Without this fish your saltwater aquarium is not complete..

How much do what fish you have in your tank matter to you?

  • I take my fish selection VERY carefully.

    Votes: 517 74.8%
  • I just focus on a few of my favorites and don't care much for the rest.

    Votes: 94 13.6%
  • I just choose fish on a feeling or a whim.

    Votes: 55 8.0%
  • Whatever fish are the cheapest.

    Votes: 6 0.9%
  • No fish for me in my aquarium.

    Votes: 4 0.6%
  • Other (please explain)

    Votes: 15 2.2%

  • Total voters
    691
I will only put tank bred livestock, and aqua cultured corals in my tank even if it means some fish are not available to me.
Primarily because I wont have a hobby that damaged natural coral reefs. I would be no better than the fox hunters or game keepers then.

It also has the advantage that you get less pests, hardier fish and in some cases even less fussy eaters.
I insist that nothing goes in my tank if it came from the ocean, must be at least F1, preferably F2+ if available. Some species are becoming quite rare in the wild, and the capture process can be quite stressful for the fish when taken from the wild.
 
Diamond Goby: amazing for cleanliness, coral health, and - in my case - being the total boss of the tank.
PXL_20210321_205735300.PORTRAIT-01.COVER.jpg

Almost forgot a photo of muh boy
 
After waiting tankless for 25 years, I promised myself that I would have to have the following:
Purple tang
Flame angel and
Flame hawk

I now have the first two, looking for a hawk!!!
We had a flame hawk and got rid of it as it ate our shrimp and small gobies. Loved his look and quirky personality though. But we insist on a Bully- less tank
 
I only have a betta and future addition of catfish tank. Though if I do get into saltwater it would be tank bred clownfish and anemones.
 
1. Yellow Tang. Colorful, active and continually nibbles at algae to keep the tank clean.
2. Golden Head Sleeper Gobie. Tirelessly turns over the substrate to keep it clean and you've got to love the pearl white body and bright yellow head.
 
I am currently waiting for my tank to mature and when it does will be adding a Dragonet(probably Red). I do have a question though, will it be ok with a blue streak goby or will I have to remove him?
 
I’m really hoping to find a shrimp/goby pair. They’re the coolest.

It is cool, but after having a pair, I would only see the pistol shrimp maybe once every few weeks and that was with his burrow facing the front. I always thought that had built its hole in the back, then I'd never even see it. And the watchman is cool, but always hiding. Now that I just moved my 40 gallon to a 125, I find that my stocking list is all open water swimmers :D

I guess my two most iconic for me are the clown and yellow tang, which figures now that I have a big enough tank for a yellow they are hundreds of dollars, if you can find one at all... going to settle on a Tomini I think instead.
 
None of my tanks would be complete without firefish. Second runner up would be clownfish or watchman goby
Firefish, pair of clowns, wheeler's goby with companion tiger pistol shrimp. We think alike.
 
I give very careful consideration to fish in my tank.
I would say my jewel is my purple tang.
20210504_201549.jpg


I don't really have a second favourite, my coral beauty is a good character, but I've had my clownfish about 5 years, so have a real soft spot for them.
 
Lol, I don’t think that is a fair question to ask.

