Which tank looks better overall ?

[Maxcmo]

I am waiting for my Frag 105.4 any day now. I originally wanted the Marine X 110 then settled for this one at the end. Cant go wrong either way except the Frag tank will definitely be easier to work in but harder to scape up very tall but the scape on this one you have posted looks great can't ask for much more...

 

[DeniseAndy]

I like the dimensions of the second one and the cleaner look. I think it will depend on the fish. My fish like the upper open water a lot. If you get those that stay low, the first one is nice too.

 

[JJSins]

I am waiting for my Frag 105.4 any day now. I originally wanted the Marine X 110 then settled for this one at the end. Cant go wrong either way except the Frag tank will definitely be easier to work in but harder to scape up very tall but the scape on this one you have posted looks great can't ask for much more...

Agreed, I think it has a cleaner look.

 

[JCM]

Definitely option 2 in my opinion. 16" is too short for a 4' main display in my opinion, especially when overall aesthetics in the home are important. Great for a frag tank, but not well balanced enough to be a main tank.