Unquarantined anemone - how much will I regret this?

OP - Apologies for derailing your thread.
Impulse buys on anemones to "rescue" them rarely works in my experience. If you know what you're doing, know how to spot a healthy anemone, have meds and a QT set up that can quickly be put up, then you can get away with it. Here's the rub....how do you get the experience?
Being a geographically beautiful but remote place for the hobby can make for tough choices. Despite what one other poster stated....Stay in Montana, figure out a way to get anemones up there. I'd love to be able to retire up to Montana...but I dont think I could afford what I want up there now with the influx of money into your real-estate market up there. Be patient, develop some supply lines and find some reputable vendors who will ship semi near you. Might mean a 6 or 8 hour drive. But if it's healthy livestock, the drive is usually worth it.

Steve, thanks for chiming in!
That would make for an interesting science experiment.
It should be repeatable.
Question for you though:
I believe I've seen pictures of your tank, and you state you have multiple species of anemone in it. What species do you have in your tank in total? IS it possible that one of the many other species you have in the tank is causing the allelopathy your seeing?
Hypothesis: One of the many other species of anemone is responsible for the allelopathy, and the CSB's, and BW's are so selectively bred to attain the color combination that makes them CSB & BW that they show the effects first?

Please note - I'm not trying to be disrespectful or snarky. I find this fascinating and I dont understand it. I love anemones in an aquarium, so I'm always interested in learning more about them beyond the simple biology and habitat preferences.

To be fair, I most certainly can be snarky and sarcastic...humor is important too.


Winchester.gif


Having said all of that....

Realizing absolutely nobody is volunteering to have their ridiculously expensive E.Quad morphs dissected for a theory....
Have you (or anyone else) done any experiments with just E.quad where identical tanks are set up, and identical clones of E.quad are placed into the tanks? One a control - no carbon. One with Carbon, one with ozone, and one with ozone and carbon?

That would certainly shed some light on the issue?
It’s been my expierence that GBTA and rbta fight each other , I was losing all my GBTA until I dosed cipro into the main display , this saved them and something happened to where they don’t fight anymore but all my GBTA were looking ill while the rbta looked fine , they even snuggle sometimes lol
 

Attachments

  • 69104F1D-9421-42A9-AFF8-ADCA29EEC5F5.jpeg
    69104F1D-9421-42A9-AFF8-ADCA29EEC5F5.jpeg
    180 KB · Views: 26
  • 18D42707-2E20-4BFF-A9D7-C8B72A192FE4.jpeg
    18D42707-2E20-4BFF-A9D7-C8B72A192FE4.jpeg
    193.1 KB · Views: 37
See. This is what makes it interesting. I have a rbta and a green that touch in a tank as well, but put that green in with my other rbta and the green will get mad lol.
There's 6 of them in this mess lol
 

Attachments

  • 16446175945507031224757553860978.jpg
    16446175945507031224757553860978.jpg
    220.6 KB · Views: 26
It’s been my expierence that GBTA and rbta fight each other , I was losing all my GBTA until I dosed cipro into the main display , this saved them and something happened to where they don’t fight anymore but all my GBTA were looking ill while the rbta looked fine , they even snuggle sometimes lol
That would probably be related to a bacteria that the gbta were not used to and the rbta were. Especially if one or the other was a freshly collected wild strain.
 
It’s been my expierence that GBTA and rbta fight each other , I was losing all my GBTA until I dosed cipro into the main display , this saved them and something happened to where they don’t fight anymore but all my GBTA were looking ill while the rbta looked fine , they even snuggle sometimes lol
Wouldn't this be more indicative of bacterial issues? I don't think we can say that Cipro dosing cleared it up, means nems fighting.

Anenomes do release terpenes. We aren't sure exactly the point is, but it seems to be warfare.

Cipro shouldn't do anything to terpenes in the water. If Cipro fixed it, the issue should have been bacterial.

I ran two back-to-back cycles of Cipro with no results.

Ran 8oz of carbon for a week. Nothing. Hooked up additional reactors with carbon only @200gph and within Hours, there was noticeable changes.

Could the toxins (terpenes) make other nems more susceptible to bacteria? Who knows.
 
I guess I don’t really know , it could be a bacterial incompatibility betweeen the nems , the GBTA came from a tank housing them for 10+ years don’t know if wild caught but they were splits from the orginal all GBTA tank . I may need to run more carbon got 3-4 bags of chemi pure in sump but probly need to be replaced. Nems are so strange lol but I love them. Could possibly bacterial incompatibility be linked for nems to use chemical warfare ? Anemones have invaded my thoughts this Friday
 
Have any of you seen adverse effects between different species and those BTA? Like with gigs, merts etc...

P.S. Sorry OP. We're really nerding out on anemone in your post.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top