What do you think the best tank size is?

That is a good point - we didn't get into some of the more "specialty" tanks for species like pipes/seahorses. I agree, for the more fragile smaller species like that, a 40 breeder is probably the best choice.
In my opinion, a 6 foot tank is good for tangs that reach 10-12 inches long. There are a few Acanthurus that commonly pass this, and all of the common Naso species. 8 feet can handle the Acanthurus, with 10 feet needed for smaller Naso and the larger species needing 12'.
A 12x4x3 tank would be beautiful for the larger tangs - it would allow you to keep nearly anything you wanted. There is always an exception to the rule, though.


I agree wholeheartedly about the 120 gallon - but I think a 180 is more versatile than a 210 for a few major reasons, like the height-width ratio, and 30" being a bit deep for many to comfortably work in.


Thanks for the input - is that because of the fish you want to keep, or because you simply wish you had more length of tank to work with?

Well, I would like more room for more rock, different kind of aquascaping, I could of done a island at the end or something and yes, more fish and bigger fish! I almost got a 90g thank goodness I got my 120g love it. Next tank will be a 180 or 220 if its a deal down the road ;)
 
I like the 125 gallon (72 x 18 x 21) that’s always been my favorite tank size. When I had fresh water tank I got one on Craigslist for $100 with over flow. I was able to get a new one when my tank cracked on a Sunday morning for $400 new. It’s a 6 ft tank and it’s cheap and readily available. I can keep tangs and I can reach the bottom to clean with no problem.

If you don’t have the space for a 6ft tank then
Go for a 55 gallon that’s also very cheap. You can get a new one at the $1 a gallon sale for $55
Last would be the 40 breeder that’s a great size tank and you can get it everywhere cheap.
 
Personally, I don't think there is a "perfect size", as there are too many variables that goes into what size tank you can get.

I will say, I think the best size overall is a 40 gal breeder - there is a reason this size is the hobby standard. This tank balances water volume, equipment needs and stocking capabilities. Tanks smaller than this do not significantly reduce the investment cost at the same ratio they reduce your stocking options. However, this tank does have its stocking options. So perfect size for apartments and smaller homes or for those who want in the hobby but have limited cash flow.

So, if you can go a foot bigger, can afford bigger and have more space for bigger, the 90 gallon is my all time favorite. I have had a 90 gallon for over 10 years and I have a 110 gallon now (same footprint but taller). I love my 110, but maintenance makes it less than perfect as you cannot physically reach the bottom. Based on the height rule, one should stick to the 75 gallon, 48x18x18. Personally, I do not think 4-ft tanks look good capped at 18" height, so I default back to the 90 gallon. Again, the extra height on the 110 makes a statement, but at an expense of not being perfect. The 90 it is. Unfortunately at this size, you still have some fish stocking limits, namely the tang. So...

If you can up your price a few more thousand and have the space for the 6-ft tanks, the 180 gallon monster is the "perfect" tank IMO. You get the 6-ft tank that better accommodates the higher prized fish, you get the 24" width that accommodates the best aquascaping and you get the 24" height that I personally think is the "best height". I cannot say this is the perfect tank as the capital cost to purchases, equip and stock this tank are steep. Above 180, I think the costs and maintenance needs outweighs the gains.

So I offer this phased answer that gives you a perfect tank size for the 3-ft tanks (40gB), 4-ft tanks (90g) and 6-ft tanks (180g). Of the 3, I think the 90 is my overall favorite, but short of perfect. The 40gB is the overall best as it allows the hobby to be more inclusive.

Btw, I completely disagree that the height must be smaller than the tank width. You do have to be creative on the aquascaping and I find its best to not count on that extra height for stocking options. It think modern equipment regarding in tank flow makes the air exchange argument moot. Not really debating as much as just proving another data point on opinions.
 
