonade that continues to be as yellow as can be.
About my tank: 250 gallon DD. I have very low nutrients my NO3 is 1-2 ppm and my PO4 level is very low too, I had a Triton water test done recently and they said to feed the fish more more because the phosphates were so low. I don't normally use any gfo either just 10% water changes religiously and keep a low fish load. I have 5 MP40's providing lots of water flow.
My lighting: I had 4 ATI 80 watt actinics with 250 watt Radium MH bulbs running for several months prior. I just swapped out 2 of the ATI T5 actinics with a "coral blue special" and a "Blue plus" bulbs both of these bulbs are in the 15,000K range. This is in hopes of thinking that the actinics were exciting the green pigments in the affected corals.
Should I swap out the other actinics for warmer spectrum bulbs? Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated.
Very good question! And please bear with me as I sort out the ins-and-outs of responding to forum threads. Yellow fluorescence in corals is usually due to color-mixing of two fluorescent colors - red and green. If red fluorescent proteins increase, the color becomes orange. If red decreases, green becomes apparent. There are a staggering number of things that can affect this coloration. To help understand this, let's look at the anatomy of a fluorescent protein. Central to our interest is the fluorescent part of the protein - the fluorophore. It is protected by ribbons of proteins wrapped in a spiral manner. This is called the beta-can. The fluorophore is held in place by weak electrical forces. If something (and there are many, including some metals, water (!), etc.) 'cracks' the beta-can, the forces holding the fluorophore in place are distorted. This could result in increased fluorescence - or no fluorescence at all. The truth is that we don't know what might cause these shifts. It is possible that it could be an increase of the metal nickel due to deterioration of a poor quality stainless steel pump shaft or something equally obscure. This is a subject I'd love to hear about from fellow hobbyists. I intent to look at coloration issues once the new lab is up and running (hopefully in a couple of months.) So, thanks for your intriguing question. Let's hear from others and we can all learn!
 
Hi Dana, Welcome to R2R. I love your articles. I switched from 400 Watt MH to 250 watters after reading an article of yours last year. I'm getting much better coloration in my sps tank as a result...not to mention the electric bill is a bit lower.

I'm having an issue with some of the coral in my tank getting green hue to them. The corals affected are: a wolverine, pikachu and a pink floyd. These coral are normally a school bus yellow/banana color. Additionally, I have a yellow microclados that has also gotten very green. In contrast, I have a pink lemonade that continues to be as yellow as can be.
About my tank: 250 gallon DD. I have very low nutrients my NO3 is 1-2 ppm and my PO4 level is very low too, I had a Triton water test done recently and they said to feed the fish more more because the phosphates were so low. I don't normally use any gfo either just 10% water changes religiously and keep a low fish load. I have 5 MP40's providing lots of water flow.
My lighting: I had 4 ATI 80 watt actinics with 250 watt Radium MH bulbs running for several months prior. I just swapped out 2 of the ATI T5 actinics with a "coral blue special" and a "Blue plus" bulbs both of these bulbs are in the 15,000K range. This is in hopes of thinking that the actinics were exciting the green pigments in the affected corals.
Should I swap out the other actinics for warmer spectrum bulbs? Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated.

gfp.jpg
 
The above shows the general shape of a fluorescent protein. The small green tree-like structure within the protein barrel is the fluorophore - the part that fluoresces (glows) under proper illumination. To answer your question further, there is no phosphorus in the protein, and it is not created by zooxanthellae but by the coral animal instead. Blue light is known to induce coloration, so a seat-of-the-pants suggestion would suggest your lighting is probably OK.
 
Thank you for your extensive reply. I greatly appreciate it! I'm glad we have someone onboard such as yourself well versed in scientific observation. There is way too much misleading anecdotal information floating around out there.
I'd like to add that I am excited about the Triton water testing that is starting to gain momentum amongst reefkeepers. Hopefully it will provide us all with real data that can help us determine what is actually going on in our reef tanks...cause and effect.
I look forward to all the new data that will be coming out of your new lab!
 
The above shows the general shape of a fluorescent protein. The small green tree-like structure within the protein barrel is the fluorophore - the part that fluoresces (glows) under proper illumination. To answer your question further, there is no phosphorus in the protein, and it is not created by zooxanthellae but by the coral animal instead. Blue light is known to induce coloration, so a seat-of-the-pants suggestion would suggest your lighting is probably OK.
If there were too much light, would the xanthophylls number not increase? (Spell check hates that word btw) , or do they not have a pigmentation that's noticeable. How does that mechanism work. The easy ansewer is fine, or link to an article.

