What is "dull" anyways?

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Total: 0, Members: 0, Guests: 0)

uniquecorals

UniqueCorals
View Badges
Joined
Nov 23, 2006
Messages
13,377
Reaction score
11,088
Location
Los Angeles
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I'm getting ready to set up a small, freshwater "hardscape" tank in my office.

13_1aquarium_ada60cm_fishtank.jpg

This is what I'm planning on recreating...Dull? Not to me.

Yeah, freshwater. Why not? And I'm thinking of populating this aquarium with some really grey or silver-colored fishes. Very monotone; kinda "Zen", sort of.

Grey? Dull? Hmm..made me think...I've spoken of this thing I have for seemingly "bland" animals before, and I realized today it's a real aesthetic "stance" I take sometimes. Weird.

Why do I like small , grey fishes? Why do I covet corals that most people find rather uninteresting? Why do I get excited about great Sarcophyton, Acropora yongei, and Fungia specimens way more than I do about many other corals? Do I not get out enough? Am I too cool to jump on the bandwagon of new Chalices? Or, could it simply be that, after several decades in the hobby- I’ve learned to be honest with myself about what I like? Hmm…is there a lesson here? Or even a blog? Does something have to be rare and crazy looking to be worthy of our keeping it? Let’s see…

I get to see a lot of corals and fishes in my day-to-day work- a lot of really rare stuff. I don’t care how long you’ve been in the hobby or worked in the aquatics industry- when a new livestock shipment arrives and it’s time to break out the box cutters, even the most crusty fish person still gets a kind of giddy excitement, anticipating what is in the box.Just like on your birthday!

Not too long ago, I was in our warehouse when a shipment arrived from one of our guys in Australia. I hung around watching the crew open up the boxes to see what was coming in. I opened one one of the boxes, not reading the manifest attached to it. Wonder what was inside? "Masterpiece" Scolys? Insane Yellow and Blue Tabling Millies? "A" Grade Acans? No, this time, it was a box of Green Sarcophyton leathers. Sarcophyton? Really? The “bread and butter”, ultra “common” staples of the reef hobby.

Yawn.

Actually, I wasn’t yawning. They were beautiful. I was admiring these brightly colored gems in their bags, and considering what brought them here. Just a few days earlier, these little corals were happily located somewhere in their native Great Barrier Reef, photosynthesizing away like their ancestors had done for eons before them. I wondered what they faced now. What was their destiny? Who would end up buying them? What size aquarium would they spend the rest of their lives in? Would they be kept in proper conditions, or would they slowly waste away and die? I felt a bit of guilt. I mean, they were collected in accordance with some of the strictest laws in the world, by people I know truly care about the well being of the reefs. Yet, the fact is, they were hacked off a wild reef. These are animals that are easily propagated in captivity..That's part of our mission. I was a bit depressed for a second, then it dawned upon me that we would be using some of these for brood stock, so that we WON'T have to take hundreds more off the GBR in the future. Nonethelss, it made me think about our awesome role as both hobbyists and stewards of the wild reefs. Serious stuff.. Do we ever think about this?

Was I being overly sentimental? Stupidly self-righteous? Maybe. But I was contemplating; just for a second- how easy it is to take for granted what has become “common” to us. These corals are popular in the aquarium hobby for a reason: They are beautiful, not trendy. Yet, they are interesting creatures. They are precious, regardless of the price tag- and they are worthy of our respect and admiration. They need not be expensive and flashy to be worthy of our admiration, do they? Just because we can get them all the time doesn't make them any less enjoyable or worthy of our efforts.

GREEN TOADSTOOL-MAR 16.jpg

Just because it's common doesn't mean that it isn't cool!

Which brings me back to fish. What about the not-so-crazy-looking ones? Who loves the grey fishes? Maybe more people than we think.


To further compound my theory, I need only Google into a freshwater hobby forum, and admire the (very grey!) fishes sometimes coveted by our friends in the FW world. I saw pics of “Tanganyika Lampeyes” not too long ago. Okay, on the surface, these grayish Rift Lake killifish are about as unexciting (is that a word?) as a fish can get- a poster child for the freshwater “haters”…But wait a minute. Have you ever even seen one? Probably not that often. Probably because they are rather…well, bland, and collectors toss ‘em back. But man- that’s what’s so cool about them, right? They are different! Subtle. Imagine how awesome they’d look as contrasting players in a tank full of colorful African Cichlids!

procatopus_nototaenia_1.jpg

Grey, yet compelling, if you ask me...The Tanganyika Lampeye.

