Two out of two fish died in two days

It's an auto feeder, not placed. Smallest setting, just a tiny pinch of food once a day.
 
Inside notice the water getting slightly cloudy for a day, but then I got the protein skimmer and it cleared instantly
 
Good for water change. Do another later if you can.
The two deaths may not be related to the same thing.
I have some concern with the dosing thing you were doing.
You have no rock, no sand, and small water volume, in essence your setup may not support enough good bacteria to process the ammonia, or at least, not at this early stage.
When there no rock, sand or block, it much more challenging to balance input/output in terms of nutrients, or at least, IMM.
 
i add bacteria too micro bacter clean. I started with micro bacter start xlm for cycling.
when the tank first started there was red algae everywhere. the snail ate almost all of it. now i just continue to add micro bacter clean, and i did add one dose of micro bacter bio fule, but with the protein skimmer it should be fine even without the coral in there yet,

reason why i was dosing and checking all of the parameters all the time, is just to prepare for when i put in all of the coral, i want the tank to stabilize completely, i didn't think about ammonia, i'm still learning all this even though i've been doing this since i was a kid
 
i add bacteria too micro bacter clean. I started with micro bacter start xlm for cycling.
when the tank first started there was red algae everywhere. the snail ate almost all of it. now i just continue to add micro bacter clean, and i did add one dose of micro bacter bio fule, but with the protein skimmer it should be fine even without the coral in there yet,

reason why i was dosing and checking all of the parameters all the time, is just to prepare for when i put in all of the coral, i want the tank to stabilize completely, i didn't think about ammonia, i'm still learning all this even though i've been doing this since i was a kid
found out the red algae was bacteria by the way
 
i still say it was ammonia, i saved some of the old water to do a water change when the ammonia strips come, i'll probably do another water change this weekend, and change the filter/carbon
 
i still say it was ammonia, i saved some of the old water to do a water change when the ammonia strips come, i'll probably do another water change this weekend, and change the filter/carbon
i meant i saved some of the old water to test when the ammonia strips come in
 
Penguin filter does not provide chemical filtration and enough water movement hence the waste you see on bottom
Skimmer good but you need more to support the nitrogen cycle
Job refugium or similar and even a small Nano powerhead will help with water movement and added oxygen
 
Penguin filter does not provide chemical filtration and enough water movement hence the waste you see on bottom
Skimmer good but you need more to support the nitrogen cycle
Job refugium or similar and even a small Nano powerhead will help with water movement and added oxygen
i have a nano powerhead
 
the whole tank is the size of a refugium, that is not an option, i think one golby later on will work, i need to decrease the amount of food i put in, and during water changes, lift up the mesh and get everything out of the base of the tank, which i wasn't doing.
 
i add bacteria too micro bacter clean. I started with micro bacter start xlm for cycling.
when the tank first started there was red algae everywhere. the snail ate almost all of it. now i just continue to add micro bacter clean, and i did add one dose of micro bacter bio fule, but with the protein skimmer it should be fine even without the coral in there yet,

reason why i was dosing and checking all of the parameters all the time, is just to prepare for when i put in all of the coral, i want the tank to stabilize completely, i didn't think about ammonia, i'm still learning all this even though i've been doing this since i was a kid
What were you dosing and how much?

you should not been dosing anything at all with your current set up. Nothing is taking up Ca or Alk. If there were changes in the numbers it was likely due to precipitation. That can make the tank cloudy.
 
i was dosing .5 milligrams of calcium like every other week as needed, if that, magnesium was normally fine, maybe .5 milligrams, i just test everything at least once a week and if it needs some, i add a tiny amount, everyone is fixating on the dosing, i barely add anything, it's miniscule. It's the nitrates that killed the fish, i am almost certain, there was a ton of waste at the bottom of the tank
 
i was dosing .5 milligrams of calcium like every other week as needed, if that, magnesium was normally fine, maybe .5 milligrams, i just test everything at least once a week and if it needs some, i add a tiny amount, everyone is fixating on the dosing, i barely add anything, it's miniscule. It's the nitrates that killed the fish, i am almost certain, there was a ton of waste at the bottom of the tank
ammonia i meant
 
i was dosing .5 milligrams of calcium like every other week as needed, if that, magnesium was normally fine, maybe .5 milligrams, i just test everything at least once a week and if it needs some, i add a tiny amount, everyone is fixating on the dosing, i barely add anything, it's miniscule. It's the nitrates that killed the fish, i am almost certain, there was a ton of waste at the bottom of the tank
I think the details you provided allow enough reason to question all angles. We still don’t have an ammonia result and there are other areas of concern.
 
i was dosing .5 milligrams of calcium like every other week as needed, if that, magnesium was normally fine, maybe .5 milligrams, i just test everything at least once a week and if it needs some, i add a tiny amount, everyone is fixating on the dosing, i barely add anything, it's miniscule. It's the nitrates that killed the fish, i am almost certain, there was a ton of waste at the bottom of the tank
With no coral.... calcium-mag-alk not needed. Water changes will maintain that
 
With no coral.... calcium-mag-alk not needed. Water changes will maintain that
I understand that now, i would get low calcium levels from time to time, and add some as needed, magnesium and alk was always fine, but the main thing i think, was the waste at the bottom of the tank needed to be syphoned out, i was unaware of ammonia and phosphate testing, all i was worried about was nitrates and nitrites. I ordered ammonia and phosphate test kits, and saved some of the old water to test this weekend. I'll post the results
 
Just be aware that such a small tank is very sensitive. Your salinity can change a lot during the day just from evaporation. My 10-gallon QT tank can easily go from 1.025 to 1.028 in a day or so if I don't top it off with RO/DI water.

Small amounts of uneaten food could cause an ammonia spike in such a small tank. You may want to wait on using the auto-feeder until you have more mouths to feed.
 
Thank you, I have the auto doser, it fluctuates around 1.025 to 1.026. it's a nano auto doser and activates daily with rodi fresh water.

I just decreased the amount of food to just a sliver on the auto feeder. It's smaller than a dime slot, a tiny bit of food is released.

I need to keep feeding the tank for the shrimp, but I do plan on getting a neon goby. I'll keep the food dispenser on the same setting.
 
You should probably test your ammonia daily. If your auto-feeder runs and the power-head blows it around, then the shrimp isn't likely to eat all of it. Uneaten food is the quickest source of ammonia. You need to know if the ammonia is being converted to nitrite immediately or not. If not, then you will continue to struggle with keeping a fish alive.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top