What is this critter?

Double J

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Oct 25, 2015
Messages
307
Reaction score
88
Location
Iowa
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
IMG_1479656380.197453.jpg
IMG_1479656391.089834.jpg

Anyone know what this is? I thought I had gotten some star polyps with some zoas, but last night they were on the top rock and now down a rock and visibly moving.
IMG_1479656500.620678.jpg

It looks like a slug kinda.
Thanks
 
You never know what they eat:eek:
id bet that one eats zoas.
It looks like its fluorescing. That and rather than a split in the tentacles down the back its a solid cluster.
Id pull the frags into a lttle "hospital" if you can, heat rock powered and get ready to dip. youll want to look for the spiral egg clusters on the polyps.
 
Thanks all! I grabbed him out of the tank. Too bad he was kinda neat looking, but I have noticed one set of zoas disappearing and melting away, may have been this little guy
 
Thanks all! I grabbed him out of the tank. Too bad he was kinda neat looking, but I have noticed one set of zoas disappearing and melting away, may have been this little guy
its the babies.
 
Pulled my zoas and dipped them, I dipped them before they went in the tank, but maybe not long enough? I have some baby starfish in one and they aren't too happy after the dip. I was able to get them out of the frag. I will attach a picture
 
IMG_1479668681.014918.jpg

Here they are, 2 of them. 3 legs a heart shaped middle. Brown legs have stripes. Good or bad?
 
Pulled my zoas and dipped them, I dipped them before they went in the tank, but maybe not long enough? I have some baby starfish in one and they aren't too happy after the dip. I was able to get them out of the frag. I will attach a picture
Dips won't impact most eggs so that is how many pests get through.

I really need to stop procrastinating and set up a frag QT. :(
 
Sorry, I got threads mixed up and I thought you just bought something.

The eggs are nasty and stick all over the tweezers when you remove them.
 
Hmmm... there's a lot of things "getting through" dips these days.....



Totally agree.
were not doing it right anymore. Dip qt, dip again. qt. dip DT. Same process to get rid of the nudis. but you can do it in the tank. 8 to 16 day life/egg hatch cycle I do believe ime. If you see an adult on the glass or rocks, it just laid eggs.
They like announce that you haven't won the war just yet.:D
(or they leave the colony to die or not compete with the babies)
 
all good. what dip did you use
revive, should i get something else? and continue to dip? I know which frags it was on and unfortunately one was a goner and i pulled it out last night. should i keep dipping the other one, and how often?
Thanks, my other zoas still look great, for now.
 
revive, should i get something else? and continue to dip? I know which frags it was on and unfortunately one was a goner and i pulled it out last night. should i keep dipping the other one, and how often?
Thanks, my other zoas still look great, for now.
no, you have to go slow. the dips are a pretty aggressive treatment so you should space them far apart imo. try to keep the zoas where you can see them and maybe look for a good magnifying glass. (I have like 12, cuz im a nerd)
keep an eye out for adults, use a baster to make the zoas close and look for babies and the egg swirls. its a bummer, but your waiting for the eggs to hatch and then kill them. that's about 8 to 16 days ime.

did the stars survive? revive is mild enough that some inverts do make it through,that's good and bad of course. the theory on dips is the larger animals like coral can take it more than the small ones.
 
no, you have to go slow. the dips are a pretty aggressive treatment so you should space them far apart imo. try to keep the zoas where you can see them and maybe look for a good magnifying glass. (I have like 12, cuz im a nerd)
keep an eye out for adults, use a baster to make the zoas close and look for babies and the egg swirls. its a bummer, but your waiting for the eggs to hatch and then kill them. that's about 8 to 16 days ime.

did the stars survive? revive is mild enough that some inverts do make it through,that's good and bad of course. the theory on dips is the larger animals like coral can take it more than the small ones.
watched them for about 10 minutes, then back in the tank and saw one about an hour later moving, but they went into hiding. is coral rx any better then revive? I see it is a doorbuster at brs, as well as there ro/di systems. getting ready to pull the trigger on a ro/di and can add in the coral rx if it is better.

also as far as the other frag goes, it hasnt opened up for a few day maybe up to a week, should i consider it gone and just pull it for the greater cause? I dont have a frag qt yet, and main qt is at full therapeutic copper levels.

looking on the furum it seems that peppermint shrimp might eat these nudibuchs? can anyone confirm this?
 
Last edited:
watched them for about 10 minutes, then back in the tank and saw one about an hour later moving, but they went into hiding. is coral rx any better then revive? I see it is a doorbuster at brs, as well as there ro/di systems. getting ready to pull the trigger on a ro/di and can add in the coral rx if it is better.

also as far as the other frag goes, it hasnt opened up for a few day maybe up to a week, should i consider it gone and just pull it for the greater cause? I dont have a frag qt yet, and main qt is at full therapeutic copper levels.

looking on the furum it seems that peppermint shrimp might eat these nudibuchs? can anyone confirm this?
honestly in my only somewhat scientific comparisons experience it doesn't matter. Ive used diluted peroxide too.
yea some nudis may be indiscriminate eaters possibly some snails poss shrimps imo. def many wrasses. Side note(not lecture) this is why we should dip coral as one guy may have predators and not even know he has zoa eaters, or flatworms etc.

no may as well jus eyeball the sick colony and see what happens. give it more light maybe see if it recovers. poss a reaction to the dip.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top