Tank Crash

Just curious because it kind of relates to tank crashes but do you guys replace equipment at certain intervals rather then waiting until something breaks? Like return pumps or heaters? Do you just swap them out after a few years just to be safe? Doser?...basically I'm wondering if you guys take steps like that before a mechanical failure results in crashed tank? I know routine maintenance can extend equipment life and reliability.
 
Maybe upgrade. :grinning-squinting-face: My tanks' status don't define my reefing. Reefing isn't a hobby to me, it is who I am. Just like life, things happen. And just because they happen doesn't mean I just quit something. I continue with life and take the good with the bad. :beaming-face-with-smiling-eyes:
Well said
 
Just curious because it kind of relates to tank crashes but do you guys replace equipment at certain intervals rather then waiting until something breaks? Like return pumps or heaters? Do you just swap them out after a few years just to be safe? Doser?...basically I'm wondering if you guys take steps like that before a mechanical failure results in crashed tank? I know routine maintenance can extend equipment life and reliability.
I upgrade periodically, either aligning with technology or general replacement.
I always have a Backup: Return pump, heater, items for power outage and medications if ever needed
 
I just had a major dino outbreak that took out all my coral. Killed the lights and just enjoying my fish and adding more fish to ensure nutrients stay up. Have some local swaps this summer, I might pick up some pieces.

If I were to have a major crash, everything dead, I'd be tempted to throw in the towel. Fish and coral are so dang pricy anymore.
 
I've had plenty of minor and major tank crashes in this hobby. Some were due to my ignorance and/or laziness, others were due to equipment failures. Regardless of crashes, I restarted and learned from the mistakes -- my next tank was always better than the last. If recovering from the same tank, I took an opportunity to kill everything with vinegar and gave it one good scrub - very therapeutic anyway! Finally, redo that aquascape since it's a "new" tank! :)
 
I don't know if its about a tank crash so much as about where you are in life when the tank crashes. For me, I was in the middle of divorce and broke and other life challenges, was not in the mind set to restart a tank. If my tank crashed now, I would definately restart.
 
I've had my own salt water (not family) since 1986. In 2008 I had a massive crash of a 400g amazing SPS tank. I spent days on the couch in front of the tank with tears rolling down my cheeks. The loss of life, the loss of time, the impossibility to replace were just overwhelming.

There were still some fish and corals left alive - but I couldn't deal with it. I got the water clear and then turned off the lights and all the accessory equipment and left the return pump and heaters running. The tank sat like this, just a brown box for about 9 months. Then I got diagnosed with Kidney Cancer.

I didn't want to deal with cancer without my tank. So I turned on the lights. I scrubbed an inch thick algae layer off the front of the tank and holy moly - There were damsels, and tangs, and a few angels and other fish swimming around in the darkness. All the aquascape was covered in a leafy brown turf algae. I drained the tank down to a few inches and brought the pressure washer into the house and just pressure washed all the rock in place. I used a wet dry vac to suck up as much as the algae on the bottom, filled the tank back up with water and a week later started adding fish and corals back.

In March of 2022, we sufferred a huge loss of the fish on a Thursday from a treatment of Salifert Flatworm Exit (130+ fish lost) and then the corals 30hrs later when the seam of the sump blew and the topoff filled the system back up with fresh water. We had a packed 1350g system at the time.

It was about 3 weeks of being in shock when I told my wife, I think it's time to take a break from the hobby for awhile. We have some other things going on in life as well that are challenges. My wife didn't even take a breath. She said, "Go Order the Tank that you want. Get a new tank. You're not taking a break.".

We'd been living with a 560g tank for almost 2 years that was an emergency swap out. And while the 560g was beautiful, it was 10x2.5x36t - It was impossible to work on as a reef tank. It was a gorgeous reef. But when you are 5.6' and round as a beer keg, your stubby lil arms don't reach very far into a 36 deep tank for mounting corals or picking up things that get knocked over.

So we called Titan Aquatic Exhibits and ordered a new 750g 120x48x30t and started our current tank build.

We are fortunate, in that while the money loss of March 2022 was outrageous, it didn't affect our life. And we could build a new tank and quickly restock it and not have to alter our lifestyle.

Now 7 months after filling the 750 with water, I'm glad my wife didn't let me take a break.

We had fully mature liverock and a running system. So 12 hours after adding water to the tank we had fish and the first couple corals in it. A week later we had 30 new corals in it. A week after that there were 60+ corals in it. For the first 4 months, even without a budget limit on buying corals, it was a overwhelming to see all that empty aquascape and imagine the patience it would take till I had a mature reef tank again. At about the 5.5 month mark we were up to 350+ frags in the tank and there was finally enough corals and fish (140+) so that I had a beautiful aquarium again.

Now I just need to be patient and let things grow and grow and grow.

Dave B


Dave B
 

Attachments

  • 750g - New Cabinets for Stand - Jan 23 - 7.jpg
    750g - New Cabinets for Stand - Jan 23 - 7.jpg
    192.5 KB · Views: 50
Just curious because it kind of relates to tank crashes but do you guys replace equipment at certain intervals rather then waiting until something breaks? Like return pumps or heaters? Do you just swap them out after a few years just to be safe? Doser?...basically I'm wondering if you guys take steps like that before a mechanical failure results in crashed tank? I know routine maintenance can extend equipment life and reliability.
For me I have shelves of replacement parts - Heaters, Pumps, Skimmer pumps, skimmers, Solenoids, etc.

I wait for things to break, pull a new on off the shelf and then order a new replacement.

Most of these kinds of part on the big systems seemed to break between 2am and 4am. So you have to be prepared to curse in the pre-dawn while looking for the spare parts.

