So you think your torch corals don't like too much flow? Think again!

Torch corals need lower flow.

  • True

    Votes: 213 26.6%
  • False

    Votes: 440 54.9%
  • THINK AGAIN and check the thread!

    Votes: 148 18.5%

  • Total voters
    801
No corals will do well in direct, unrelenting laminar flow. I've found my euphillia to do generally better in somewhat lower flow ..... but not low flow. I typically place them in the bottom third of the tank where there is more of an undertow.
 
Ive had to turn down my flow recently as my torch and hammers were not extending all the way, I would say they are not in pretty low flow.
 
And I thought mine had a lot of flow- I guess not! Pretty irregular though, DC powerbeads are awesome in their ability to replicate non-laminar flow.


 
c3305d0fbbf17bca98026bfaedb5004a.jpg


Not a torch, but also seems happy in some decent flow.
 
I think the issue I’ve seen with other reef keepers isn’t about the amount of flow but more a question of type of flow.
@TheHarold you already kinda beat me to it and I say kind of cause I’d feel the best flow would be some sort of mix with non uniform and turbulent flow added in.
 
Last edited:
I think the issue I’ve seen with other reef keepers isn’t about the amount of flow but more a question of type of flow.
@TheHarold you already kinda beat me to it and I say kind of cause I’d feel the best blow would be some sort of mix with non uniform and turbulent flow added in.

That is how it happens in nature, no?

Most reefs are inshore and thus are subject to constant wave and tide movement that can go from calm (almost still) to violent. Anyone who has bait fished from shore or bottom fished from a boat knows what it's like to go from a 1 ounce bucktail to 8 ounces of lead in the same day to hold bottom.

Constant flow in the same direction is called a river.

Accordingly, I have some low flow 24x7 (return pumps), plus medium flow from two pumps facing each other on 30 minute on/off cycles and then I have one pump that's way oversized for the tank that turns on 4 times a day for 1 hour each time, directed at my sps but strong enough to kick up the detritus. My torch and frogspawns appear to like this, although the one frogspawn's heads that are near the return pump (24x7 light to med flow) are much tighter than the frogspawn that get a more varied flow including a direct hit of from the high flow.

Now if I wanted to upped the ante even more, I'd get rid of all my pumps for variable speed DC pumps and include a moon cycle to mimic how the moon affect the intensity of flow and a random storm function.
 
Lower the flow the more water they take in which makes them more puffy. People tend to think that means they prefer low flow. Im my experience torches can be kept in either or. Just depends if you like them more puffy or the more stringy look in the video posted.
 
I know torches can take flow but how much more can they take over hammers or frogspawn ? as having all types in the same tank, trying to dial the flow to keep all happy is quite hard in a small 24x18x18 tank with montipora digitata aswel.
Sounds like you need a bigger tank... like a real big tank.. haha. That’s what I’m thinkin, then you can have all sorts of Varying hi and low flow. Make em all happy. 1000 G’s should suffice
 
Just bc you can blast a torch with flow doesn’t mean that it should be done. We grow coral for aesthetic reasons and having the tentacles flying around all of the place doesn’t bring out the beauty of the coral imo.
 
Great thread. My son just got a Holy Grail. Might change it's placement completely.
 
I am hesitant to make changes based of videos like that. It's interesting to see, and no doubt it's worth consideration, but it's not a home reef tank. That sounds trite, but there might be hundreds of reasons they can be maintained in that fashion that might be absent in home reef tanks. I could see the potential of getting a cut and brown jelly setting in for one. Perhaps those pathogens are in higher density in small system.... On the other hand perhaps it's that flow that keep it at bay in the video!

We just don't know but it's cool to see.
 
My torches are in mixed reef in sps dominant tank and they love the flow.
 
Sounds like you need a bigger tank... like a real big tank.. haha. That’s what I’m thinkin, then you can have all sorts of Varying hi and low flow. Make em all happy. 1000 G’s should suffice
I would like a huge tank but I'd require more light (money) more flow so more pumps ( more money) and more coral to fill it (alot more money). I only like the smaller fish as not a big fish/tang fan. I'm running 3 small tanks at the moment. All 3 tanks to buy and set up still cost less than buying a massive tank.
DSC_0876.JPG
DSC_0862.JPG
DSC_0664.JPG
 
There is an issue with flow and torches that I haven't seen mentioned yet in this thread.

Torches can become damaged if their tissue is banged against rockwork or sharp edges of other coral. The torch can get infected and start losing heads, and sometimes the problem can spread through the colony.
 
For mine, its always been low to medium flow is what keeps them extended the most. High flow they seem to close up a good amount.
 
Like everything nature adapts too it’s circumstances... great thread by the way .. I’m definitely gonna try more flow in my tank now !!
 
I've got my torches on the top of my rocks in my mixed tank. They get as much or more flow than my acropora. A lot of light as well! They are happy so I just leave them alone for the past couple years. As long as the powerhead isn't directly a few inches away blasting the torch, they will handle a lot of flow imo. I have 2 gyre 250s and 2 tunze 6105s in my 200 gallon DD.

The torches will tell us if they are getting hit too hard in my experience.

Yes I agree, and I think they do well with higher light and flow, like a sps reef tank, with low nutrient and without direct feeding, and when I mean higher, I think they like a medium/high random flow.

Also curious about how frogspawn and hammers handle flow.
I think frogspawn like low flow, hammers medium flow and torchs medium/high

Maybe what I said above is what worked for the torches from Indonesia, with long and thin tentacles, since I never had much luck with the Aussies.

Here some examples of my flow for torches:



There's more videos here.
Www.youtube.com/kaduozores
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top