$50,000 tank giveaway! Disappointed!!

I can agree with the OP to an extent. They could have pulled names from a the tank or something instead of having a list already made up. WWC draws names on video to show it is in fact truly random in their live sale contests. A bit more transparency would have went a long way.

And Carl, their buddy, they gave a prize to, because well he works on their fire extinguishers and help out?? That is not random by any means and is actually favoritism.
I can understand your issues with transparency. Do you know how much time and resources it would take to print off and draw from 40k names? Does the lottery draw your tickets out of a hat? Let's be real please.

Is favoritism illegal? Is rewarding a colleague illegal? How about bonuses for your employees? Are those illegal?

I really don't think it's fair to criticize a company's actions, especially when it pertains to free items or giveaways.

If I owned a company I'd love to reward people who did a good job. It was never expressly stated that all prizes were random. Only the 20k tank.
 
I can understand your issues with transparency. Do you know how much time and resources it would take to print off and draw from 40k names? Does the lottery draw your tickets out of a hat? Let's be real please.

Is favoritism illegal? Is rewarding a colleague illegal? How about bonuses for your employees? Are those illegal?

I really don't think it's fair to criticize a company's actions, especially when it pertains to free items or giveaways.

If I owned a company I'd love to reward people who did a good job. It was never expressly stated that all prizes were random. Only the 20k tank.


It’s not illegal to hook up a buddy but perhaps doing it during a contest wasn’t the best time. They can hook him up anytime he is at their store.
 
The reason for the post was just to vent a little. I couldn’t remember the exact details but thought it was weird they announced their buddy winning. Just made me think what else could be a setup? Maybe a few calls to dummy phones to build suspense? Then the winner isn’t even excited? I was expecting someone to scream and freak the hell out! But everyone is different I suppose.

Also thank you @revhtree clearing up my mistakes on the OP. For whatever reason I thought it was 50k .

Just to be clear I have nothing against BRS and am not upset at all. I agree with many of the posts on here. Just would have liked to seen a drawing instead of just calling people. Probably not worth make a post about but to late now. Hope everyone has a great weekend.
 
Wow how can you get mad at them? No good deed goes unpunished. I like the way they did it. The suspense was great

All I can say is the team here had a blast giving away a ton of stuff. I am so happy that we reached out to all the vendors, worldwide corals and Reef2Reef to make this happen. Reading the comments on both the feeds and everywhere else was overwhelmingly positive and it just seemed like a fun event for a vast majority of those who took part. I do have a few comments to some of the feedback that has been shared here.

1) We did use a random generator to select 20 potential winners for the tank contest and put them in order on a sheet which I called from.
2) The orders we chose to refund was not a contest in any way. It was just a fun thing to do which publicly recognized a couple of people who have been engaging with reefers on the #askbrstv community, a customer who not only comes in a lot but is also helping us with fish for the BRS/WWC hybrid series and someone who helped me personally get past the struggles with my first tank like 15 years ago. This is all positive and fun.
3) The random gear, fishing worms, tee shirts and fun stuff we decided to hand out I thought was also fun, we just let Frank pick a random person from a comment feed that was coming in fast and furious. This again wasn't designed to be a contest, just a free hand out like shooting tee shirts at screaming fans at a ball game.

I almost never let the 1% of negativity get me down but I got to say this time it is kinda disappointing. Win or not a lot of us felt like this was a really fun event and I certainly hope that is the prevailing opinion in the end. I realize if it was up to others they would have a slightly different rule set and after doing it for the first time here I would make some additional fun improvements for the future as well.

Last night we all left the shop to have beers, live in the moment and cheers to how we could do something even more amazing next year. Step one is make sure @revhtree is here to celebrate and take part of the giveaway with us. That was certainly the biggest miss of the year! :)
 
Last edited:
Yeah, I thought they were going to use the hour before the drawing to push the products they were giving away as free advertisement. There was no overview from the products they were giving away (other than the video earlier this month), even the guy from WWC didn't step in and put a plug in for his company, they just had fun for a half hour giving away random stuff, then gave someone a dream tank. No complaints from me. But from an advertising stand point, they probably could have done more with the captive audience they had.

LOL :) Like you said who wants to watch an hour-long commercial. It was just time to have some fun!
 
Yeah I didnt know I needed to be around a phone at a time. Im dang glad they didnt call me I would be ****** because I was working and didnt have my phone cause I didnt know I needed it. Well it is what it is im not worst off then I was before other then seeing people complain about payments and bills they choice to get in their life. It would had been nice to know more ahead of time how it was going to work. i thought a random drawing as well.

It stated that it was going to require you to answer the phone when you signed up for the contest.
 
All I can say is the team here had a blast giving away a ton of stuff. I am so happy that we reached out to all the vendors, worldwide corals and Reef2Reef to make this happen. Reading the comments on both the feeds and everywhere else was overwhelmingly positive and it just seemed like a fun event for a vast majority of those who took part. I do have a few comments to some of the feedback that has been shared here.

1) We did use a random generator to select 20 potential winners for the tank contest and put them in order on a sheet which I called from.
2) The orders we chose to refund was not a contest in any way. It was just a fun thing to do which publicly recognized a couple of people who have been engaging with reefers on the #askbrstv community, a customer who not only comes in a lot but is also helping us with fish for the BRS/WWC hybrid series and someone who helped me personally get past the struggles with my first tank like 15 years ago. This is all positive and fun.
3) The random gear, fishing worms, tee shirts and fun stuff we decided to hand out I thought was also fun, we just let Frank pick a random person from a comment feed that was coming in fast and furious. This again wasn't designed to be a contest, just a free hand out like shooting tee shirts at screaming fans at a ball game.