Think about the humble “Blue Streak Cardinalfish” Apogon leptocanthus. This little Indo Pacific fish looks for all the world like a kind of dull freshwater Tetra from the Amazon, yet it’s a 100% marine…Subtly colored, yet somehow compelling. It sold out really fast when we used to receive them as "Eco Labeled" fishes from Papua New Guinea. In fact, I had plenty of "call me" rain checks for even a handful of them. Why? I don’t know. I mean, why is a “Pokerstar Monti” so hot? It's pretty dull, if you ask me. But that's the charm. To each his own, I suppose. Could it be that we really, truly love the creatures of the sea for what they are?

Apogon leptacanthus Threadfin cardinalfish.jpg

Get in line...This Cardinalfish is a hot commodity...if you can find one.

I believe we do!

The beauty of the hobby is that there really IS room for all sorts of fishes and inverts. Seems like pretty much every animal out there gets at least some love from the reef masses! And that's a really good thing, I think. Admit it- you’ve occasionally stared longingly at a browned-out Acro and wondered, right? There's some magic in there, huh? You’ve contemplated purchasing that grey-brown blenny with the cute eyes and cirri before, huh? You may have even owned a Scopas Tang once!

I would love to hear about YOUR predilection for the common. The seemingly dull. The "mundane."

2012-08-02 05.17.19.jpg

Dull, maybe. But I know more than a few reefers who keep 'em...The much maligned Scopas.

There is hope for the hobby after all…Long live the dull!

Who loves the grey fishes; the "common" corals?

We all do.

Something to ponder on a Monday.

Until next time…

Stay Wet.

Scott Fellman
Unique Corals
 
Last edited:
I was actually thinking about dull corals the other day and I do have a few. I have two really old Rics that likely came from Haiti when the ban on Florida Rics was is place. The one is a solid, weakly fluorescent green (looks like a small carpet anemone) and the other is a near solid steel blue. I also have a D. carlgreni that won't take home any trophies for color, but I still find it a weirdly interesting 'Shroom:

Discosomacalgreni_031514_zpse8a74b48.jpg


They aren't eye-poppers by any means, but they all have history :)
 
This is another great read Scott. I once received "thats a dull choice" for recommending a Bangaii or a pajama cardinal to a beginning reefer asking for help choosing fish. I find them fascinating and if people saw them in the wild how Bangaii hang out between spines of urchins they would be amazed and intrigued. I have a pair of CB Bangaiis that literally "hang out" in my water column. I absolutely adore them...
Likewise (and as you know) when it can time to choose a pair of clowns after viewing all the lovely designer choices; I went with the good old tank bred Ocellaris…… As you said - to each his own…. but i find it easy to find incredible beauty in simplicity…. BUT I am human… and many times go for the bling bling…LOL...
 
I was actually thinking about dull corals the other day and I do have a few. I have two really old Rics that likely came from Haiti when the ban on Florida Rics was is place. The one is a solid, weakly fluorescent green (looks like a small carpet anemone) and the other is a near solid steel blue. I also have a D. carlgreni that won't take home any trophies for color, but I still find it a weirdly interesting 'Shroom:

Discosomacalgreni_031514_zpse8a74b48.jpg


They aren't eye-poppers by any means, but they all have history :)

I think that's actually very cool-looking!
 
We need to avoid mistaking what's "hot" for what's beautiful. Being common in and of itself doesn't make something ugly or dull.

Take my scooter dragonet, for example. Readily available. And brown. Who wants that? Guess what? I think she's gorgeous. Very cool patterning if you look closely - and she acts so darned cute!
 
Cardinals are one of my favorite fish, and I can't get enough of green slimmer. Once my tank is up that may be one of the dominant players in the tank.
 
I was actually thinking about dull corals the other day and I do have a few. I have two really old Rics that likely came from Haiti when the ban on Florida Rics was is place. The one is a solid, weakly fluorescent green (looks like a small carpet anemone) and the other is a near solid steel blue. I also have a D. carlgreni that won't take home any trophies for color, but I still find it a weirdly interesting 'Shroom:

Discosomacalgreni_031514_zpse8a74b48.jpg


They aren't eye-poppers by any means, but they all have history :)
That is definitely a show stopper!!!
 
That is definitely a show stopper!!!

LOL, thanks, Darwin.

