Pink fish for ten gallon and 20 gallon

Good luck with your tank, leaving via gif.
bfba72c3577cb95a1cfacc373cf54bef.jpg
 
Good luck with your tank, leaving via gif.
bfba72c3577cb95a1cfacc373cf54bef.jpg
I got too much luck already with this tank. Had a chalice stung the crap out of a whole bunch of my BC sps. Everything's surprisingly fine however. Had this ol' tank for 8 years, just new location and fish selection.
 
I never wanted a six line. As I have said, I'm bored with them. But if there's no suggestions, then I'm gonna go with what's pink and good looking. Which happens to be a six line wrasse.

Let's be honest, all of the suggestions I got were bland fish (besides the trimma goby, but unfortunately my store will never get them) compared to the six line wrasse. Made me really want a flasher wrasse real bad. However, I was appalled about the anecdotal claims of this fish. I don't even know if we're talking about the same species anymore. You literally said six lines are not pink. WHAT?!

Six lines are pink. They just also have a mixture of other colors such as blue and orange stripes, but their base color is pink. It is pretty obvious in fact. Literally just google an image, watch a video, or find someone who has one and there you go, pink. And it's not "cooked salmon" pink.

The point of this was for me to NOT get a six line, however, I'm not getting one anymore. My friend had a candy basslet that she surprised me for my birthday. Her father didn't want it cuz it hid too much and he was breaking down all of his tanks for just a massive one. So six line is no more, I'm getting a candy basslet.

So all of this, just for nothing really. Apparently the ocean isn't as vast as I thought it was. Or at least the market.

This should have never escalated this far, and it was my fault. I don't know why I got so worked up in the first place, but I guess they hold a special place in my heart since they're the only fish that I have kept in every single tank I had. Then again, the claims made were just down right false ime. The stigma is so negative. You guys are scaring people away from these beautiful fish just based on rare occurrences and the possible lack of knowledge for this fish. But who knows, maybe I was extremely lucky. Or maybe you guys misunderstand this species. But it's over. I got my fish, let's move on now. If the consensus says they're aggressive, so be it.

I just don't like it when false facts are made publicly to influence someone, that's all. I just saw it that way.

I actually have a sixline, unfortunately. At best, sixlines have a pink stomach, maybe. Green tail, orange stripes over blue body but ok. You insisted on pink, cant get much more pink than strawberry gramma but you acted like that suggestion was for a black and white fish.

And then suggest to someone who has cared for thousands of sixline that they must not have fed enough at each of the 5x a day feedings?? Gimme a break.
 
Last edited:
I actually have a sixline, unfortunately. At best, sixlines have a pink stomach, maybe. Green tail, orange stripes over blue body but ok. You insisted on pink, cant get much more pink than strawberry gramma but you acted like that suggestion was for a black and white fish.

And then suggest to someone who has cared for thousands of sixline that they must not have fed enough at each of the 5x a day feedings?? Gimme a break.
I asked for a pink fish with patterns. I explained it earlier. If I could have a flasher wrasse, which are mostly pink, I would. Just too active for my tank. Strawberry gramma has no patterns, and it colors aren't even vibrant. I might as well go with an orchid dottyback if I'm getting a fish that's pink throughout.

I highly doubt he cared for 1000's of six lines if he speaks so badly about it. Why the hell would you do that if you hated it so much. He may have seen them under care, but he probably kept less than 5 in his life. But keeping them and watching them are two very different perspectives.

Again, the six line may not get enough per feeding. It's like a dragonet, you must absolutely make sure his belly is big and full after every feeding cuz both metabolism is pretty high. Six lines just tolerate starvation better than dragonets, which is why people assume they are well fed. Broadcast feeding will not cut it. I feed my fish 3-4 times a day (mostly 4 to make sure my dragonets are full), making sure he eats til he is stuffed. I found that they "apparently" behave well when full and happy.

I already got my fish. I'm not even getting a six line. Quit instigating. I've already stated my case on why I felt this way. If I hurt your feelings earlier, I am truly sorry.
 
