Should I run a carbon reactor for a reef tank?

aquatony

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Apr 14, 2017
Messages
245
Reaction score
149
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I have a 40 g cube. Eshopp s120 skimmer. In a wet dry system with marine pure balls under neath my sponge filter. My tank is almost 3 months old. Had a fish took him out because he had flukes so I am running fishless for a month. Just 5-6 red and blue hermits. 4-5 margaritas snails and 1 turbo. Also been dosing zeoback and coral snow. For a month now. Getting great growth. Lots of feather dusters and such. Also just order my ATO system. Should I implement a reactor as well??
 
I have been running fishless for a month now** going to wait 80 days or so before adding another fish
 
I run one periodically, but not all the time. It will help with clarity and pulls out coral toxins fairly well. I run it one week a month then toss it.
 
Its up to you weather you add a reactor or not. Some will run GFO if they have high phosphates they need to keep in check, others run carbon for that great clearness or to use to pull out contaminants...etc. Personally I do not run anything on my systems as I like to keep them as natural as I can. For a young tank I would not worry about a reactor, but this is something everyone would have a different opinion on.

In all honesty the only thing i really dose in a new tank is alk, calc and mag. I then wait for the tank to mature before I start dosing supplements. After your tank settles in I like to try additives to see if they yeild any results, but when your tank is still in that new phase or maturing phase i think your just wasting money.
 
I have seen some people pulling 1/4 cup in of Gfo with their carbon. I deffinitely have phosphates in my tank. More than their should be. Starting to get a cyano layer on the sand and also some hairy algae. I have been doing water changes once a week. Only have a frog spawn an awesome zoa and and Xenia island. Planning to do a lot of hammers frog spawns and maybe. A torch over a anemone. Not sure yet. I'm going to cut back on the zeoback and snow. Also I increased my flow quite a bit to maybe help the cyano clear up
 
My skimmer hasn't been doing the best I have been running it wet so when I'm gone the water level doesn't effect it as much. But now that I got my ato coming in the mail I believe my skimmer will do a lot more of the work
 
Well, you do have a new tank. First comes diatoms, then cyano, followed by hair algae. These are the cycles the tank goes through to establish its ecosystem. In fact the tank never stops cycling, just keeps maturing. Everything you have is normal. With the presence of phosphates, need to test for nitrates also.
 
My nitrates are at a steady 5ish according to the color. For the last month. I increased my water changes for a few weeks I did not notice any change
 
Have been cleaning my sponge every water change. According to brs. Cleaning a filter sock 2-3 days will drop you phos and nitrates by 40-50 % so was considering trying that
 
Keep up with the water changes. Try not to intervene too much with gfo or additives. In my experience, doing this prolongs cyano or stunts its cycling stages. Nature is slow, as we should be too. Just take it slow.
 
How much water do you recommend I change weekly at this stage?
 
[emoji106] been doing around 8-10 gallons. Should I try removing detrius from sump ? I don't have anything to remove it with as of right now. Need a sink vacuum hook up since I live in an apartment ATM do not have a basement to make gravity flow
 
Also I only have 1 live Xenia rock. And some snails who were brought in with corraline algae and I have already starting noticing little pink spots on my dry rock [emoji106] Other than the spots my dry rock is pretty much completely green except for where the coral has shaded?
 
I keep a bag of purigen and carbon in my sump, no need for reactors ime. I keep the purigen until it changes colors and the carbon for a few weeks. It will not make or break the system, but it does do a good job of removing an tint from the water. I figure the stuff works, so why not?
 
I don't see carbon being necessary unless you spray chemicals near the tank or air fresheners. I tried the AC bandwagon for a couple weeks and my fished seemed off. Some users have seen negative effects on Tangs.

http://www.advancedaquarist.com/blog/activated-carbon-affirmed-as-causative-agent-for-hlle-disease

That article is very misleading IMHO. I believe the most important quote from it is......
"More research is needed to understand all the criteria involved. This may, in time, lead to "anti-HLLES" GAC implementations and technologies. Perhaps all that may be required is using fine micron filters post GAC."
Tangs are grazers. Naturally, if there is an abundance of carbon dust on the surfaces in the tank, the tang will ingest it, and it will likely lead to health issues. Simply rinsing the carbon well and/or running particulate filtration after the carbon should remedy this situation. Which would explain why many of us run carbon without such problems.
Peace
EC

 
That article is very misleading IMHO. I believe the most important quote from it is......
"More research is needed to understand all the criteria involved. This may, in time, lead to "anti-HLLES" GAC implementations and technologies. Perhaps all that may be required is using fine micron filters post GAC."
Tangs are grazers. Naturally, if there is an abundance of carbon dust on the surfaces in the tank, the tang will ingest it, and it will likely lead to health issues. Simply rinsing the carbon well and/or running particulate filtration after the carbon should remedy this situation. Which would explain why many of us run carbon without such problems.
Peace
EC
That may be so but I've seen it here in the forums. Constant AC usage can cause issues. In fact some forum members were told to remove AC due to HLLE.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top