Where is all the info on sponges at?

Ever kept a sponge?


  • Total voters
    60
I had about 20 lbs of LR from KP aquatics, so I am hoping it will seed my cryptic zone. When I first received the rock it had all types of sponges on it. In addition I have some small clams/scallops that seem to be multiplying in my cryptic zone. I also dose phytoplankton that I culture myself.

Much like Paul, I will get sponge nearly everywhere that the light does not shine. Even if it takes a while to get going, it will take off after a while. Mostly green and white in the shadows, but in the low light areas, I get some nice oranges and yellows. This is from a 13 month old tank... took this long for the sponge to start to grow...
Screen Shot 2020-06-19 at 4.22.26 PM.png
 
@KenO thank you, yeah the article said you really can't overdose but I suppose too much of anything is bad, most if not all of the silica is used up within 4 days.
If you overdose you will get diatoms. Cut back and the diatoms will disappear. I’m now getting the brown algae/diatoms on my glass vs the green algae like Randy described in his article. I noticed 100’s of baby snails and limpets all over my glass in the mornings feeding on the brown algae.
 
Much like Paul, I will get sponge nearly everywhere that the light does not shine. Even if it takes a while to get going, it will take off after a while. Mostly green and white in the shadows, but in the low light areas, I get some nice oranges and yellows. This is from a 13 month old tank... took this long for the sponge to start to grow...
Screen Shot 2020-06-19 at 4.22.26 PM.png
Nice.
Most of my rock in the cryptic zone has been in one of my tanks for 3+ years. I’m seeing clear/white sponges and some reddish ones.
 
Steve Tyree has a couple books out talking about sponges in his "Zonal" filtration methodology. I can't imagine a reef system running any length of time without growing cryptic sponges which are essential for recycling labile DOC in a system. There is a black sponge that can be invasive but even that shold be controlable using stainless steel straws with a siphon to remove it. Locally there's an orange/yellow sponge that seems to like growing around palies and will choke them out but it seems to leave other corals alone but it's easily siphoned out. As far as keeping the "ornamental" species like finger or tree or ridge sponges you might need to identify the species and search it's needs (scholar.google.com)
 
Below my cryptic zone I have a RDSB. After feeding my fish I rinse the cup above the RDSB. I also have a roller mat device on the water feed line to the 40 breeder that holds the cryptic zone and RDSB. I turn it off for a couple of hours each day and let the stuff floating in the tank settle out on the sand of the RDSB. Here’s a video showing the life that emerges from the sand. The RDSB was setup and seeded mid April 2020 with bacteria, pods and worms from IPSF.com.
 
Below my cryptic zone I have a RDSB. After feeding my fish I rinse the cup above the RDSB. I also have a roller mat device on the water feed line to the 40 breeder that holds the cryptic zone and RDSB. I turn it off for a couple of hours each day and let the stuff floating in the tank settle out on the sand of the RDSB. Here’s a video showing the life that emerges from the sand. The RDSB was setup and seeded mid April 2020 with bacteria, pods and worms from IPSF.com.
i'm waiting to order from them, but did you get more then just bristle worms for worms? i want some tube worms, not dusters. getting microfauna seems to be difficult recently, without grabbing a bucket full of sand from the ocean
 
Generally I am also all for sponges but on reefbuilders, jake guy does point out some negatives of sponges. Do a search and enter sponge on that website and you can read his articles on the bads. NoWadays, we do get most of our live rock from the Caribbean’s and not for Asia so when we mix Indoasia corals with Caribbean sponges, unforeseen issues may arise.
 
Generally I am also all for sponges but on reefbuilders, jake guy does point out some negatives of sponges. Do a search and enter sponge on that website and you can read his articles on the bads. NoWadays, we do get most of our live rock from the Caribbean’s and not for Asia so when we mix Indoasia corals with Caribbean sponges, unforeseen issues may arise.
i read both articles and it seems like he's upset sponge is in his tank... the same way corals that do well in tank will warfare with other corals, sponge can overcrowd a coral? some sponges have toxins? but so do a lot of corals. in that sense sponges and corals have a lot of the same cons, personally a lot of the points he made don't really make sense to me or relay any sort of turn off from sponges. going off both articles it feels like a sponge bias to me. stating that with mechanical filtration nowadays why use sponges, that's silly (r2r appropriate). it feels like people want to skimmer this and UV that so that their tank is so sterile they can eat out of it.
 
Jake also made a point on one of his articles on corraline algae( many types)about at one point, it will compete with your corals and fauna on the water columns’ minerals, etc. I do appreciate his point of views though which may be valid and only through studies can his point of view be validated....after all he is a marine science major and long time reefer
 
Jake also made a point on one of his articles on corraline algae( many types)about at one point, it will compete with your corals and fauna on the water columns’ minerals, etc. I do appreciate his point of views though which may be valid and only through studies can his point of view be validated....after all he is a marine science major and long time reefer
of course, he always makes good content. but i'm not surprised with that coralline fact, everything in the box of water is trying to one up the other
 
i'm waiting to order from them, but did you get more then just bristle worms for worms? i want some tube worms, not dusters. getting microfauna seems to be difficult recently, without grabbing a bucket full of sand from the ocean
I got the diversity worm pack.
 
Generally I am also all for sponges but on reefbuilders, jake guy does point out some negatives of sponges. Do a search and enter sponge on that website and you can read his articles on the bads. NoWadays, we do get most of our live rock from the Caribbean’s and not for Asia so when we mix Indoasia corals with Caribbean sponges, unforeseen issues may arise.
We mix all types of critters in our tanks from all parts of the world. It seems like everything in the ocean has evolved to wage chemical warfare on everything else. If you think of it that way, you would never put anything in your tank.
 
All exposed surfaces in my 6' reef are covered in sponge. Excellent water conditioners and will grow depending on the microscope food available but I never directly feed them.
They will clear my tank of cloudy clam juice in minutes.
This is an encrusting photosynthetic sponge (I forgot the name.)

Blue Photo Sponge. Collospongia Auris. I have it and it is beautiful. Grows like a Monti cap and can be easily removed when it gets too big.

 
That is a cool looking sponge. Did you put it in the tank?
 
If you ever have to remove some, I’d be interested in get a piece.
 
If you ever have to remove some, I’d be interested in get a piece.
I’m in the Dallas area if you are close. This sponge is not like the normal sponge you typically get in your tank. It feels like leather and can be exposed to air with no issue.
 
Jake also made a point on one of his articles on corraline algae( many types)about at one point, it will compete with your corals and fauna on the water columns’ minerals, etc. I do appreciate his point of views though which may be valid and only through studies can his point of view be validated....after all he is a marine science major and long time reefer

Well, he needs to read up a little more, me thinks. de Geoij's research back in '07 - '08 on sponges (which blew away the scientific community showing some sponges have a mitosis rate [cell splitting] of 8 hours but don't grow) demonstrated how critical cryptic sponges are. With their ability to remove labile DOC (carbon dosing) 1000 times faster than bacterioplankton they're essential for healthy reef systems.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top