I asked for a pink fish with patterns. I explained it earlier. If I could have a flasher wrasse, which are mostly pink, I would. Just too active for my tank. Strawberry gramma has no patterns, and it colors aren't even vibrant. I might as well go with an orchid dottyback if I'm getting a fish that's pink throughout.

I highly doubt he cared for 1000's of six lines if he speaks so badly about it. Why the hell would you do that if you hated it so much. He may have seen them under care, but he probably kept less than 5 in his life. But keeping them and watching them are two very different perspectives.

Again, the six line may not get enough per feeding. It's like a dragonet, you must absolutely make sure his belly is big and full after every feeding cuz both metabolism is pretty high. Six lines just tolerate starvation better than dragonets, which is why people assume they are well fed. Broadcast feeding will not cut it. I feed my fish 3-4 times a day (mostly 4 to make sure my dragonets are full), making sure he eats til he is stuffed. I found that they "apparently" behave well when full and happy.

I already got my fish. I'm not even getting a six line. Quit instigating. I've already stated my case on why I felt this way. If I hurt your feelings earlier, I am truly sorry.
Getting a little aggressive here... check your self before you shrek your self
 
Getting a little aggressive here... check your self before you shrek your self
I have explained I am a bit passive aggressive, but I don't see any aggressiveness there? Am I not allow to reason? I haven't said anything mean really. I'm guessing I really underestimate what "aggressive behavior" is. But whatever, got a fish.
 
I know.

Well I'm done debating about this apparent six line aggressiveness now. Everyone is entitled to their own opinion. I'll just stick to facts. Hopefully a marine biologist will solve this mystery.

However, for those who are reading this and just deciding to whether or not you should get a six line, just get one. Make sure you feed it well, or else it won't be happy.
 
I have explained I am a bit passive aggressive, but I don't see any aggressiveness there? Am I not allow to reason? I haven't said anything mean really. I'm guessing I really underestimate what "aggressive behavior" is. But whatever, got a fish.

I'd describe your aggression level as more than passive. Sixline wrasse levels of aggression IMO

also, have you ever been tested for colorblindness? orchid dottybacks be purple brosef
 
I'd describe your aggression level as more than passive. Sixline wrasse levels of aggression IMO

also, have you ever been tested for colorblindness? orchid dottybacks be purple brosef
Haven't heard the word brosef used in years haha!
 
To anyone reading this I would recommend against a sixline wrasse. I know the op has already decided, so that statement is not addressed to him. There is no fish I have had to remove from systems more than sixlines.

I have worked with an LFS and serviced tanks for over the last 10yrs. I take care of more than 20 different tanks a week. And while keeping them and watching them are two different things, they aren't mutually exclusive either.

Working with a store, I have had many sixlines cross my path. They are an excellent pest eater and is a good choice for small frag tanks without tankmates. But through my own experiences, and talking to customers that decide to get one for a community tank, despite my advice, the reality that most become a problem is apparent.

They are also a species I have personally kept early in my saltwater days, before I knew what the demeanor was, and even then gave the first few specimens the benefit of the doubt as a bad apple rather than viewing the whole species like that. However, experience with a preponderance of individuals taught me otherwise.

If you look at my post history you will see that anytime I give advise on aggression I mention feeding more to reduce it. I give advise on keeping challenging species and common species, and my advice is based on experience.

To "highly doubt" a statement I have made comes across as calling me a liar. Saying that you are passive aggressive, and haven't said anything mean is false and also no excuse. To state your experience is one thing, but you don't get to only "count" your experience, other people's experiences count too.
 
I'd describe your aggression level as more than passive. Sixline wrasse levels of aggression IMO

also, have you ever been tested for colorblindness? orchid dottybacks be purple brosef
I know, it's more magenta if anything, but still a lot better looking than the strawberry gramma.
 
To anyone reading this I would recommend against a sixline wrasse. I know the op has already decided, so that statement is not addressed to him. There is no fish I have had to remove from systems more than sixlines.

