should I reuse my mature live rock?

Man there's no way idea kill that rock. Personally I'd just kill the to keep them in check.

Obviously they haven't bothered you that much if they are that big. Haha.
You're somewhat right. They haven't bothered me that much. I would probably just keep living with them if I didn't have to move the tank to a new stand. Since I have to break it down, I figured it would be a good time to address the hydroids and aptasia. I appreciate the feed back from those posting.
 
I would put the rock in the other tank and treat them or start with new rock. Nowaday, minimum live rock is look much better and clean.
 
I guess I'll be the lone voice in the dark who doesn't agree. To me the hydroids are a sign that the tank is fully mature and that there's enough pods and plankton in the system for hydroids and corals to survive well. As long as there's no algae issue and the hydroids aren't overgrowing areas where you don't want them I see no reason to remove them. If anything they are somewhat beneficial to the tank by removing compounds from the water, even the aptasia does this removing nitrates from the water. As far as the amount of rock work unless you have a large refusium with lots of gravel and rock, the more rock in the display the more bacteria to process bio-load in the tank. The great thing about this forum is you'll often get differing views and that actually is a good thing when it gets you doing more research before committing to a course of action. As nice as your zoa's and mushrooms look I wouldn't make a lot of changes.
 
I guess I'll be the lone voice in the dark who doesn't agree. To me the hydroids are a sign that the tank is fully mature and that there's enough pods and plankton in the system for hydroids and corals to survive well. As long as there's no algae issue and the hydroids aren't overgrowing areas where you don't want them I see no reason to remove them. If anything they are somewhat beneficial to the tank by removing compounds from the water, even the aptasia does this removing nitrates from the water. As far as the amount of rock work unless you have a large refusium with lots of gravel and rock, the more rock in the display the more bacteria to process bio-load in the tank. The great thing about this forum is you'll often get differing views and that actually is a good thing when it gets you doing more research before committing to a course of action. As nice as your zoa's and mushrooms look I wouldn't make a lot of changes.
Well stated :-)
 
I guess I'll be the lone voice in the dark who doesn't agree. To me the hydroids are a sign that the tank is fully mature and that there's enough pods and plankton in the system for hydroids and corals to survive well. As long as there's no algae issue and the hydroids aren't overgrowing areas where you don't want them I see no reason to remove them. If anything they are somewhat beneficial to the tank by removing compounds from the water, even the aptasia does this removing nitrates from the water. As far as the amount of rock work unless you have a large refusium with lots of gravel and rock, the more rock in the display the more bacteria to process bio-load in the tank. The great thing about this forum is you'll often get differing views and that actually is a good thing when it gets you doing more research before committing to a course of action. As nice as your zoa's and mushrooms look I wouldn't make a lot of changes.
Thank you Harold for your opinion. This why I asked the question. To hear different points of view so an informed course of action can be made.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top