Pigment shift, corals going from yellow to greenish

Nickel can influence the branching of corals so it could be a good idea to raise that level a bit.
But when CO2 scrubbers began being tested in Sweden a few reefers noted much more branching on some corals. So pH can be a factor too for branching.
Greening can in some corals depend on light to. The yellow Seriatopora hystrix is by me brown in really low light - green in somewhat stronger (around 70 PAR) and yellow in 200 PAR or more.
That is with zero phosphate (Hanna Checker Phospourus) and nitrate.
 
Fascinating - I love this sort of observation - thanks for sharing! Off the top of my head, one of these transitions is reversible, while the other is a done deal once the maturation process is complete. A Ds-Red protein is auto-catalytic and will do its thing without any external factors, assuming the host stays healthy. I'll have to look at my notes for the Mussid corals, but I think they're Clade D proteins.
Now to muddy the waters a little, I accidentally over-dosed a tank with kalkwasser years ago, and a green chalice coral turned orange overnight. It never regained the green fluorescence. It sure looks like the pH swing cracked the beta-can!
Thank you for the clarification.

If I understand you correctly then, you don't belive the greening is from too much light?
Depends. One researcher found green fluorescent proteins (GFP) in shallow to deep waters suggesting light had no influence. Later researcher found at least some green coloration is light related. Considering GFPs are by far the most common 'pigments' it would be wrong on my part to paint with a broad brush. See here: http://www.advancedaquarist.com/2009/2/aafeature1
 
Depends. One researcher found green fluorescent proteins (GFP) in shallow to deep waters suggesting light had no influence. Later researcher found at least some green coloration is light related. Considering GFPs are by far the most common 'pigments' it would be wrong on my part to paint with a broad brush. See here: http://www.advancedaquarist.co
Interesting.
Once the greening questions had been posed, I ran an extended photoperiod of high intensity in my smaller tank. Many of the acros did change color. Mainly a green, but some more an odd teal color. Once I stopped the photoperid experiment all of the acros recovered their original colors.

Additionally, these are the same coral, different tanks, different light fixture and par.
IMG_1915.JPG


IMG_1916.JPG

These Ricordia are in the same tank as the first coral sample. One is shaded.
IMG_1945.JPG
 
Fascinating - I love this sort of observation - thanks for sharing! Off the top of my head, one of these transitions is reversible, while the other is a done deal once the maturation process is complete. A Ds-Red protein is auto-catalytic and will do its thing without any external factors, assuming the host stays healthy. I'll have to look at my notes for the Mussid corals, but I think they're Clade D proteins.
Now to muddy the waters a little, I accidentally over-dosed a tank with kalkwasser years ago, and a green chalice coral turned orange overnight. It never regained the green fluorescence. It sure looks like the pH swing cracked the beta-can!

One last comment of interest as I'm getting off-topic a little, but if I temporarily raise the Reddish-orange Blasto up to the top of the aquariuam (~400 PAR), the bright yellow-orange coloration becomes very apparent in the mature polyp. Facinating...
 
over-dosed a tank with kalkwasser years ago, and a green chalice coral turned orange overnight. It never regained the green fluorescence.

Interesting – I've seen green algae do that, but I think it was related to die-off. It ended up fluorescent orange. Still maybe the same protein degrading? Similar effect to Fall leaves in trees where a covering pigment degrades to show the "true color"?
 
Nickel can influence the branching of corals so it could be a good idea to raise that level a bit.
But when CO2 scrubbers began being tested in Sweden a few reefers noted much more branching on some corals. So pH can be a factor too for branching.

AFAIhave read, branching is a response to light and water flow conditions, not elemental conditions of the water per se.

However I can imagine that relatively better or worse elemental conditions could change the ratio of turbulence:flow they'd want around them. I don't know how Ni would figure in to that, but pH is obvious.

Does the observation on Ni and pH being associated with the nature of branching come from a journal you can link perhaps or home observation? I'd definitely like to read more if there's anything available. :)

What are the exact outcomes you've seen for Ni and pH? Does higher = more branching or less? thicker or thinner? What aspects changed?

Thanks for any feedback – you can PM me if it doesn't fit the conversation here. :)
 
About Nickel have i read in Koralle N.r 65 page 36. The article is from H. W. Balling.
It is a German magazine but it is possible that the article also is in the American version of the paper - Coral Magazine.
 
Interesting. Nickel is found in most coral skeletons at low concentrations (<5 mg/kg, or ppm, if you will.) How that could influence skeletal morphology is a mystery to me. Normally, high metal concentrations would be a result of the coral living in areas subject to terrestrial run-off. We could expect the water to be turbid and, hence, the coral growth would become flattened in order to capture light. But then, the ocean isn't an aquarium. Thoughts?
 