Dave B
 
I've had my own salt water (not family) since 1986. In 2008 I had a massive crash of a 400g amazing SPS tank. I spent days on the couch in front of the tank with tears rolling down my cheeks. The loss of life, the loss of time, the impossibility to replace were just overwhelming.

There were still some fish and corals left alive - but I couldn't deal with it. I got the water clear and then turned off the lights and all the accessory equipment and left the return pump and heaters running. The tank sat like this, just a brown box for about 9 months. Then I got diagnosed with Kidney Cancer.

I didn't want to deal with cancer without my tank. So I turned on the lights. I scrubbed an inch thick algae layer off the front of the tank and holy moly - There were damsels, and tangs, and a few angels and other fish swimming around in the darkness. All the aquascape was covered in a leafy brown turf algae. I drained the tank down to a few inches and brought the pressure washer into the house and just pressure washed all the rock in place. I used a wet dry vac to suck up as much as the algae on the bottom, filled the tank back up with water and a week later started adding fish and corals back.

In March of 2022, we sufferred a huge loss of the fish on a Thursday from a treatment of Salifert Flatworm Exit (130+ fish lost) and then the corals 30hrs later when the seam of the sump blew and the topoff filled the system back up with fresh water. We had a packed 1350g system at the time.

It was about 3 weeks of being in shock when I told my wife, I think it's time to take a break from the hobby for awhile. We have some other things going on in life as well that are challenges. My wife didn't even take a breath. She said, "Go Order the Tank that you want. Get a new tank. You're not taking a break.".

We'd been living with a 560g tank for almost 2 years that was an emergency swap out. And while the 560g was beautiful, it was 10x2.5x36t - It was impossible to work on as a reef tank. It was a gorgeous reef. But when you are 5.6' and round as a beer keg, your stubby lil arms don't reach very far into a 36 deep tank for mounting corals or picking up things that get knocked over.

So we called Titan Aquatic Exhibits and ordered a new 750g 120x48x30t and started our current tank build.

We are fortunate, in that while the money loss of March 2022 was outrageous, it didn't affect our life. And we could build a new tank and quickly restock it and not have to alter our lifestyle.

Now 7 months after filling the 750 with water, I'm glad my wife didn't let me take a break.

We had fully mature liverock and a running system. So 12 hours after adding water to the tank we had fish and the first couple corals in it. A week later we had 30 new corals in it. A week after that there were 60+ corals in it. For the first 4 months, even without a budget limit on buying corals, it was a overwhelming to see all that empty aquascape and imagine the patience it would take till I had a mature reef tank again. At about the 5.5 month mark we were up to 350+ frags in the tank and there was finally enough corals and fish (140+) so that I had a beautiful aquarium again.

Now I just need to be patient and let things grow and grow and grow.

Dave B


Dave B
Youre the one with this tank. !! Grerat story, hope youre feeling well and love the tank
 
Definitely restart. I would absolutely be devastated about the loss of life and my little buddies, but I'd try to view it as an opportunity to try something maybe a bit different.
 
Ya but I would be heartbroken to lose the fish so I suspect I would take a break.

If it was just the coral, then whatever, be frustrated but not sad I guess.

It is an addiction though so I don't think I could stay away.
 
Had two major crashes in 30 years and still here. First was years ago and a garbage ATO that wiped the ENTIRE tank fish coral and all. Second was probably an alk crash probably 4 years ago that wiped all my SPS. I mean hey each recovery or remodel is a new adventure and opportunity to pour lots more money into the pit ;)
 
I had a major heatwave nuke my 2 month old 55 gallon while I was on vacation 20 years ago...I happened to be bringing back an A/C unit at the time. I was 2 years into the hobby and had recently parted and moved my 38 gallon to a different apartment.

I just recured the existing rock, but should have done a rip clean/reset.


I'm still here with some of that original rock and a couple of survivor softies.

If my current system totally nuked, I might rebuild it differently and maybe put more focus into SPS or do a Caribbean tank with Florida live rock and Atlantic species.
 
I have 2 reef systems an 80g and a 170g. So I would definitely take one down. Then definitely fowlr. I'm kinda over the coral thing but really love my fish. I'm much more apt to drop big money on a fish vs. a coral now. I'm very confident with fish. Coral is just too much upkeep. I would probably do some gsp of all things for a color pop and keep just fish,nems and clams..
 
I have 2 reef systems an 80g and a 170g. So I would definitely take one down. Then definitely fowlr. I'm kinda over the coral thing but really love my fish. I'm much more apt to drop big money on a fish vs. a coral now. I'm very confident with fish. Coral is just too much upkeep. I would probably do some gsp of all things for a color pop and keep just fish,nems and clams..
Coral is another issue. Made two attempts at fish only and always ends up with a city of coral
 
This is pretty relevant to me since I just had a crash. My wifes cats managed to submerge one of my flex-armed lights into the tank and it looked like this introduced voltage and copper into the water column. I lost most of my established corals and 1 fish. 1 of my other SPS colonies is hanging by a thread with some bleaching and STN occuring, but some of the arms still have good polyp extension.

I used this as an opportunity to upgrade my lighting and also purchased a Hydros controller and Gyre pump.

For some reason this seemed to motivate me more than depress me. I've always been competitive and like a good challenge.
 
Maybe upgrade. :grinning-squinting-face: My tanks' status don't define my reefing. Reefing isn't a hobby to me, it is who I am. Just like life, things happen. And just because they happen doesn't mean I just quit something. I continue with life and take the good with the bad. :beaming-face-with-smiling-eyes:
This sums it up for me. "Reefing isn't a hobby to me, it is who I am...."
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top