I think a Golden rule no matter what - is that the height should be no more than the width. That allows for good aquascaping, and the best gas exchange as well
Drew

From an aesthetics standpoint (and my opinion) I 100% disagree :)
A taller tank (more tall than it is wide) to me visually looks better. Yes you lose light penetration to the bottom, it’s more difficult to work on/reach bottom, aquascaping is more difficult, and you increase water volume without increasing real estate for fish and coral... but it jus looks better.

When my 125 blew out (it was brand new with just water and sand, luckily), the only way I was going to do another one was if it was bigger and better. I contemplated between a 180 (72X24X24) and a 210 (72X24 X30). In the end I chose the 210, and I’m glad I did. Landscaping was really not an issue (I used rods and epoxy to hold rocks together and stacked them high). The par on my sandbed is lower, but there is plenty of high par spots on the rock work, and the lower par at the sandbd opens up possibilities for LPS and softies. Maintenance is more challenging, but with a pik -stick, an array of rods, tubes, pipes, and hoses, and a step ladder I make it work. If your armpits aren’t wet, you’re not reefing :)
 
My first serious reef tank was 90 gallons 36x24x24. I think this is the perfect and almost universally fitting size. Fits most homes or apts. even bedrooms. I think this is the biggest you can go before substantially increasing equipment costs. Large enough for most reef safe fish but you might catch some heat if you put a tang in. 10% water changes only require 2 jugs of saltwater. Sump pricing is reasonable within these dimensions. Doesn't require an expensive return pump. Doesn't require high powered circulation pumps. Finally, most smaller/cost effective skimmers will be more than adequate to filter this system.

When I upgraded to a 150g I noticed how much more money I had to spend to have sufficient, lighting, flow, and filtration. Plus it forced me to make my own saltwater in house (which is not a bad thing actually) vs getting it from my LFS.
 
hi I had a 6*2*2ft for yrs, than went to an 8*2*2. They both set the room off and were predominantly tangs and mixed corals. If I were to do another tank I think it would be 6*1.5*2.5 . This would give me enough water for stability, reduce my current water changes , allow for heaps of light on the bottom and allow enough space under the tank for equipment. I currently have 2 rock towers in my 8ft a wider base would be more practical with this type of aquascape
 
I personally like the 48x24x24. Right at 120 gallons and gives me plenty of room for aquascape. I'm new to this hobby so take it with a grain of Fiji pink:)
 
I have had a 6x2x2 for quite few years. If i were to upgrade i would definitely go for a 6(l)x3(w)x2(h)
 
My largest aquarium is a 225 gallon and is 6' long, 30" tall, and 24" wide. I wish it were 2' longer and 30" wide.
So.... to me a 375 gallon aquarium would be the perfect size, but I bought my 225 at a closing sale for nearly wholesale price so I can't complain! LOL!
 
I have a deep dimensions 250 gal. It’s 5’x3’x28” (LxWxH). It’s good. But wishing I would have went with the 300 gallon that is 6’ long. But my halides/led/T-5 lights were sized for a 4’ tank and they work perfectly. I bought a sea swirl for the return and gyre for flow. Upgraded from a 65 gal (great tank size too). Stability is amazing and the flow in a bigger tank really seems natural compared to flow in a small tank. More laminar and better imitates flow on a real reef. My next build will be 11.5’x5’x3’ (LxWxH) and I cannot wait!
 
My ideal dimension is 78 x 32 x 24 (or 200cm x 80 cm x 60cm). Elos Diamond Line 200XL is precisely this size but the price is exorbitant.
I think the tank longer than 2m would make it difficult for smaller fish to show their presence and charm and extra depth will open so much possibility for creative and dynamic aquascaping and sense of space.
Personally, I am not a fan of "cube" style tank although it seems to be getting more popular. Not much open space for fish to swim freely and scaping possibility will be limited. But they are good for a themed tank or to display specific species.
 
honestly I'd be happy with a 65g or 75g cube. I don't see myself getting anything bigger personally. I love how you can create a sense of depth with a cube
 
I chose a 90g. When I switched from a 36g bowfront FW to SW, at first I chose a 75 figuring it was large enough to have a decent reef and keep a the fish I wanted without breaking the bank, but before I even got it set up I saw a 90g and liked the extra height for viewing and extra water volume for stability, so the 75g went up on Craigslist. Truth be known though, I suppose if I was more experienced and had the space & the budget, I would choose a 180g.
 