I almost never let the 1% of negativity get me down but I got to say this time it is kinda disappointing. Win or not a lot of us felt like this was a really fun event and I certainly hope that is the prevailing opinion in the end. I realize if it was up to others they would have a slightly different rule set and after doing it for the first time here I would make some additional fun improvements for the future as well.

Last night we all left the shop to have beers, live in the moment and cheers to how we could do something even more amazing next year. Step one is make sure @revhtree is here to celebrate and take part of the giveaway with us. That was certainly the biggest miss of the year! :)

@Ryanbrs

don't ever apologize. you guys are awesome, I've had a million questions since I got into this hobby. Some of which were repeated, and every day I have about 20 questions that I would like to ask.

So don't ever apologize for giving away something free.
 
I almost never let the 1% of negativity get me down but I got to say this time it is kinda disappointing. Win or not a lot of us felt like this was a really fun event and I certainly hope that is the prevailing opinion in the end. I realize if it was up to others they would have a slightly different rule set and after doing it for the first time here I would make some additional fun improvements for the future as well.

No, no no, just no. This is a forum on the internet. A well moderated one, but it's still a forum on the internet. No matter what you do you will NEVER make everybody happy. You guys ran a good contest, it was advertised well all over the SW fish community and 40K person participation is nothing to scoff at.

I know you often takes things personally when things don't go well for one reason or another as you have expressed so in multiple videos multiple times. Every accusation levied against you was already dis-proven without you even saying a word. The winner came here and stood up and said "it was me and I had no idea what was going on".

Continue pleasing the 99% and realize the 1% will never be attainable. Between the videos, weekly giveaway, info...etc....some people really have some nerve and very little appreciation for how much BRS has helped the SW fish community.

(Side Note: Please add an East Coast Warehouse so I can order more from you guys and less from a different distributor who has an ATL warehouse and gets me things in 2 days. )
 
I almost never let the 1% of negativity get me down but I got to say this time it is kinda disappointing.

Don't listen to the haters! Some people live to be disgruntled!

BRS has been a huge part of me getting into the reefing side of the hobby, your staff has been amazingly supportive and informative in helping me decide on equipment and helping with questions as I get my Reefer 350 up and running. You guys are awesome!
 
it was fun to watch and hope that certain people dont ruin any upcoming things that brs and reef2reef may have planned. if his number got dialed he would love the way everything was done. keep on doing what your doing brs because you have plenty of support from the rest of the 99.9% of us.
 
All I can say is the team here had a blast giving away a ton of stuff. I am so happy that we reached out to all the vendors, worldwide corals and Reef2Reef to make this happen. Reading the comments on both the feeds and everywhere else was overwhelmingly positive and it just seemed like a fun event for a vast majority of those who took part. I do have a few comments to some of the feedback that has been shared here.

1) We did use a random generator to select 20 potential winners for the tank contest and put them in order on a sheet which I called from.
2) The orders we chose to refund was not a contest in any way. It was just a fun thing to do which publicly recognized a couple of people who have been engaging with reefers on the #askbrstv community, a customer who not only comes in a lot but is also helping us with fish for the BRS/WWC hybrid series and someone who helped me personally get past the struggles with my first tank like 15 years ago. This is all positive and fun.
3) The random gear, fishing worms, tee shirts and fun stuff we decided to hand out I thought was also fun, we just let Frank pick a random person from a comment feed that was coming in fast and furious. This again wasn't designed to be a contest, just a free hand out like shooting tee shirts at screaming fans at a ball game.

I almost never let the 1% of negativity get me down but I got to say this time it is kinda disappointing. Win or not a lot of us felt like this was a really fun event and I certainly hope that is the prevailing opinion in the end. I realize if it was up to others they would have a slightly different rule set and after doing it for the first time here I would make some additional fun improvements for the future as well.

Last night we all left the shop to have beers, live in the moment and cheers to how we could do something even more amazing next year. Step one is make sure @revhtree is here to celebrate and take part of the giveaway with us. That was certainly the biggest miss of the year! :)
Ryan it was a lot of fun watching you guys and I want to make it VERY clear you and your team at BRS do an amazing job. I was watching the stream on my way home from work and probably missed some key points that were said about the giveaway. all the post was meant for was to talk bring up some thoughts I had and they have all been answered/cleared up.

Thank you for all the work you guys do to help us out. hope you have a great weekend!!!
 
it was fun to watch and hope that certain people dont ruin any upcoming things that brs and reef2reef may have planned. if his number got dialed he would love the way everything was done. keep on doing what your doing brs because you have plenty of support from the rest of the 99.9% of us.
all i said was i wish there was a actual drawing instead of preselected names on a paper. Not trying to ruin anything just talking on a forum!
 
I feel like the negative attitude about this is going to pretty much seal the deal about any future give aways on R2R. I certainly hope not. It's a shame that Brett can read any of this. I'm happy for him.
what negative attitudes? the OP was not negative at all just a open discussion. did something i say offend you? should we talk about it ;)
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top