I have worked with an LFS and serviced tanks for over the last 10yrs. I take care of more than 20 different tanks a week. And while keeping them and watching them are two different things, they aren't mutually exclusive either.

Working with a store, I have had many sixlines cross my path. They are an excellent pest eater and is a good choice for small frag tanks without tankmates. But through my own experiences, and talking to customers that decide to get one for a community tank, despite my advice, the reality that most become a problem is apparent.

They are also a species I have personally kept early in my saltwater days, before I knew what the demeanor was, and even then gave the first few specimens the benefit of the doubt as a bad apple rather than viewing the whole species like that. However, experience with a preponderance of individuals taught me otherwise.

If you look at my post history you will see that anytime I give advise on aggression I mention feeding more to reduce it. I give advise on keeping challenging species and common species, and my advice is based on experience.

To "highly doubt" a statement I have made comes across as calling me a liar. Saying that you are passive aggressive, and haven't said anything mean is false and also no excuse. To state your experience is one thing, but you don't get to only "count" your experience, other people's experiences count too.
By "highly doubt", I didn't mean to call you a liar. You did not state how many six lines you have kept personally, so assuming your hatred towards them, I was assuming you had bad experience with no more than 5 personally.

Even tho I have worked in lfs less years and serviced less tanks, it still a decent chunk of experience, 5 years+. And I can tell you, the knowledge of reefkeeping has changed tremendously over the years. You know back then acros and anemones were impossible to keep, now they're easy peasy lemon squeezy. Why? Because we got more information about them. It's just that it's hard to tell the actual need of something when they don't show it by dying. Which is why I thought the six line was heavily misunderstood. But looking at the consensus in this thread, I gotta say, I'm shocked. I didn't know they were this aggressive until now, after 50+ tanks I have seen with six line, even after a decade keeping tens of them. The most aggressiveness I have seen is chasing damsels out of it's territory. Other than, never I had heard other claims. I would say dottybacks or dwarf angels are a lot nastier if anything.

This info on six line was relatively new to me, I didn't even know we were talking about the right fish. I thought these were just rare occurrences and anecdotal claims because I have never heard anything prior to this. Apparently, everyone in this thread agrees that it is aggressive. I just didn't know that before. Again, I was appalled. I just thought you guys were against me making my own suggestion. I was quite combative, but that's because the suggestions made were pretty bland compared to the six line and I'm quite picky since this is the last fish. You have to agree, if the six line wasn't as aggressive as it is, you would probably say that the six line is the most vibrant pink fish out of all of the suggestions here.

Well, it's been decided I guess. You learn something new everyday.
 
I have a 6 line in a 55g. He is a model citizen. His tankmates include a female maroon clown, a bangaii cardinalfish, and pajama cardinalfish, and scooter dragonet. They all have lived with each other for 2 years now. They get fed 4 times a week. Everyone is happy, no agression other than sometimes the maroon to one of the cardinals.
 
Well, kinda too late for that. In a decade of keeping them, 2 out of 25 I keep are sort of jerks, but not "thalassoma" bullying (now that's a different story), just a bit of chasing. The others I have yet to see aggressive behavior. They are at most semi-aggressive.
Either you guys are pansies and misunderstand what aggressive behavior really is, or you guys misunderstand what a six-line needs.
And don't get it twisted and say I'm the one misunderstanding, I'm the one having success with them.
Unless there is a pink fish that can meet my expectations, I'm going with the six line. I'm quarantining at the store that I work at, so it's not really too late for more suggestions.
But with the suggestions that are given, at this point I'm asking for too much. But since I see keeping a six line as a tradition, unless candy basslets are only $100 or a trimma caudomaculatum is available, it will be VERY hard to convince me.
My six line was the very first fish I bought. He’s been moved to three different tanks and survived a velvet outbreak that killed everything else. He passes my little bumblebee shrimp and pays them no attention. He is an absolute model citizen. I purchase tisbe pods for him often. It keeps him busy. He’s NEVER been aggressive towards anything. I’ve had him for nearly two years. The most misunderstood fish out there!
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top