SPS dominant with very low alkalinity in the 4's

reeferee

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Mar 18, 2013
Messages
158
Reaction score
135
Location
CT
What state or country do you live in
Connecticut
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I have an 800 gallon sps dominant reef and when I tested alkalinity today it was at 4.2. I don't test often, typically only when something seems off. Today my euphelia wasn't fully extended. I've tried to research alkalinity levels this low and can't really find anything posted below the 6 range. My alkalinity has slowly drifted down from 7.5 over the last few years. It had been in the 6's, then down InThe 5's
 
I have an 800 gallon sps dominant reef and when I tested alkalinity today it was at 4.2. I don't test often, typically only when something seems off. Today my euphelia wasn't fully extended. I've tried to research alkalinity levels this low and can't really find anything posted below the 6 range. My alkalinity has slowly drifted down from 7.5 over the last few years. It had been in the 6's, then down InThe 5's
What are you using as a test kit? Just curious, as Hanna is notorious for testing low if it has been open a while and low in the bottle.
 
But now in the 4's seems crazy low. Most of the sps is growing great with the exception of a few pieces receding at the base. I have trouble introducing new pieces, but haven't tried to add anything in a few years for fear of introducing pests
 
What are you using as a test kit? Just curious, as Hanna is notorious for testing low if it has been open a while and low in the bottle.
I am using hanna but tested my other system with the same kit and came back at 8.2
 
Also, if you are going to bring it up, I would do no more than 1dkh a day and try to spread it throughout the day, as that will take a lot of any thing to raise it up.
 
But now in the 4's seems crazy low. Most of the sps is growing great with the exception of a few pieces receding at the base. I have trouble introducing new pieces, but haven't tried to add anything in a few years for fear of introducing pests
I have been down in the low 5 numerous times while traveling out of town and forgetting to fill my dosing containers up. Trick is to bring it up slowly and then figure out your consumption to determine if dosing, kalk stirrer, etc will be the best to maintain it.
 
A few pics
 

Attachments

  • 1609098762664.jpg
    1609098762664.jpg
    225.7 KB · Views: 134
  • 20211020_212903.jpg
    20211020_212903.jpg
    165.9 KB · Views: 142
  • 20211020_212829.jpg
    20211020_212829.jpg
    262.9 KB · Views: 158
  • 20211020_212703.jpg
    20211020_212703.jpg
    168.5 KB · Views: 160
What are you using to test ALK? Forget that, I see you used a Hanna.

I use a Trident, KHD, and Hanna, long story, but, never seen a reading that low. Hanna testers will not show that low on themselves. I have seen bad reagents of Hanna that show low though. I would get another reagent bottle and test. I don't even know it that level is possible? I did see some jacked up readings from my Hanna Alk tester and though I needed to get another Hanna tester, but, I bought another reagent bottle to test it, and, it came back into line with what I expected.

When I say bad reagents, I mean that they read fine for a few months, and then poof, they read way off. I did use that specific reagent for several months though, maybe moisture or something got to it, not sure.
 
I have been down in the low 5 numerous times while traveling out of town and forgetting to fill my dosing containers up. Trick is to bring it up slowly and then figure out your consumption to determine if dosing, kalk stirrer, etc will be the best to maintain it.
Also I am using a calcium reactor. Calcium is 450. Ph has perfect sinewave on apex between 8.3 to 8.7 but haven't calibrated in awhile
 
Also I am using a calcium reactor. Calcium is 450. Ph has perfect sinewave on apex between 8.3 to 8.7 but haven't calibrated in awhile
Also, just to double check, I know you did test the other tank to check, but do you have some fresh SW to test? You could try that just as a triple check. Just compare the alk to what the salt mix should mix to. Just remember, some salts list their params at 1.026 and others at 1.021. If you need to know what your salt mixes at, I can pull out my laptop and look for ya. I have an old article screen snipped and saved on it with all salts params.
 
What are you using to test ALK? Forget that, I see you used a Hanna.

I use a Trident, KHD, and Hanna, long story, but, never seen a reading that low. Hanna testers will not show that low on themselves. I have seen bad reagents of Hanna that show low though. I would get another reagent bottle and test. I don't even know it that level is possible? I did see some jacked up readings from my Hanna Alk tester and though I needed to get another Hanna tester, but, I bought another reagent bottle to test it, and, it came back into line with what I expected.

When I say bad reagents, I mean that they read fine for a few months, and then poof, they read way off. I did use that specific reagent for several months though, maybe moisture or something got to it, not sure.
Just tested with salient. 0.7 remaining = 4.5
 

Attachments

  • 20211213_192706.jpg
    20211213_192706.jpg
    71.1 KB · Views: 150
Salifert
 
Just tested with salient. 0.7 remaining = 4.5
I am not even sure if that is possible. 4.5 DKH

Salifert, never have been a fan. Please get another reagent vial for the Hanna. I am not sure if it is chemically possible to have a 4 or 4.5 DKH. What is your Cal at?
 
After dosing 200 ml every alkalinity, its 4.8
 

Attachments

  • 20211213_193240.jpg
    20211213_193240.jpg
    78.9 KB · Views: 133
I am not even sure if that is possible. 4.5 DKH

Salifert, never have been a fan. Please get another reagent vial for the Hanna.
4.5 is possible. Been at that before and was scary thought.

He has also tested another tank and didn’t get a low reading with the Hanna, so at least that is a little promising for the reagent.
 
Esv....I hate auto correct
 
I'm not really concerned because I don't chase levels and the corals look great, but can't find anyone else with similar levels which seems weird
 
What is the Cal at, before you dosed?
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top