Should I run a carbon reactor for a reef tank?

Actived carbon wagon. meaning a lot of hobbyists have been using it. A lot of hype so many others joined in
I don't think it's necessary. It's for polishing your water. If you are doing water changes, you won't notice a difference. If you don't do water changes, running it periodically it might benefit. Besides some elements are needed in our systems like Iron.
 
Easy to tell if you would benefit from the clarity aspect. Put tank water in a white bucket - is it white a brown tint? Add carbon and see if the bucket loses the tint. It's hard to tell in the tank if water has a tint, some don't care, others do.
 
Easy to tell if you would benefit from the clarity aspect. Put tank water in a white bucket - is it white a brown tint? Add carbon and see if the bucket loses the tint. It's hard to tell in the tank if water has a tint, some don't care, others do.
Gonna have to make sure that bucket is clean too. Maybe use a new bucket and then look under full spectrum light or day light as some incandescent lighting will show a yellow tint. Might try to study it for a few minutes that way you can decide if it's even necessary lol ;Playful;Meh
 
No need to get snotty just because you don't like doing that. Every try it? You might be surprised. I don't know if everyone has a taste for DOC discolored water, but hey, to each their own. Did activated carbon bully you as a child?

When touring the Omaha zoo aquarium the director told me that they use ozone because activated carbon is too expensive to run in their large systems - of course their viewing window is generally meters and not feet like home aquaria, but it still is a valid reason to run carbon.
 
No need to get snotty just because you don't like doing that. Every try it? You might be surprised. I don't know if everyone has a taste for DOC discolored water, but hey, to each their own. Did activated carbon bully you as a child?

When touring the Omaha zoo aquarium the director told me that they use ozone because activated carbon is too expensive to run in their large systems - of course their viewing window is generally meters and not feet like home aquaria, but it still is a valid reason to run carbon.
Not being snotty at all. The question to this thread is "should i run a reactor" answet is it isnt necessary. Ive never delt with an issue that would say i need to check water color for use of carbon to fix my issue. If you are going to take pictures, have company or have something to really show off, then running carbon for clarity could be considered. Now I've had issues where water was too clean and therefore resulting in issues. So all in all, is it necessary?
 
I only feel that it's wise to point out pros and cons and also how one can verify resutls if they so wanted. Very few things in this hobby are absolute requirements, however that choice to run something or not is an individual one.

http://www.reefkeeping.com/issues/2006-05/rhf/index.php#4

Randy's article about ozone and talking about water clarity. Carbon will have similar effect. I actually thought I got that bucket idea from him, maybe I saw it a post of his. I don't think we have talked about the benefits of running carbon in a mixed reef where soft leathers if large enough can produce allopathic biochemicals that have the potential of growth inhibition of other corals or if keeping a species of fish or invert that if injured release nasty chemicals into the system.
 
I only feel that it's wise to point out pros and cons and also how one can verify resutls if they so wanted. Very few things in this hobby are absolute requirements, however that choice to run something or not is an individual one.

http://www.reefkeeping.com/issues/2006-05/rhf/index.php#4

Randy's article about ozone and talking about water clarity. Carbon will have similar effect. I actually thought I got that bucket idea from him, maybe I saw it a post of his. I don't think we have talked about the benefits of running carbon in a mixed reef where soft leathers if large enough can produce allopathic biochemicals that have the potential of growth inhibition of other corals or if keeping a species of fish or invert that if injured release nasty chemicals into the system.

Yeah, I was wondering about the issue of soft corals producing toxins and affecting other corals--including adversely affecting other soft corals in my tank. I periodically snip back the Xenia and the GSP in my tank. I do catch a lot of the large pieces in a net, but a lot of little pieces go uncaught. Also, sometimes I accidentally snip a couple of polyps of a Zoa when I'm cutting back the Xenia, because the Xenia has encroached on this other rock where I have these Zoas growing. I have started to wonder if the Zoas I accidentally clip off could be causing toxins in the water and perhaps I should be putting some carbon or a poly filter into my sump for a few days around the time I do that. Also, I have a toadstool, and I am wondering if it is putting any toxins out as it is gradually getting bigger.
I recently had a pair of Bam Bam zoas die for no clear reason, a couple of Goniopora are looking bad and my Rastas lost a few polyps.....not sure, but it could have come right after I did cut back some Xenia and accidentally clipped a couple of zoas. And I recently had a new fish die--I did get it out on the evening of the day it died after I came back from work, but perhaps it put out some toxins for the 9 or 10 hours I was gone and it was dead....
 
I just started 75 gallon saltwater tank and was wondering if I should take out huge pouches of carbon in aqua clear 70 filters
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top