For me 72” L x 30” W x 24” D(224 gal), but I will settle for 72” L x 24” W x 24” D(180 gal) or 72” L x 24” W x 20” D(150 gal) . The largest reef fish I keep are yellow tang size. I currently have a 90(48x18x24), just doesn’t have enough room for the amount of rock I have and the corals I have. They don’t have room to grow.
 
IMO a reef tank should never be taller than it is deep (front to back) . Aquascaping and accounting for coral growth is just hard when they are not deep enough. Most people don’t go higher than 24 as well. Just too hard to get your arms in and clean the tank. 30” is about the most the average reefer will go in height but you will have to be able to access the front and back of the tank.

I agree that the tank should visually look as deep as it is tall but water distorts that so in an ideal world the real dimensions should have the tank be about 2/3rds as tall as it is deap. However the larger tank manufactures haven’t provided a lot of options like that in reasonably sized tanks.

That said.

40 breeder for a small/mid size tank. Water change is a single 5 gallon bucket. This is a solid tank that fits many busy lifestyles.

120 . Fits standard 4 foot lighting and most equipment for this size is reasonably priced. 120 is just a lot nicer than a 90 or 75 and once everything is added up doesn’t cost much more because the equipment needs are not all that different. Weight is also low enough for most home environments.

180 - the extra 2 feet matter for larger fish and a visual appeal of movement, aquascapes are almost always better. However costs are much higher in a variety of ways. Also pushing the weight barriers of many homes (depending on placement).

After that you are getting into most people’s dream tank sizes but they are not just expensive to build and fill with corals but can be a lot of work. I know a lot of people find a 96” x 36 x 24-30 to be a pretty solid dream ;)
 
Last edited:
As someone relatively new to marine aquaria and one who prefers a more 'natural' tank, I think the minimum tank size would be 120 gallons. That appears to be close to the minimum size to keep an interesting variety of livestock and fish that help to maintain the tank by controlling pests and algae.

As for dimensions, I'd prefer one no deeper than the length of my forearm plus tongs/alligator forceps (I finally found elbow length exam gloves on Amazon). More length front to back allows for more interesting aquascaping.
 
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
IMO a reef tank should never be taller than it is deep (front to back) . Aquascaping and accounting for coral growth is just hard when they are not deep enough. Most people don’t go higher than 24 as well. Just too hard to get your arms in and clean the tank. 30” is about the most the average reefer will go in height but you will have to be able to access the front and back of the tank.

I agree that the tank should visually look as deep as it is tall but water distorts that so in an ideal world the real dimensions should have the tank be about 2/3rds as tall as it is deap. However the larger tank manufactures haven’t provided a lot of options like that in reasonably sized tanks.

That said.

40 breeder for a small/mid size tank. Water change is a single 5 gallon bucket. This is a solid tank that fits many busy lifestyles.

120 . Fits standard 4 foot lighting and most equipment for this size is reasonably priced. 120 is just a lot nicer than a 90 or 75 and once everything is added up doesn’t cost much more because the equipment needs are not all that different. Weight is also low enough for most home environments.

180 - the extra 2 feet matter for larger fish and a visual appeal of movement, aquascapes are almost always better. However costs are much higher in a variety of ways. Also pushing the weight barriers of many homes (depending on placement).

After that you are getting into most people’s dream tank sizes but they are not just expensive to build and fill with corals but can be a lot of work. I know a lot of people find a 96” x 36 x 24-30 to be a pretty solid dream ;)

Is there an off the shelf option at 96x36x 24-30? Or are we talking about custom tanks since the price jumps rather quickly.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top