This'll blow your mind. The 'Shroom started off a few years ago without any maroon whatsoever. Is it trying to camouflage itself by matching the coralline algae on the LR? (joking, but who knows?)

Or is it possibly incorporating symbiotic Cyanobacteria? (not unheard of in corals as it occurs in Montastrea cavernosa and possibly Fungia granulosa juveniles). Still a lot we don't fully understand...
 
Last edited:
Good article. This is my Tanganyikan killie (lamprichthys tanganicanus). Your pic is of a procatopus sp. Neither are dull in my opiniion.
 
Scott I know an awesome tank mate to go with your killie's, try a L264 pleco. Absolutely gorgeous but won't take away from the killie. Everyone with a freshwater tank should have a L-number!
 
Well since you are doing a freshie tank in the office, I suppose you should just ship your corals to me, so I can find them loving caring home away from the dull saltless office. All kidding aside, I am not a fan of fresh water. Pwehaps I have some salt snobbery, but I want bright obsene color pop that smashes you in the face first thing in the morning.
 
Good article. This is my Tanganyikan killie (lamprichthys tanganicanus). Your pic is of a procatopus sp. Neither are dull in my opiniion.

I have to warn you that many killies (not all) have a lifespan of only a year, but can be bred for successive generations.
 
I was actually thinking about dull corals the other day and I do have a few. I have two really old Rics that likely came from Haiti when the ban on Florida Rics was is place. The one is a solid, weakly fluorescent green (looks like a small carpet anemone) and the other is a near solid steel blue. I also have a D. carlgreni that won't take home any trophies for color, but I still find it a weirdly interesting 'Shroom:

Discosomacalgreni_031514_zpse8a74b48.jpg



They aren't eye-poppers by any means, but they all have history :)

Actually, those look kinda sweet!

-Scott
 
This is another great read Scott. I once received "thats a dull choice" for recommending a Bangaii or a pajama cardinal to a beginning reefer asking for help choosing fish. I find them fascinating and if people saw them in the wild how Bangaii hang out between spines of urchins they would be amazed and intrigued. I have a pair of CB Bangaiis that literally "hang out" in my water column. I absolutely adore them...
Likewise (and as you know) when it can time to choose a pair of clowns after viewing all the lovely designer choices; I went with the good old tank bred Ocellaris…… As you said - to each his own…. but i find it easy to find incredible beauty in simplicity…. BUT I am human… and many times go for the bling bling…LOL...

So true...But you bring up a cool point, Barbara: If you display even a "dull" fish in context (such as the Banggais in a seagrass/urchin biotope), you suddenly create something that just "works", right?

-Scott
 
We need to avoid mistaking what's "hot" for what's beautiful. Being common in and of itself doesn't make something ugly or dull.

Take my scooter dragonet, for example. Readily available. And brown. Who wants that? Guess what? I think she's gorgeous. Very cool patterning if you look closely - and she acts so darned cute!

But you know what? A healthy and happy Scooter is a pretty cool fish that everyone seems to love! because "healthy" and "happy" are not a given with this species!

-Scott
 
Good article. This is my Tanganyikan killie (lamprichthys tanganicanus). Your pic is of a procatopus sp. Neither are dull in my opiniion.

LOL, you're right...Good pickup! Still a fish I love! In fact, I was looking at some Medaka the other day...not the "gold" variety, either...LOL

-Scott
 
Scott I know an awesome tank mate to go with your killie's, try a L264 pleco. Absolutely gorgeous but won't take away from the killie. Everyone with a freshwater tank should have a L-number!

That would be pretty sweet, actually! How large do these L number guys get? I must admit I also covet the Chocolate Guarami!

Chocolate Gourami.jpg


-Scott
 
Well since you are doing a freshie tank in the office, I suppose you should just ship your corals to me, so I can find them loving caring home away from the dull saltless office. All kidding aside, I am not a fan of fresh water. Pwehaps I have some salt snobbery, but I want bright obsene color pop that smashes you in the face first thing in the morning.

No, I hear ya...I get a few of those now and then...

1andhalfinch-bloodshot-acans-with-babies-88.jpg
 
I have to warn you that many killies (not all) have a lifespan of only a year, but can be bred for successive generations.

Yup...sadly...I've kept and bred many killies over the years...I did like Epiplatys species; I had a few live pretty long live spans...On the other hands, I recall Cynolebias that looked "elderly" after just 2 months...craziness.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top