should I reuse my mature live rock?

imustbenuts

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Oct 22, 2013
Messages
462
Reaction score
244
Location
San Diego
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I wanted to get an idea what others would do. I have to move my 65g tank to a new stand. I've had my rock for 11 years. The main issues with the current rock are mega hydroids and aptasia. I have maintained the aptasia with Breghia Nudibranch. Once a year I have to buy about 5 and they mow it down really well. The hydroids are not that simple. So would you start over with new base rock, keep the old rock or kill and clean the old rock to reuse? What say you?
image.jpg
image.jpg
image.jpg
 
I would ditch your rock and get some clean Live Rock from an established tank with less pests. You are already at a disadvantage with that rock.

The established rock is good to seed your new rock.
 
I would kill it all, but re-cure any pieces that are awesome shaped and throw the rest out
Rock of that perfect size, shape, structure is worth curing over - the stuff that is just round or dense or otherwise undesirable isn't worth the trouble
You can frag and save many of those zoas and shrooms on clean plugs should you want to
 
I would kill it all, but re-cure any pieces that are awesome shaped and throw the rest out
Rock of that perfect size, shape, structure is worth curing over - the stuff that is just round or dense or otherwise undesirable isn't worth the trouble
You can frag and save many of those zoas and shrooms on clean plugs should you want to
What would your process be to kill it?
 
kill the hydroids keep the rock, im actively doing it in my tank as we speak i can get some pix later.

high percentage peroxide, not pharmacy water but health food lab grade kills them and not the filter bacteria or anything else.

Not dosed in tank but removed target runs, lift out

retreatments are based on permeation and a few rounds are needed. the reason i mention such a dangerous chemical is because my child could buy it over the counter at a healthfood store, so not mentioning it doesnt take that fact away, its avail, and quite useful, and you should wear eye protection and gloves and treat it like you are handling battery acid lol. it is easy to control, i use it frequently~

I think you shouldnt kill the rock even if you can't beat them all, those are just part of the normal benthics that various fishes and crabs would be picking at from time to time, we are only trained they are bad. they aren't harming or stinging anything in my tank/ they are harmful to baby zosterae seahorses so unless they are a goal id keep that pristine rock regardless.

only massive algae issues would make me think different, old rock has character. hydroids can easily be re imported so i dont like bleaching and losing all that color without trying a live time save.

if you can lift out that rock and spot apply, they die, nothing else does, im doing this in a ten year old one gallon reef packed w life, w 35% peroxide causing no harm.
 
Last edited:
Any rocks worth their salt with a cool shape or size that you want, I would let dry in the sun for a few days, give a vinegar bath and then cure using normal curing methods
Getting new, favorable life is easy, getting rid of pests is extremely difficult

I would not put a rock with aptasia on it in my tank, ever for any reason....

Kill it! Period end of sentence!
 
I do like that option I remember reading about it working on other threads. Wonder if that is a pod zapper too, how targeting was fen
 
No no no.. fenbenz will take care of the issue..
pm me

Never heard of fenbenz.

kill the hydroids keep the rock, im actively doing it in my tank as we speak i can get some pix later.

high percentage peroxide, not pharmacy water but health food lab grade kills them and not the filter bacteria or anything else.

Not dosed in tank but removed target runs, lift out

retreatments are based on permeation and a few rounds are needed. the reason i mention such a dangerous chemical is because my child could buy it over the counter at a healthfood store, so not mentioning it doesnt take that fact away, its avail, and quite useful, and you should wear eye protection and gloves and treat it like you are handling battery acid lol. it is easy to control, i use it frequently~

I think you shouldnt kill the rock even if you can't beat them all, those are just part of the normal benthics that various fishes and crabs would be picking at from time to time, we are only trained they are bad. they aren't harming or stinging anything in my tank/ they are harmful to baby zosterae seahorses so unless they are a goal id keep that pristine rock regardless.

only massive algae issues would make me think different, old rock has character. hydroids can easily be re imported so i dont like bleaching and losing all that color without trying a live time save.

if you can lift out that rock and spot apply, they die, nothing else does, im doing this in a ten year old one gallon reef packed w life, w 35% peroxide causing no harm.
How do you know the peroxide isn't killing beneficial bac?

Any rocks worth their salt with a cool shape or size that you want, I would let dry in the sun for a few days, give a vinegar bath and then cure using normal curing methods
Getting new, favorable life is easy, getting rid of pests is extremely difficult

I would not put a rock with aptasia on it in my tank, ever for any reason....

Kill it! Period end of sentence!
Thanks for your 2c
 
Brandon knows his stuff with peroxide. I personally have not done testing with this method but it is promising
I am currently doing testing with peroxide on flatworm and so far results are surprising !
 
upload_2015-8-7_14-48-10.png


I borrowed a tiny clip of your photo to ask a question. (I hope that's ok.) Just curious about these little guys. I have a couple of tiny bundles on my rock (nothing major). Are these a pest or ok to have? Their tubes are hard, so my assumption is that they're just a type of fan worm/feather duster.
 
They are hydroids
Oops.

So I guess I need to be paying attention to this thread to how to get it cleaned up. Luckily my rock is very small and I can kill it with fire. (joking) I had ONE tiny aptasia, so I just put reef glue on it and the problem was solved. These guys are a little bigger. Suggestions from the "Peroxide King"?
 
P_20150807_131532.jpg Hold on I will take a picture on how I "spot treat" with Brandon's method
 
I've never seen so many hydroids. I generally have a few on my rock work and they never seem to multiply to the point of becoming a problem. Same with aptasia. I've had a few in one of my tanks for years without them ever multiplying. How are your tank parameters? From what I've read years ago and it may not be true but at one time hobbyists were building aptasia filters. A sump that would remove phosphates by the animal life. The hydroids are probably so plentiful because you have a lot of plankton in the tank water for them to consume. And that's a guess on my part. Just suggesting there may be other methods of control beyond replacing the rock or damaging the bacteria in it.
 
Good point Harold!
Aptasia, zenia, macro farms are in fact used for "control" of water.
Hydroids are opportunist feeder feeding off the water column and the available food particles.
They are just as bad as any other hydroid so in high numbers should be spot treated.

Take out a rock. Drip peroxide on the section you want to rid of sit for a minute or two then rinse off.
 
Man there's no way idea kill that rock. Personally I'd just kill the to keep them in check.

Obviously they haven't bothered you that much if they are that big. Haha.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top