Personally, I HAVE to have my inverts. They bring me the most joy. Some actual fish (puffers) I would really really love in my tank, but I love my inverts too much to do that to them. I like gobies and semi-cryptic aquatic life. I also love my hitchhiker freaks.
AB834ECC-6E8B-4821-A808-7914E8BCB46F.jpeg
21242289-30C3-416F-9AC0-11FF0F3D437E.jpeg
AEC10FB8-DE57-468F-BF08-2189C770D37E.jpeg
99E3903A-A0DA-4CF5-A36F-08A318F8BB60.jpeg
7D9B0824-B503-465B-B8DC-057948E712AD.jpeg
0C7C895E-2F43-4397-A5CE-0DB32D41234D.jpeg
5C760FA3-8F12-4329-812B-5E204491C61E.jpeg
1090B0D6-50F4-4347-A590-0B60A56504B2.jpeg
CF0B2D4E-67CF-433A-9C93-CCBED04182C0.jpeg
958AE18E-6857-4E84-9FBA-FFA49ABE8766.jpeg
1D4360CD-B11B-4AC4-B450-162D6240ECC0.jpeg
6BA24A1D-D094-4B06-BA3F-22A23E163412.jpeg
958A552C-1F95-4B57-9509-BF3F4289F90B.jpeg
F6E3137B-6A90-4880-A5F8-A763A572DD23.jpeg
5445CE71-068E-4EB6-8EC7-E7539F41B840.jpeg
2568C5F8-6E56-41A0-BB9E-D96D26E35A66.jpeg
04459915-EFFC-495B-8212-2E8744311CAC.jpeg
672B816B-23A8-4602-94B4-B4F25B041FD2.jpeg
47B3B406-1B5F-4A3A-B0D8-94740AF9152A.jpeg
AA7F6730-8AD7-40E0-9E04-1EAEC523C999.jpeg
E4B241AC-8B84-4F72-A22C-5857274CFE86.jpeg
75FD3B6C-77A0-4C56-B61C-97819C7761AE.jpeg
C2BA025A-6B54-4C4F-B980-7CB047E7DBAE.jpeg
E9E2E33B-C3F9-4651-B530-49AFA5FBB3EE.jpeg
DAC9302B-0D2B-4878-8F61-670A06E4C976.jpeg
AD7600F9-C4BE-4FB6-BE70-F15499ADB1B2.jpeg
292C6296-89C4-4BB8-83AA-8F56EBDC9DD6.jpeg
16C3EA70-2544-4647-A998-5D1871CA5F22.jpeg
4E209BEB-B452-4BC5-ABB3-A42C4AC3E6FC.jpeg
73C47987-27AE-4628-9FBD-25FF4BDA9BA7.jpeg
EB810C13-C898-4A06-9A63-A3E8B061D5E9.jpeg
1F4C249D-615E-49E4-899D-6F74FA770840.jpeg
82F3A920-9BC9-4B54-9628-3B70D8F5C600.jpeg
A10DDD8F-2C82-439E-83C6-89E3FD3B393A.jpeg
E4C428E1-F0B2-4B65-A202-AE569CBFC0FC.jpeg
4773F071-5001-45FB-8176-88ECAD57461D.jpeg
E43CEAA7-5FD9-478A-A642-48172A087194.jpeg
B5C8A117-6090-4FE0-BE11-08C8E97D2B2D.jpeg
192A2479-76AA-4FA2-AB89-442FEAC18FCB.jpeg
EBF80BBA-A09E-45EF-8551-0BC2E464E332.jpeg
F9513C11-6681-411C-B131-351B89FF1C70.jpeg
655333C6-B910-4244-BB2C-2F1CA0AACC99.jpeg
F70BD9C9-48C3-4FD3-8A31-3CFD1729978E.jpeg
5F1AF572-3B69-44A2-B28B-BAC05D481F83.jpeg
E876143F-86AE-4204-B804-8DA165FC4A52.jpeg
C076A3D8-6F5B-44FF-A09F-7A67E638F37C.jpeg
D264C3B8-11EE-4592-ADD1-FC91EB5B5A61.jpeg
Before my tanks big crash I had 2 Griessingei Gobies, I named them Waldo and Carmen San Diego.

I really really miss my eel. Never went after my sexy shrimp, never bit, never tried to escape.

I have attached pictures of some of the life I have really loved in my tank and managed to get photos of.
 
My aquarium is currently empty while cycling, but here is my fish wish list:

couple clownfish (of course)
banggai cardinalfish
royal gramma
hawkfish
fire angle
cole tang
yellow coris wrasse
 
Firefish. Red of Helfrichi. I much prefer the Helfrichi but the wallet doesn't. I can't think of a sinlgle tank that I have kept that didn't have a red firefish in it.

One fish I will NEVER own again? Clownfish of any kind.
 
I have a tiny little 5 gallon tall reef, keeping a fish wouldn’t be ethical imo. However, I love all blennies and would love a blenny focused tank someday. They have so much personality and are such fun little buggers, would love to have a bunch and maybe even breed ‘em! They’re not the most colorful (usually) but they have more personality than any other fish I know.
I totally agree with you! Love my Benny. So fun to watch
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top