I started a thread half a year ago asking for thoughts about coral calcification. https://www.reef2reef.com/threads/coral-calcification.275803/
It quickly died so i guess there is not much knowledge of the basics in calcification. But somehow - in the DNA of the corals there is information of how to build the skeleton.
And i guess thats where the trace elements come in. Not in the DNA of course but somewhere between it and how the calcification forms.
We dont even know if the deposit of trace elements in the coral skeleton is a way for the animal to get rid of elements it has too much of or if it has a function for the skeleton itself.
Or if it is just a leak of the elements from the coral animal through the calcification layer because the processes invalved are not perfect. It could be that the trace elements found in coral skeletons are deposited directly from the surronding water? Four theories. Maybe they are all correct but one of them will be the main function i guess. And it can be different for different trace elements.
So the scientists still have something to do.
This is a bit of what i dont know but maybe there is someone here knowing more?
 
Many of the elements (such as strontium) found in coral skeletons are a 'mistake' - their size and charge are similar to that of calcium. I would expect light and water motion to have profound effects on skeletal morphology, but how metals would affect it? I'll research this as soon as I can get a chance (hopefully this afternoon.)
 
Following this thread!
I found it by searching for topics about yellow in acans, as I have one that started as a bright yellow at the lfs and changed it orange and red within a few days, and stayed orange in my tank. I would love to learn how to get that yellow coloration back. This thread seems like it's a little off topic from what I was looking for but it is very interesting and good reading!
 
I searched my database for scientific journal references to coloration in Acans, but found none, so my comments are seat-of-the-pants. It does sound like your observation is of a maturation of a green pigment to a red one, with the intermediate being an apparent yellow color. I'll get some Acans and take a close look once the lab is functional again.
 
Following this thread!
I found it by searching for topics about yellow in acans, as I have one that started as a bright yellow at the lfs and changed it orange and red within a few days, and stayed orange in my tank. I would love to learn how to get that yellow coloration back. This thread seems like it's a little off topic from what I was looking for but it is very interesting and good reading!

This is a common occurance with these Mussids (Acans, Blastos) when LED lighting is used and I see the same thing. Suggested causes I've seen are 'too much 'blue' in the spectrum' and/or too much light intensity. I do notice that my rainbow acan's new polyps (that form under the main poly) appear yellow with a touch of green until they grow large enough to receive direct lighting and ~ 150 PAR...and they then turn orange-red. Similar occurance with my Blasto, too, although the young polyps go from predominently green to orange-red when large enough to be in the light (~80 - 100 PAR).

What type of lighting were they under at the LFS? (Metal Halide, T5, LED?). Were they in direct light, indirect, partial shade?
 
This is a common occurance with these Mussids (Acans, Blastos) when LED lighting is used and I see the same thing. Suggested causes I've seen are 'too much 'blue' in the spectrum' and/or too much light intensity. I do notice that my rainbow acan's new polyps (that form under the main poly) appear yellow with a touch of green until they grow large enough to receive direct lighting and ~ 150 PAR...and they then turn orange-red. Similar occurance with my Blasto, too, although the young polyps go from predominently green to orange-red when large enough to be in the light (~80 - 100 PAR).

What type of lighting were they under at the LFS? (Metal Halide, T5, LED?). Were they in direct light, indirect, partial shade?
LEDs at the lfs and home, direct light. They were only at the lfs for 2-3 days, the color change was very fast. Do you think if I put them back in a shaded area they might regain yellow or the new growth might be more yellow?
 
Okay maybe the color change gets wasn't quite as rapid as I initially thought. So sorry for the sideways pictures.

January 31st at lfs
3fe35379ca5e3e3b25682bf3d5fd0815.jpg

9c2ccf9bdc4d255ccabf120445f005e4.jpg


Feb 2nd at home
608f697e78009d15bf5ce7851c8a87d1.jpg

e3255284dfca6149f5e4f0f54b18a3a7.jpg


Feb 3rd
86829605d1c5a7c05cb3fedecd848db2.jpg


Feb 19
9080c826a9524fb2f939c6fedf1e95a8.jpg


March 9
dcac1b112debc25bc23fbad2915f3428.jpg


March 31
247dd7db0f9373510acd5ea91213b06e.jpg


May 21
5c6f2e2c99eb3c5b8fac6a57204ea998.jpg


July 9
2964e85313abd6a69c7b2f0eb6ca6bf3.jpg
 
LEDs at the lfs and home, direct light. They were only at the lfs for 2-3 days, the color change was very fast. Do you think if I put them back in a shaded area they might regain yellow or the new growth might be more yellow?

Lower light location *might* do the trick, but what I don't know is if the color change to orange-red is of a permanent type. If you see any new polyps that are yellow-ish, it would be interesting to frag them before the change to orange-red and place them under lower lighting.

My parent Acan polyp and the new ones budding off the bottom (sorry for the blurry image, but they are buried a bit in my rockwork):

LKz53QW.jpg


The yellow is starting to be replaced by the green as they receive more light. I can also see some orange developing...
 
Last edited:

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top