I had assumed that overdose of a specific wavlength would produce an abundance of a specific pigment. (Green) in this case or of those with lower light requirements , but it sounds like it's possible this overdose could be what is cracking the "beta can"

In my cases of coral geeening , it appeared that simply lowering intensity and/ or duration solved these issues.
The first time I saw evidence of greening was in fact one Side of an acro that only received blue light from my led at the time.

I have two tanks currently and have been moving frags between the two just to see the differences.

I also noticed I had apparently just turned a ricordia green today. :confused:
 
In Sweden we often say that green color (color not fluorescence) depends on too much iron. We have a few reefers here that got better yellow from stepping down the adding of trace elements or stopped adding iron as a supplement.
I see two possible methods.

1. Stop adding trace elements for a week and see if anything changes. Take photos preferably with a DSLR with in manual mode and don´t change anything in the camera.

2. Add a detoxing agent like Tritons detox or something similar that will bind metals. If you use 2 part method with trace elements in the solutions it will come new trace elements with every dose so you dont risk to eliminate all trace elements.
 
If there were too much light, would the xanthophylls number not increase? (Spell check hates that word btw) , or do they not have a pigmentation that's noticeable. How does that mechanism work. The easy ansewer is fine, or link to an article.

I had assumed that overdose of a specific wavlength would produce an abundance of a specific pigment. (Green) in this case or of those with lower light requirements , but it sounds like it's possible this overdose could be what is cracking the "beta can"

In my cases of coral geeening , it appeared that simply lowering intensity and/ or duration solved these issues.
The first time I saw evidence of greening was in fact one Side of an acro that only received blue light from my led at the time.

I have two tanks currently and have been moving frags between the two just to see the differences.

I also noticed I had apparently just turned a ricordia green today. :confused:
Hi Jason. At one time, a prominent reef aquarium author attributed coral coloration to zooxanthellae photopigments (if red, it was due to peridinin and so on.) unfortunately, this info is still floating around on the internet. As I mentioned, xanthophylls are yellow in color (they absorb mostly blue light) but I have never seen a reference (out of hundreds in my library) that mentions xanthophylls influencing the apparent color of a coral (not saying it can't happen - it hasn't been described. Adding to the case against, xanthophylls are not water soluble while chromoproteins and fluorescent proteins are. This would be important to know when extracting pigments for analyses, and it hasn't happened in the few hundred I've done.) As mentioned, xanthophylls absorb blue light thus shunting energy away from photosynthesis. This energy changes DD to DT.
I should note there is a yellow fluorescent protein but it has been reported only in zoanthids, if memory serves me.
Further, there are at least two fluorescent proteins that mature - one from green to red, the other from red to green, with yellow and orange colors being apparent during transition due to color mixing. This is readily apparent in some of the Acropora milleporas. Keep us posted on your observations!
 
In Sweden we often say that green color (color not fluorescence) depends on too much iron. We have a few reefers here that got better yellow from stepping down the adding of trace elements or stopped adding iron as a supplement.
I see two possible methods.

1. Stop adding trace elements for a week and see if anything changes. Take photos preferably with a DSLR with in manual mode and don´t change anything in the camera.

2. Add a detoxing agent like Tritons detox or something similar that will bind metals. If you use 2 part method with trace elements in the solutions it will come new trace elements with every dose so you dont risk to eliminate all trace elements.
I had a triton test.my iron was normal. They said I had high chromium although, I can figure out what the source is. Does there metal detox take out chromium? I actually added nickel as per their suggestion.
I didn't understand your #2 reply about trace elements. I'm using Red Sea energy. It's a 2 part mix.
 
In Sweden we often say that green color (color not fluorescence) depends on too much iron. We have a few reefers here that got better yellow from stepping down the adding of trace elements or stopped adding iron as a supplement.
I see two possible methods.

1. Stop adding trace elements for a week and see if anything changes. Take photos preferably with a DSLR with in manual mode and don´t change anything in the camera.

2. Add a detoxing agent like Tritons detox or something similar that will bind metals. If you use 2 part method with trace elements in the solutions it will come new trace elements with every dose so you dont risk to eliminate all trace elements.
Thanks for the information. These sorts of observations fascinate me!
 
