Well this is no good... (warning! wp-25 discussion ahead)

Ill take my Tunze's with amazing customer service right here in the U.S. Roger has earned my business over the years and I dont mind paying a little more for that.
 
Ipso facto you are contradicting the whole "infringing on copyright/patent" argument. Which I believe was the point of this thread.

To get back on topic, which i thought discussing ethics of copying a design was right inline with the lawsuit, if i was to speculate on which design patent was infringed upon it would be the

Tunze Turbelle 6105

Not the tunze wavebox. The spec of the jaebo and that tunze seem to be similar. What would be nice is a person who has both of these powerheads to do a side by side similarity comparison. My guess to the claim of the lawsuit, is that the wp40 has to many (less than 10% different or whatever is required) physical design features (impeller housing, impeller dimensions, motor specs, shaft dimensions, etc) to be considered an original design. Jaebo will most likely do one of two things, they can do a quick redesign by redimensionjng everything or they can change the company name and sell it under a differed name while they drag it through court. Either way, I can't see this pump not being available in the US for very long.


Sent Via the R2R Forum APP
 
Last edited:
The facts are boring. Please continue to argue so I have something interesting to read. :bigsmile:
 
The facts are boring. Please continue to argue so I have something interesting to read. :bigsmile:

Easy, Gary, if I get banned you've lost your best customer. haha....
 
Rev everyone deserves a second chance. Don't ban Willz, Reef Pets needs all the support possible.

Since no warning has been given and Rev is a nice guy and I'm sure would give you a second chance please continue to argue!
 
To get back on topic, which i thought discussing ethics of copying a design was right inline with the lawsuit, if i was to speculate on which design patent was infringed upon it would be the <br>
<br>
Tunze Turbelle 6105<br>
<br>
Not the tunze wavebox. The spec of the jaebo and that tunze seem to be similar. What would be nice is a person who has both of these powerheads to do a side by side similarity comparison. My guess to the claim of the lawsuit, is that the wp40 has to many (less than 10% different or whatever is required) physical design features (impeller housing, impeller dimensions, motor specs, shaft dimensions, etc) to be considered an original design. Jaebo will most likely do one of two things, they can do a quick redesign by redimensionjng everything or they can change the company name and sell it under a differed name while they drag it through court. Either way, I can't see this pump not being available in the US for very long.
<br><br>No.&nbsp;<br><br>Based on a quick search of the US patent database, the only patent Tunze is likely&nbsp;<em>threatening</em>&nbsp;to assert is a design patent. &nbsp;This is functionally similar to a trade mark - it protects the appearance of a product, to the extent that appearance is ORNAMENTAL. &nbsp;<br><br>Tunze DOES NOT HAVE A PATENT on the design/function of their Turbelle pumps (with the exception of a patent on a particular arrangement of the magnetic holder). &nbsp;They have a "design patent" (as opposed to a "utility patent") on the appearance of their pump, to the extent that appearance is ornamental.<br><br>Most of the appearance of their pump is dictated by function, and therefore NOT PROTECTED BY THE PATENT (e.g., the plastic cage surrounding the motor is functional, the blade guard is functional, the water inlet ports are functional, the mounting hardware is functional, etc.). &nbsp;<br><br>Tunze, in all likelihood, CAN NOT WIN a lawsuit for infringement of this design patent. &nbsp;In all likelihood, they would not risk a lawsuit, since the result might be the invalidation of their design patent, and then they would have nothing to threaten and bluster with.<br><br>To all those complaining about Chinese companies knocking-off innovative products and stealing ideas: &nbsp;If Tunze invented something, they should have patented (with a proper utility patent) their invention. &nbsp;They didn't, either because they didn't "invent" anything (within the legal meaning of that word), or they were to cheap to protect their invention (more likely, since they filed a worthless bull**** design patent on the cheap). &nbsp;So they have no reason to complain about perfectly legal and healthy competition from a company eager to serve a market they're ignoring: cost-sensitive aquarists.
 
I know Skinz, you are the bad guy that bans everyone. Shame on you!
Booooo
 
Well there is only one way to move up, you gotta keep on bidding! When I get the shop shop tomorrow I promise to give them a rub and possible a little song and dance. No promise on the song and dance but certainly a rub
 
Rev everyone deserves a second chance. Don't ban Willz, Reef Pets needs all the support possible.

Since no warning has been given and Rev is a nice guy and I'm sure would give you a second chance please continue to argue!

