SPS dominant with very low alkalinity in the 4's

So I retested my alk/Calc and PO4 today. Alk was at 4.4, Calc at 515 and PO4 at .092 or 31 on hanna ULR
 

Attachments

  • 20211215_165113.jpg
    20211215_165113.jpg
    69.5 KB · Views: 47
  • 20211215_170811.jpg
    20211215_170811.jpg
    110.1 KB · Views: 43
  • 20211215_170817.jpg
    20211215_170817.jpg
    104 KB · Views: 43
Now I speculate the Calc was higher after dosing part 1 esv raising them both in tandem. Did some research and found d that soda ash or sodium carbonate will raise alk without increasing calcium. Added 1/2 cup soda ash which by my Calc should raise alk by 1.4 dkh in 720 gallons. Retested alk and it is 5.7, so worked out exactly as planned. Also mixed some fresh reef crystals and tested that to see if hanna is accurate and it tested 9.8 which leads me to believe hanna is fine. Will update again in a few days.
 

Attachments

  • 20211215_165852.jpg
    20211215_165852.jpg
    94 KB · Views: 39
  • 20211215_174803.jpg
    20211215_174803.jpg
    64.1 KB · Views: 45
my red sea kit tests out a 3. I did it twice today. my api says 8. who knows! my coral look good. torches , brain, aneneome, mushrooms , rodi's
I am using hanna but tested my other system with the same kit and came back at 8.2
 
Good to see you guys with 4s and 5s not impacting your SPS too much. I'm in the same boat with a wonky CaRX that let my ALK drift down. Discovered it in 5.5 and now raising back up hence the research mode here for other experiences. Looks like I may be lucky and not get too much of an SPS impact.
 
You can make your own soda ash (carbonate) out of baking soda (bicarbonate) if you bake it in the oven for a while. Either works to add alk. Bicarbonate will add some co2, so if you are already super low PH, then might be a good idea to bake it some. I have no pH issues, so I just use baking soda.

Healthy corals can tolerate massive swings and stuff. If one alk swing kills them, then they were probably just hanging on anyway - nobody wants to hear this, but it is likely true in most cases.
 
I have an 800 gallon sps dominant reef and when I tested alkalinity today it was at 4.2. I don't test often, typically only when something seems off. Today my euphelia wasn't fully extended. I've tried to research alkalinity levels this low and can't really find anything posted below the 6 range. My alkalinity has slowly drifted down from 7.5 over the last few years. It had been in the 6's, then down InThe 5's
Dude, keep it at 8-9.5 DkH
 
I'm not really concerned because I don't chase levels and the corals look great, but can't find anyone else with similar levels which seems weird
I have similar levels. Every time my tank is tested (once every year or two) it’s somewhere between 4 and 5 dkh. Has been like that for 10 years. I run a mixed reef with super easy sps (birdsnest, stylo, Digi, monti) and lps corals and zoas. I don’t run a skimmer so I think it’s waste buildup that drags mine down.
I do a large 50% water change once every 4-6 weeks. The zoas are the only corals that do seem to struggle from time to time to time but perk up after the monthly water change. guess that’s not an option for you though with that massive system.
 
Last edited:
For what it's worth I too have low Alk and have been working to slowly get it up. I have a small system. I also noticed my alk was low in a new batch of salt as well. HERE

Off topic, what is the name of this coral... love how it's rounded.

1640872556831.png
 
People routinely keep alk well above natural levels at 1.5 or ever 2x higher. Who is to say that 1.5 or 2x lower is a problem. I am not advocating this, but it seems that most are more apt to gasp at 2x lower than 2x higher and do we know that either is different?
 
I would think that growth of stony corals would slow/stop with alk in that range. There has to be a certain combo of low pH and alk that makes it impossible for the precipitation needed for the skeleton.
 
Once there is enough, then are we sure what more does? If 1 ppm of something is enough for corals to use, then what does 7 or 9 do?

Carbonate is just buffer. It does not move pH. You could have 8.3 pH with low carbonate readings or 7.7 pH with very high. My tank is usually 8-8.1 to 8.3 with a dKh in the high 6s but this is almost exculsively because we keep the home aired out with low ambient co2 content.

I am not wanting to sound all crazy or anything and I do keep my alk in the high 6s like the ocean and like to recommend this range, but I am not sure that you could convince me that the 4.4 reading above was any worse than 9.0 since both are not even close to NSW.
 
I'm also wondering what your mag is reading at. I noticed my alkalinity dropped down to 5.5, I checked my mag and that was like 1170 but my calcium was still in the low 400's. Without your magnesium being 1250 or higher, numbers can swing.
 
Once there is enough, then are we sure what more does?
But how much is enough to grow the skeleton?

I know you're aware of how corals grow. For some other folks, corals uptake carbonate (we just measure alk, because it's easier to measure and is the same for our purposes) and precipitate it with calcium by increasing the pH. The higher the tank pH, the less it takes to accomplish this. At a certain point where alk, or Ca, or pH is low enough, the process has to slow down or stop. Maybe that's a @Randy Holmes-Farley question. And maybe it is lower than 5 dKH.

Carbonate is just buffer. It does not move pH.
I know you're trying to make a point, but you know both of those statements are false. Carbonate /bicarbonate means more to corals than that, and pH and is mathematically dependent on dKH and CO2.
You could have 8.3 pH with low carbonate readings or 7.7 pH with very high.
Sure, depending on CO2 levels.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top