I had a triton test.my iron was normal. They said I had high chromium although, I can figure out what the source is. Does there metal detox take out chromium? I actually added nickel as per their suggestion.
I didn't understand your #2 reply about trace elements. I'm using Red Sea energy. It's a 2 part mix.
I'd like to hear their reasoning for the nickel addition!
 
Very good question! And please bear with me as I sort out the ins-and-outs of responding to forum threads. Yellow fluorescence in corals is usually due to color-mixing of two fluorescent colors - red and green. If red fluorescent proteins increase, the color becomes orange. If red decreases, green becomes apparent. There are a staggering number of things that can affect this coloration. To help understand this, let's look at the anatomy of a fluorescent protein. Central to our interest is the fluorescent part of the protein - the fluorophore. It is protected by ribbons of proteins wrapped in a spiral manner. This is called the beta-can. The fluorophore is held in place by weak electrical forces. If something (and there are many, including some metals, water (!), etc.) 'cracks' the beta-can, the forces holding the fluorophore in place are distorted. This could result in increased fluorescence - or no fluorescence at all. The truth is that we don't know what might cause these shifts. It is possible that it could be an increase of the metal nickel due to deterioration of a poor quality stainless steel pump shaft or something equally obscure. This is a subject I'd love to hear about from fellow hobbyists. I intent to look at coloration issues once the new lab is up and running (hopefully in a couple of months.) So, thanks for your intriguing question. Let's hear from others and we can all learn!
FYI Triton said my chromium level was high. They had me add Nickel to to my water (amongst other additives). That was two months ago. I will be sending in a new sample in one week to see how my levels are currently.
 
Thanks for the information. These sorts of observations fascinate me!
Hi
In Sweden we often say that green color (color not fluorescence) depends on too much iron. We have a few reefers here that got better yellow from stepping down the adding of trace elements or stopped adding iron as a supplement.
I see two possible methods.

1. Stop adding trace elements for a week and see if anything changes. Take photos preferably with a DSLR with in manual mode and don´t change anything in the camera.

2. Add a detoxing agent like Tritons detox or something similar that will bind metals. If you use 2 part method with trace elements in the solutions it will come new trace elements with every dose so you dont risk to eliminate all trace elements.
I reread your post and understand. Thanks!
 
Hi Jason. At one time, a prominent reef aquarium author attributed coral coloration to zooxanthellae photopigments (if red, it was due to peridinin and so on.) unfortunately, this info is still floating around on the internet. As I mentioned, xanthophylls are yellow in color (they absorb mostly blue light) but I have never seen a reference (out of hundreds in my library) that mentions xanthophylls influencing the apparent color of a coral (not saying it can't happen - it hasn't been described. Adding to the case against, xanthophylls are not water soluble while chromoproteins and fluorescent proteins are. This would be important to know when extracting pigments for analyses, and it hasn't happened in the few hundred I've done.) As mentioned, xanthophylls absorb blue light thus shunting energy away from photosynthesis. This energy changes DD to DT.
I should note there is a yellow fluorescent protein but it has been reported only in zoanthids, if memory serves me.
Further, there are at least two fluorescent proteins that mature - one from green to red, the other from red to green, with yellow and orange colors being apparent during transition due to color mixing. This is readily apparent in some of the Acropora milleporas. Keep us posted on your observations!
Thank you for the clarification.

If I understand you correctly then, you don't belive the greening is from too much light?
 
Further, there are at least two fluorescent proteins that mature - one from green to red, the other from red to green, with yellow and orange colors being apparent during transition due to color mixing. This is readily apparent in some of the Acropora milleporas. Keep us posted on your observations!

I have two Mussids (Micromussa lordhowensis and Blastomussa wellsi) that could be the poster children for the 'green to red with yellow/orange transition coloration'). When the new buds are under the main polyp (or in full shade) they are fluorescent green. But once they start to get a little bigger, and therefore receive a little light, the yellow/orange is very apparent. As they slowly get larger and receive more light, they shift rather quickly to the adult polyp coloration of reddish-orange. Facinating to watch these color changes develop over time.

A question that comes to mind is that once the coral develops the transition yellow/orange coloration in the young polyps, could lowering the light level (or moving the coral to a more shaded location), halt the final transition to reddish-orange indefinitely (assuming the coral stays in the lower lighting level)?

Ralph -
 
Last edited:

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top