OK now that I have corporate sponsorship, I've got one more post then I have to hit the sack. Haha...

Agreed, can we get this back on track please?

You're right let's get this back on track by showing another thread where a lone unsubstantiated person on another forum claims that these pumps are having a copyright embargo levied against them, so we can get everyone lathered up in a panic about a non-event. That's not hyperbole or overblown rhetoric or anything.

Please let's get back to focusing on the "virtue" of spending $450 for a single water pump for a hobby. You'd think we were discussing water pumps for drought ravaged countries or something.

I'm just trying to be the best steward of the gifts I have been given (e.g.: if I can get a water pump for my hobby for $300 less, I'll avail myself of that opportunity). So to speak. And promptly hand the difference to someone like Reefpets for MORE CORAL. The point of the hobby :)
 
So if I obtained a red dragon acro strain from the wild. Aquaculture the species. Sell half inch frags for $400 a pop.

And you purchased a frag and now is selling them for $100 per inch.

I can sue you since you drive down the high demand and price of my corals because you are offering a better and cheaper product. What is this hobby getting too. The companies are just mas that they are not gouging the consumers. Competition always benefits the consumer.


Sent Via the R2R Forum APP
 
Personally I would like to see a copy of this from the US attorneys office or patent office. Patents have a lifespan and eventually run out and the device becomes public domain. Not sure when Tunze filed theirs but they ahve been around for many many years. Not that I agree with stealing ideas or cloning something someone has rights to but it would be nice to hear "The Rest of the Story". I am one of those who has both a WP25 and WP-40 reserved and paid for and I would really like to receive them for testing. From what I have seen and heard there are enough differences between these and Tunze or any of the other manufacturers to beat a patent infringement case but it may drag out for a long time proving it.

Did Tunze send the letter or someone in authority, that is the question?


Patents only become "public domain" if they aren't renewed. Only the original patent owner can renew and can renew as many times as wanted, infinitum...
 
I have been cursed up one side and down the other and not banned. Take a lot! Lol!
 
So if I obtained a red dragon acro strain from the wild. Aquaculture the species. Sell half inch frags for $400 a pop.

And you purchased a frag and now is selling them for $100 per inch.

I can sue you since you drive down the high demand and price of my corals because you are offering a better and cheaper product. What is this hobby getting too. The companies are just mas that they are not gouging the consumers. Competition always benefits the consumer.


Sent Via the R2R Forum APP

That is not a good comparison, I dont think you can own the rights to something like coral anyway...which renews itself.

A better example would be that you and your neighbor are always competing to have the nicest yard with the best grass, landscaping, and all of that jazz. Ten years prior you noticed a need in a niche market, and spent the next ten years coming up with a solution to that need...we will call your solution "solution x". In order for you to recover all that time spent developing solution x, you set the price at a moderate price point that you feel can be reached by all income levels, but some people might need to save up. The sale price of solution x and its ability to handle the task cause it to be a great seller, and it is well taken by the niche market you were targeting but some people feel it is to expensive. You set aside, lets say, 20% of your profit for future reseach, and allocate the rest to yourself and your employees, obviously with some going to the company too.

Your neighbor notices how much nicer your yard is and wants to know why. He notices your solution x in the garage and takes one to his house. He spends a couple weeks studying it and says I can make this a lot cheaper by making it with cheaper parts, so he outsources a foreign country to build it where the codes and standards are a lot less stringent and the product can be made very cheaply. He then names his product solution y and sells it for 1/4 of what you sell your product for. He is able to this becasue he has virtually no design costs and is having his built overseas with cheaper components.

Some of your potential customers who won day will use your product now have this much cheaper version that essentiallydoes the same thing, so they say hey its there I am going get this one instead. This spreads like wild fire and before you know it you are seeing a reduction in sales to the point you r&d money has to be used just to maintain the business. You decide that you cant continue to make your product at the quality level you are making it at and be competitive with the new lower cost solution y from your neightbor. You have to abandon the solution x. As you get home you admire at how beautiful your neighbors yard is and silently congratulate him on his yard skills.

One year later all of the solution ys are breaking and nothing better is coming out, and the consumers wish they still had solution x.

I know it is a bit of an extreme but that is what happens, and at least a better analogy. Forgive me if it makes no sense, I have taken my ambien and about to go to bed so I'm partially in a dream state. Cant wait to read this post in the mourning and smh at myself.
 
Last edited:

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top